1. Search
  2. Pick a Restaurant
  3. Build Your Meal
  4. → Order & Eat!
  • Pay with a credit card, PayPal, or cash at the door.
  • Tip online.
  • 24/7 Customer Care.
  • Free to use.
  • Get text updates about your order.
  • Saves your payment info.
  • Remembers your special instructions.
  • Saves your addresses.

Build your meal by clicking whatever sounds good.

Plenty Cafe Menu

Trending Items

Suggested Meals

    • $10.45 Veggie Sandwich Add Extra Chipotle Mayo
    • $4.00 Chocolate Mousse
    • $2.95 Boylan's Seltzer Lemon Seltzer
    • $2.95 Boylan's Mash Drink Pomegranate
    • $2.85 Iced Coffee Large
    • $10.35 Caesar Salad Dressing Mixed In, Add Extra Tomatoes
    • $1.50 Poland Spring Water
    • $5.75 Mocha Large, Add Extra Single Shot of Espresso
    • $5.75 Flourless Chocolate Cake
    • $2.95 San Pellegrino Regular San Pellegrino
  • Popular Items

    • Iced Cappuccino $3.75+
    • Iced Coffee $2.35+
    • Fresh Squeezed Orange Juice $3.50
    • Cookie $3.00
    • Homemade Oreos $3.50
    • Bacon, Egg and Cheese on a Biscuit $8.25
    • Plenty's Very Own Granola with Yogurt $7.00
    • Cheesy Egg Breakfast Sandwich $7.50 Scrambled eggs and Vermont cheddar on a rustic roll with mixed greens option.
    • Veggie Sandwich $9.95 Avocado, Vermont sharp cheddar, mixed greens, sweet potato, tomato and chipotle mayo on seven grain bread.
    • Smoked Turkey Sandwich $9.95 With avocado, mayo, lettuce and tomato on a baguette.
  • Daily Specials

    • Chicken and Avocado with Bacon Sandwich $11.45 Served on a french roll with lettuce, tomato and mayo.
    • Side Order of Potato Pancakes $5.75 Five pancakes. Served with sour cream.
    • Turkey Chili $6.75
    • Side Order of Curried Chicken Salad $6.50
    • Side Order of Chunky Chicken Salad $6.50
    • Marble Pound Cake $3.50
    • Whole Cakes $48.00
    • Vanilla and Chocolate Cake $5.50
    • Mini Chocolate Peanut Butter Cake $5.50
    • Chocolate Mousse $4.00
    • Tiramisu Slice $6.00
    • Lo-Carb Lasagna $13.50 Vegan and gluten free.
    • Israeli Couscous $5.75 Served with roasted tomatoes and balsamic reduction.
    • Chunky Veggie Soup $6.00
    • Side Order of Tuna Salad $6.50
    • Crunchy Nutella Macaroon Sandwich Cookie $3.50 Two crunchy coconut macaroons with a layer of Nutella spread in the middle. Gluten free.
    • Classic Crumb Cake $3.00
    • Flourless Chocolate Cake $5.75 Gluten free.
    • Mini Snickers Cake $5.50
    • Slice of Apple Pie $4.50
    • White Chocolate Mousse $4.00
    • Linzer Tarts $4.50
  • Beverages

    • Coffee $1.90+
    • Latte $3.50+
    • Cappuccino $3.50+
    • Cafe au Lait $2.25+
    • Macchiato $2.00+
    • Espresso $1.75+
    • Hot Chocolate $3.50+
    • Hot Tea $1.50+
    • Iced Cappuccino $3.75+
    • Iced Coffee $2.35+
    • Iced Latte $3.75+
    • Tall Glass of Milk $1.75
    • Soy Milk $2.50
    • House Made Iced Tea $2.50+
    • House Made Lemonade $3.50+
    • Half and Half $3.25+
    • Fresh Squeezed Orange Juice $3.50
    • Mocha $3.75+
    • Boylan's Mash Drink $2.95
    • Boylan's Soda $2.95
    • Boylan's Seltzer $2.95
    • San Pellegrino $2.95
    • Poland Spring Water $1.50
    • Large Bottled Soda $2.50
    • Vitamin Water $2.69
    • Gus's Soda $2.50
    • Martinelli's Apple Juice $2.95
    • Snapple $2.50
  • Breakfast

