1. Search
  2. Pick a Restaurant
  3. Build Your Meal
  4. → Order & Eat!
  • Pay with a credit card, PayPal, or cash at the door.
  • Tip online.
  • 24/7 Customer Care.
  • Free to use.
  • Get text updates about your order.
  • Saves your payment info.
  • Remembers your special instructions.
  • Saves your addresses.

Build your meal by clicking whatever sounds good.

Plenty Cafe Menu

Trending Items

Suggested Meals

    • $18.50 Fried Chicken with a Side of Mac and Cheese
    • $5.25 Slice of Red Velvet Cake
    • $17.50 Fried Chicken Plate Corn Bread
    • $8.25 Bacon Egg and Cheese on a Biscuit
    • $8.25 Bacon Egg and Cheese on a Biscuit
  • Popular Items

    • Coffee $2.00+
    • Homemade Donuts $3.25
    • Bacon Egg and Cheese on a Biscuit $8.25 Available all day.
    • All Day Breakfast Eggs $7.50 Available all day. Eggs any style. Served with toasted country bread and mixed greens.
    • Cheesy Egg Breakfast Sandwich $7.50 Available all day. Scrambled eggs and Vermont cheddar cheese on a brioche roll with mixed greens.
    • Chicken and Avocado Sandwich $9.95 Grilled chicken breast with avocado, lettuce, and tomato. Served on a baugette with mayo.
    • Buttermilk Biscuit $2.75
    • Side Order of Mac and Cheese $6.50
    • Fresh Squeezed Orange Juice $3.50
    • Iced Coffee $2.50+
  • Hot Beverages

    • Coffee $2.00+
    • Latte $3.65+
    • Cappuccino $3.65+
    • Cafe au Lait $2.25+
    • Macchiato $2.00+
    • Espresso $1.75+
    • Hot Chocolate $3.50+
    • Hot Tea $1.75+
    • Mocha $3.75+
  • Cold Beverages

    • Iced Cappuccino $3.95+
    • Iced Coffee $2.50+
    • Iced Latte $3.95+
    • Tall Glass Of Milk $1.75
    • Soy Milk $2.50
    • Almond Milk $2.50
    • Housemade Iced Tea $2.50+
    • Housemade Lemonade $3.50+
    • Half and Half $3.25+
    • Fresh Squeezed Orange Juice $3.50
    • Boylan's Mash Drink $2.95
    • Boylan's Soda $2.95
    • Boylan's Seltzer $2.95
    • San Pellegrino $2.95
    • Poland Spring Water $1.50
    • Large Bottled Soda $2.75
    • Gus's Soda $2.50
    • Martinelli's Apple Juice $2.95
    • Snapple $2.50
  • Daily Specials

    • Homemade Donuts $3.25
    • Turkey Chili Topped with Cheddar Cheese (Temporarily Unavailable) $7.75
    • Mini Snickers Cake $6.50
    • Mini Chocolate Peanut Butter Cake $6.50
    • Toasted Ham and Cheese on a Baguette $9.50 It's a grown up grilled cheese. Crunchy, toasty, and melty. Super delicious.
    • Tomato and Mozzarella Salad $11.50 Mixed greens, tomato, fresh mozzarella and roasted red peppers with balsamic vinaigrette dressing.
    • Cobb Salad $11.95 Fresh roasted chicken breast, hard-boiled egg, avocado, bacon, tomatoes and cucumbers served with Dijon vinaigrette dressing.
    • Side Order of Potato Pancakes $5.95 Served with sour cream.
    • Mini Chocolate Mousse $6.50
    • Mixed Berry Muffins $3.50
    • Blueberry Muffins $3.50
    • Apple Turn Over $3.95
    • Cheese Danish $3.95
    • Fresh Fruit Salad $6.50
    • Diced Watermelon $6.50
  • Breakfast