    • All Day Breakfast Eggs $7.50 Eggs served any style with toasted country bread and mixed greens option.
    • Cheesy Egg Breakfast Sandwich $7.50 Scrambled eggs and Vermont cheddar on a rustic roll with mixed greens option.
    • Plenty's Very Own Granola with Yogurt $7.00
    • Pastry Basket $10.50 A sampling of Plenty's freshly baked goodies.
    • Peanut Butter and Jelly on 7-Grain Toast $4.95
    • Peanut Butter, Jelly and Banana on 7-Grain Toast $5.50
    • Toasted Ham and Cheese on a Biscuit $6.50
    • Ham and Cheese Croissant $4.95
    • Bacon, Egg and Cheese on a Biscuit $8.25
    • Bacon and Cheese on a Biscuit $6.75 A warm and toasted sandwich with melted cheddar cheese and crispy bacon.
    • Greek Yogurt with Plenty's Homemade Granola $8.00
    • Greek Yogurt with Plenty's Homemade Granola and Berries $9.50
    • Quiche $8.75 Homemade spinach and Gruyere quiche. Served with a mixed green salad. Vegetarian.
  • Soup

    • Soup of the Day $5.75 Please contact Plenty at (212) 628-2110 for soup of the day selection. Enter your choice in the special instructions box below.
  • Salads

    • House Salad $9.00 Mixed greens, tomato and cucumber with vinaigrette.
    • Grilled Chicken Salad $10.95 Grilled chicken breast, mixed greens, tomato and cucumber with vinaigrette.
    • Chopped Chicken Salad $11.25 Grilled chicken breast, cucumber, feta, tomatoes, chickpeas and croutons with balsamic vinaigrette.
    • Chinese Chicken Salad $11.25 Grilled chicken breast with wonton crisps, snap peas and orange sections with miso sesame dressing.
    • Caesar Salad $9.85 Romaine lettuce, house-made croutons and Parmesan cheese with Caesar dressing.
    • Chicken Caesar Salad $10.95 Grilled chicken breast, romaine lettuce, house-made croutons and Parmesan cheese with Caesar dressing.
    • Greek Salad $9.85 Feta cheese, cucumber, tomato, red onion and black olives with red wine vinaigrette.
    • Curried Chicken Salad $10.95 A scoop of our house made curried chicken salad atop of our house salad.
    • Scoop of Tuna Salad $10.95 Our tuna is made with dill, chopped tomato and lemon mayo. Served atop our house salad.
    • Veggie Sandwich as a Salad $11.50 Mixed greens topped with sweet potato, avocado, almonds, tomato, cucumber and cheddar cheese with balsamic vinaigrette dressing.
    • Scoop of Chunky Chicken Salad $10.95 With green apples, dried cranberries and pecans on mixed greens with tomato and cucumbers with balsamic vinaigrette.
    • Kale Caesar Salad $9.95
    • Chicken Kale Caesar Salad $11.50
    • Fresh Roasted Salmon Salad $14.50 With romaine, tomatoes, cucumbers, and sugar snap peas with dijon vinaigrette.
  • Sandwiches

    • Grilled Chicken Breast Sandwich $9.95 With tomato, watercress and chipotle aioli on ciabatta bread.
    • Smoked Turkey Sandwich $9.95 With avocado, mayo, lettuce and tomato on a baguette.
    • Veggie Sandwich $9.95 Avocado, Vermont sharp cheddar, mixed greens, sweet potato, tomato and chipotle mayo on seven grain bread.
    • Tuna Salad Sandwich $9.95 Dill, lettuce and tomato on a baguette.
    • Tomato and Mozzarella Sandwich $9.95 With balsamic vinaigrette on a crunchy baguette.
    • Black Forest Ham and Brie Sandwich $9.50 Whole grain mustard and cornichons on a baguette.
    • Curried Chicken Salad Sandwich $9.95 Raisins, almond and curry mayo on a ciabatta roll.
    • Turkey Meatloaf Sandwich $11.75 Plenty's special sauce, lettuce, tomato and pickles on a baguette.
    • House-Made Roast Beef Sandwich $10.50 With caramelized onions and horseradish aioli on a baguette.
    • Warm Meatball Hero $11.50 Choice of meatballs with housemade tomato sauce and melted mozzarella cheese on a warm french roll.
    • Peanut Butter and Jelly on 7-Grain Toast $4.95
    • Peanut Butter, Jelly and Banana on 7-Grain Toast $5.50
    • Chunky Chicken Salad Sandwich $10.00 With green apples, dried cranberries and pecans on a French roll.
    • Chicken and Avocado Sandwich $9.95 Grilled chicken breast with avocado, lettuce and tomato. Served on a baguette with mayo.
    • Tuna Melt $10.00 Our homemade tuna served with melted cheddar cheese.
    • Bacon, Lettuce and Tomato on a Toasted Baguette $8.50 With mayo.
    • Bacon, Lettuce, Tomato and Avocado on a Toasted Baguette $9.50 With mayo.
    • Chicken, Bacon and Avocado Sandwich $11.45 Grilled chicken breast with bacon, avocado, lettuce and tomato. Served on a baguette with mayo.
    • Fresh Roasted Salmon BLT $13.95 With bacon, tomato salsa, crunchy romaine on toasted ciabatta.
  • Hot From Our Kitchen