    • All Day Breakfast Eggs $7.50 Available all day. Eggs any style. Served with toasted country bread and mixed greens.
    • Cheesy Egg Breakfast Sandwich $7.50 Available all day. Scrambled eggs and Vermont cheddar cheese on a brioche roll with mixed greens.
    • Plenty's Own Granola and Yogurt $7.00 Available all day.
    • Pastry Basket $10.50 Available all day. A sampling of Plenty's freshly baked goodies.
    • Toasted Ham and Cheese on a Biscuit $6.50 Available all day. No egg.
    • Ham and Cheese Croissant $4.95 Available all day. Sold as-is.
    • Side of Bacon $4.50 Available all day.
    • Bacon Egg and Cheese on a Biscuit $8.25 Available all day.
    • Bacon and Cheese on a Biscuit $6.75 Available all day. A warm and toasted sandwich, with melted cheddar cheese and crispy bacon. No egg.
    • Greek Yogurt with Plenty's Homemade Granola $8.00 Available all day.
    • Greek Yogurt with Plenty's Homemade Granola and Berries $9.50 Available all day.
    • Peanut Butter and Jelly on Seven Grain Toast $4.95 Available all day.
    • Peanut Butter, Jelly and Banana on Seven Grain Toast $5.50 Available all day.
    • Quiche $8.75 Available all day. Homemade spinach and Gruyere quiche. Served with a mixed green salad. Vegetarian.
  • Soup

    • Soup of the Day $5.75 Please contact Plenty at (212) 628-2110 for soup of the day selection. Enter your choice in the special instructions box below.
  • Salads

    • House Salad $9.00 Mixed greens, tomato, cucumber with vinaigrette. Dressing served on the side.
    • Grilled Chicken Salad $10.95 Grilled chicken breast, mixed greens, tomato, cucumber and vinaigrette. Dressing served on the side.
    • Chopped Chicken Salad $11.25 Grilled chicken breast, cucumber, feta, tomatoes, chickpeas, croutons and balsamic vinaigrette. Dressing served on the side.
    • Chinese Chicken Salad $11.25 Grilled chicken breast with wonton crisps, snap peas and orange sections with miso sesame dressing. Dressing served on the side.
    • Caesar Salad $9.85 Romaine lettuce, housemade croutons, Parmesan cheese and Caesar dressing. Dressing served on the side.
    • Chicken Caesar Salad $10.95 Grilled chicken breast, Romaine lettuce, housemade croutons, Parmesan cheese and Caesar dressing. Dressing served on the side.
    • Greek Salad $9.85 Feta cheese, cucumber, tomato, black olives and red wine vinaigrette. Dressing served on the side.
    • Curried Chicken Salad $10.95 A scoop of our housemade curried chicken salad atop of our house salad. Dressing served on the side.
    • Scoop of Tuna Salad $10.95 Our tuna is made with dill, chopped tomato and lemon mayo, served atop our house salad. Dressing served on the side.
    • Veggie Sandwich as a Salad $11.50 Mixed greens topped with sweet potato, avocado, almonds, tomato, cucumber, and cheddar cheese with balsamic vinaigrette dressing. Dressing served on the side.
    • Scoop of Chunky Chicken Salad $10.95 With green apples, dried cranberries and pecans on mixed greens with tomato and cucumbers with balsamic vinaigrette. Dressing served on the side.
    • Kale Caesar Salad $9.95 Dressing served on the side.
    • Kale Chicken Caesar Salad $11.50 Dressing served on the side.
    • Kale Salad with Golden Raisins and Dried Cranberries $10.50 Dressing served on the side.
    • Fresh Roasted Salmon Salad $14.50 With romaine, tomatoes, cucumbers, and sugar snap peas with Dijon vinaigrette. Dressing served on the side.
  • Sandwiches