    • Warm Meatball Plate $13.50 Choice of meatballs served with mixed greens and toasted country bread.
    • Lasagna Bolognese $14.50 Choice of style served with a mixed green salad and a country roll.
    • Eggplant Parmesan Plate $14.50 Served with mixed greens.
    • Fried Chicken Plate $17.50 Served with choice of side and mixed green salad.
    • Macaroni and Cheese $11.50 Creamy macaroni and cheese served with a mixed green salad and choice of side.
    • Fried Chicken with a Side of Mac and Cheese $18.50
    • Warm Chicken Schnitzel Sandwich $12.50 Breaded chicken breast with melted Swiss cheese, roasted red peppers, crunchy romaine and chipotle aioli on a toasted hero roll.
    • Warm Chicken Parmesan Sandwich $12.50 Breaded chicken breast with homemade marinara sauce and melted mozzarella cheese on a toasted hero roll.
    • Hot Eggplant Parmesan Hero $12.50 With house made tomato sauce and melted mozzarella cheese on a warm hero.
    • Quiche $8.75 Homemade spinach and Gruyere quiche. Served with a mixed green salad. Vegetarian.
  • Side Orders

    • Side Order of Mac and Cheese $6.50
    • Side Order of Curried Chicken Salad $6.50 Chunks of chicken breast with cashews, raisins and chutney.
    • Side Order of Tuna Salad $6.50
    • Side Order of Chunky Chicken Salad $6.50 Chunks of white meat chicken with dried cranberries, pecans and green apples.
    • Side Order of Mixed Greens $4.00
  • Bakery

    • Cookie $3.00
    • Brownie $3.00
    • Croissant $2.75
    • Chocolate Croissant $3.25
    • Almond Croissant $4.00
    • Chocolate Almond Croissant $4.15
    • Slice of Golden Vanilla Cake $5.25 With fudge frosting.
    • Slice of Chocolate Cake $5.25 With chocolate butter cream and fudge cream.
    • Slice of Red Velvet Cake $5.25 With cream cheese frosting.
    • Slice of Carrot Cake $5.25 With cream cheese frosting.
    • Slice of Banana Cake $5.25 With whipped Nutella frosting.
    • Slice of Coconut Cake $5.25 With coconut butter cream and coconut flakes.
    • Muffin $3.10
    • Banana Walnut Bread $3.00
    • Homemade Oreos $3.50
    • Strawberry Cheesecake $5.50
    • Salted Caramel Cheesecake $5.50
    • Oreo Cheesecake $5.50
    • Buttermilk Biscuit $2.50
    • Individual Homemade Banana Cream Pie $5.00
    • Individual Homemade Key Lime Pie $5.00
    • Cornbread $2.50
    • Zucchini Bread $3.00
    • Chocolate Chocolate Chubbies $3.35

Build your meal by clicking whatever sounds good.

Plenty Cafe Menu

Start a Group Order

Name Your Group Order

266 Ratings

"The vegetable lasagna was full of flavor, with fresh vegetables a … See more. "

156 Reviews Hide Reviews

Close
Plenty Cafe

Plenty Cafe

GrubHub reviews in your neighborhood

  • “I order from here almost every day when I'm at work. Everything is great. Love their sandwiches and baked dessert goodies. Solid espresso drinks.”

    Patrick

    6 reviews and 0 orders
  • “This place will be the death of me! Amazing baked goods, esp. the chocolate cake with "fudgy frosting." Chicken tenders are the best I've had -- not the usual greasy strips but big chunks in crispy, flavorful batter. Meatball platter is delicious, too. Everything is just really fresh and good in that homemade way. The ONLY items that aren't great are the salads--actually, just the dressings. Odd flavors, even for basics like Caesar and vinaigrette. Figures that the healthy stuff would be a miss!”

    J

    1 reviews and 0 orders
  • “For those with a sweet tooth this is the place for the best desserts! Awesome cakes and cookies especially the coconut cake and chubbie cookies.”

    Stephanie

    4 reviews and 0 orders
  • “Love this place! Where else can you get Illy cappuccino, expertly made? True, the prices on their goodies are higher than Hot and Crusty, but this place is the real deal - homemade taste and extremely high quality. Better than Eli's a few doors down. Savory hot food is also great.”

    Stephanie

    1 reviews and 0 orders
  • “The biscuits here are out of this world. And the homemade oreos are pure sugary heaven. Trust me.”

    Ashley

    12 reviews and 0 orders
  • “I love this place, everything tastes good and no hassles with the delivery. This is how food delivery should be.”

    Sangita

    4 reviews and 0 orders
  • “Great biscuits and baked goods. A bit pricey. I don't think it's the most healthy stuff, to say the least: very tasty but I often feel a bit bloated after! We have ordered from Plenty many times. Interestingly, we have experienced many mistakes in the orders. They send biscuits with the wrong breakfast ingredients, or one less OJ's than we ordered. It's rare in NY to experience delivery mistakes, in my twenty years in Manhattan. Oddly, Plenty seems to make many. Management, if you're reading this, please be more careful? Thanks.”

    Steven

    2 reviews and 0 orders
  • “This place is the best ! Always quality food. Just expect a little wait on the weekends, but it's worth it.”

    Gina

    1 reviews and 0 orders
  • “One of my favorite places on the UES. I order from here all the time. The cheesy egg sandwiches are my favorite (try one on a biscuit instead of a roll). And the desserts are simply yummy. Especially the key line pie which is the best I've had, and I'm very particular about my key lime pie! The salads and the sandwiches are good, too. There are a couple of food items that don't live up to Plenty's usually high quality - the fried chicken plate and the meatloaf sandwich among them. Also, the macaroni and cheese plate is good, but there are better on the UES. While this isn't the cheapest restaurant, I find the quality of food to be worth the price. I've always had pretty quick service meaning the food is hot and fresh when it arrives. The couple of times they've been out of something I've ordered, they've called and offered to switch it out with something else (and at no additional charge if what I switched it with is more expensive than the original item). Bottom line, I order from Seamless all the time, and I always find myself going back to Plenty because the food and service quality is consistently great. ”

    Jillian

    1 reviews and 0 orders
  • “Today my breakfast came and my large iced coffee arrived sideways and completely spilled in the bottom of the bag. After calling, and being transferred to what I thought was a manager, I explained that the entire order was destroyed and the black coffee had dripped all over my very expensive rug. The women said in an extremely rude manner, "well, what would you like me to do about it- I know it was not packed that way." Forgive me if I was expecting a bit of empathy as it was not just the food that was destroyed. I called back and asked for the manager and when she got on the phone I tried to confirm it was indeed a manager, and she then claimed to be the owner. Shocked that someone would run their business with this extreme lack of customer service I told her I would contact seamless for a credit and that I would never order again. To that she said, "be my guest."”

    dana

    3 reviews and 0 orders
  • “Easily one of my favorite (and most ordered from!) places on Seamless. Everything I've had here is out of this world and extremely fresh. My personal favorite is the simple yet delicious mozzarella and tomato sandwich and Key Lime pie!”

    Charlie

    3 reviews and 0 orders
  • “The food is always fresh and the delivery is usually very prompt. I order from here at least once a week. ”

    Katherine

    4 reviews and 0 orders
  • “Plenty is a great place for delivery. The Bacon, Egg, and Cheese Biscuit is delicious. My favorite part is their clever packaging. Everything comes delivered clean, compact, warm/hot, and ready to go. Delivery has always been fast for me too. (UPDATE: 8/8/2014 Lost a star due to today's order taking 100 mins for delivery. When I called the restaurant, the woman hung up on me. Not good service today.”

    Matthew

    5 reviews and 0 orders
  • “Everything is fresh and made very well - everything is delicious ”

    Douglas

    1 reviews and 0 orders
  • “Honestly, the food isn't the best I've ever had but for some reason I find myself ordering from here multiple times a week. Can't go wrong with the smoked turkey sandwich and a chocolate chubbie”

    Amanda

    1 reviews and 0 orders
  • “Marble pound cake was insanely delicious, but fried chicken was burnt, and not worth the cost. Also had very little flavor. Mac and cheese was good, and the portions were ample. All of the baked goods I've had from this place have been very good. ”

    Evan

    8 reviews and 0 orders
  • “Finally, a place that sells a fresh & delicious slice of basic chocolate cake! (Oh, and everything else is great too.)”

    Alka

    5 reviews and 0 orders
  • “I love this place. They have everything and it's all homemade and delicious. I love the baked goods especially. One time they were out of a baked item and I got a very friendly phone call with alternate ideas. ”

    Alyssa

    1 reviews and 0 orders
  • “Food is amazing! Why don't you offer vegetable sides though? ”

    Henry

    4 reviews and 0 orders
  • “My fiance and I have loved this place since we moved to the UES. We always get their turkey chili and curry chicken salad. We have a routine of going every Sunday before we make the trek to fairway for our weeks groceries. However, lately we have been boycotting Plenty and I will explain why. When I buy something at Plenty I am okay with paying a higher price because I know the food will taste amazing. But lately when we go on Sunday they are out of basically everything. Instead of getting the delicious warm biscuit with your soup you get a small piece of whole grain bread. Instead of a nice hearty green salad with your sandwich you get chopped iceberg lettuce with no vegetables. I understand restaurants run out of things, but then give your customers something equivalent or don't charge them the same price for your food. I don't mind paying $$ for good quality food, but when you run out of that food you should supplement it with someone just as good. Side note, the front counter needs more staff. The one person at the front is always drowning with answering the phone, giving people water, taking orders, running to the back to get food and general confusion. It has been this way since it opened and hasn't gotten better. Hopefully, we will return to plenty and see that things have changed. I do miss my turkey chili and curry chicken salad. ”

    Suzanne

    1 reviews and 0 orders
  • “The only seamless review I have ever made... Plenty is By far my favorite seamless place to order from. Fresh & made with care. I have been to the restaurant in person and know it is clean- which is a huge thing for me living in NYC. Can't believe it doesn't have 5 stars considering some of the other restaurants that actually have 5 stars are beyond gross (like awful diners ect). Fresh baked treats.. I love the Caesar salad with chicken and the chicken sandwich with a side salad and sub the mayo for mustard.. Plenty is so delicious! ”

    alexandra

    1 reviews and 0 orders
  • “Everything fro Plenty is always delish!!! Donuts are fab! i recomend the ham and cheese buscuit , meatball sub and tuna sandwhich. The marble pound cake is also amazing”

    Alexis

    2 reviews and 0 orders
  • “pastries are very good. Shame all sandwiches come loaded with salad instead of what you're supposed to be paying for! Chicken bacon avocado sandwich came with one slice of bacon and 2 slices of avocado, half a slice of tomato and loads and loads of salad.”

    Anne

    2 reviews and 0 orders
  • “Plenty's breakfast selection is limited, but what they make, they make better than all their competitors. Plus, the cookies and mini pies are to die for!”

    Alexandra

    5 reviews and 0 orders
  • “Fresh and always delicious! Great addition to the neighborhood ”

    Jodi

    2 reviews and 0 orders
  • “Wow. Bacon egg and cheese on a biscuit is one of the best I've ever had. The food is incredibly fresh and obviously homemade. ”

    Elisabeth

    8 reviews and 0 orders
  • “Very good food, but third time order was incorrect. Too bad, but I would avoid. ”

    Jason

    2 reviews and 0 orders
  • “Sometimes this place is very good. But often times they don't pay attention to what you write in special instructions. I type in - no mini pickles - and they put mini pickles on the sandwich. Then my husband won't eat it. Sometimes they read the instructions and sometimes they don't. Generally we like this place-but it's annoying when your food comes wrong & you don't have time to let them re-make it.”

    Jill

    26 reviews and 0 orders
  • “I never fail to be impressed by the things I get from Plenty. ”

    Claudia

    3 reviews and 0 orders
  • “Plenty's fried chicken is AMAZING. Always arrives fast and piping hot (and freakin' delicious). Do yourself a favor and order some. ”

    Ryan

    8 reviews and 0 orders

Full Hours, Cuisines, More Info... Hide Extra Info

Close

Plenty Cafe Delivery

Sandwiches, Healthy, Salads, Breakfast, Bakery, Lunch, Dinner

Hours

  • Monday 7:30 AM - 9:30 PM
  • Tuesday 7:30 AM - 9:30 PM
  • Wednesday 7:30 AM - 9:30 PM
  • Thursday 7:30 AM - 9:30 PM
  • Friday 7:30 AM - 9:30 PM
  • Saturday 7:30 AM - 9:30 PM
  • Sunday 7:30 AM - 9:30 PM

917-791-5057

1457 3rd Ave New York, NY

Thursday

Open Now

7:30 AM - 9:30 PM

Delivery

Delivery Free

Minimum $ 12.00

Pickup

Show map