    • Grilled Chicken Breast Sandwich $9.95 With tomato, watercress and chipotle aioli on ciabatta bread.
    • Smoked Turkey Sandwich $9.95 With avocado, mayo, lettuce and tomato on baguette.
    • Veggie Sandwich $9.95 Avocado, Vermont sharp cheddar cheese, mixed greens, sweet potato, tomato and chipotle mayo on 7 grain bread.
    • Tuna Salad Sandwich $9.95 Dill, lettuce and tomato on baguette.
    • Tomato and Mozzarella Sandwich $9.95 With balsamic vinaigrette on crunchy baguette.
    • Black Forest Ham and Brie Sandwich $9.50 With whole grain mustard and cornichons on baguette.
    • Curried Chicken Salad Sandwich $9.95 With raisins, cashews and curry mayo on a ciabatta roll.
    • Turkey Meatloaf Sandwich $11.75 With Plenty's special sauce, lettuce, tomato and pickles on baguette.
    • House-made Roast Beef Sandwich $10.50 With caramelized onions and horseradish aioli on baguette.
    • Warm Meatball Hero $11.50 Choice of meatballs with house-made tomato sauce and melted mozzarella cheese on a warm French roll.
    • Chicken and Avocado Sandwich $9.95 Grilled chicken breast with avocado, lettuce, and tomato. Served on a baugette with mayo.
    • Tuna Melt $10.00 Our homemade tuna served with melted cheddar cheese.
    • Bacon, Lettuce and Tomato on a Toasted Baguette $8.50 With mayo.
    • Bacon, Lettuce, Tomato and Avocado on a Toasted Baguette $9.50 With mayo.
    • Peanut Butter and Jelly on Seven Grain Toast $4.95
    • Peanut Butter, Jelly and Banana on Seven Grain Toast $5.50
    • Chunky Chicken Salad Sandwich $10.00 With green apples, dried cranberries, and pecans on a French roll.
    • Chicken, Avocado and Bacon Sandwich $11.45 Grilled chicken breast with bacon, avocado, lettuce and tomato. Served on a baguette with mayo.
    • Fresh Roasted Salmon BLT $13.95 With bacon, tomato salsa, crunchy romaine on toasted ciabatta.
  • Hot From Our Kitchen

    • Warm Meatball Plate $13.50 Your choice of meatballs served with mixed greens and toasted country bread.
    • Lasagna Bolognese $14.50 Your choice of vegetarian or bolognese. Served with a mixed green salad and a country roll.
    • Eggplant Parmesan $14.50 Served with mixed greens.
    • Fried Chicken Plate $17.50 Served with your choice of a biscuit or cornbread and mixed green salad.
    • Macaroni and Cheese $11.50 Creamy macaroni and cheese, served with a mixed green salad and choice of biscuit or corn bread.
    • Fried Chicken with a Side of Mac and Cheese $18.50
    • Warm Chicken Schnitzel Sandwich $12.50 Breaded chicken breast, with melted Swiss cheese, roasted red peppers, crunchy Romaine and chipotle aioli on a toasted hero roll.
    • Warm Chicken Parmesan Sandwich $12.50 Breaded chicken breast with homemade marinara sauce and melted mozzarella cheese on a toasted hero roll.
    • Hot Eggplant Parmesan Hero $12.50 With house made tomato sauce and melted mozzarella cheese on a warm hero.
    • Lo-Carb Lasagna $14.50 Made with zucchini instead of noodles. Lots of layers, lots of sauce and lots of cheese. Served with mixed green salad and a roll. Vegetarian and gluten-free.
    • Quiche $8.75 Homemade spinach and Gruyere quiche. Served with a mixed green salad. Vegetarian.
  • Side Orders

    • Side Order of Mac and Cheese $6.50
    • Side Order of Curried Chicken Salad $6.50
    • Side Order of Tuna Salad $6.50
    • Side Order of Chunky Chicken Salad $6.50
    • Side Order of Mixed Greens $4.00
  • Bakery

    • Chocolate Chip Cookie $3.00
    • Oatmeal Raisin Cookie $3.00
    • Peanut Butter Cookie $3.00
    • Kitchen Sink Cookie $3.00 Chocolate chips, oats, pecan, coconut and caramel.
    • Chocolate Brownie with Chocolate Frosting $3.75
    • Brown Sugar Blondie with Walnuts $3.95
    • Croissant $2.75
    • Slice of Golden Vanilla Cake $5.75 With fudgy frosting.
    • Slice of Chocolate Cake $5.75 With chocolate buttercream and fudgy filling.
    • Slice of Red Velvet Cake $5.75 With cream cheese frosting.
    • Slice of Carrot Cake $5.75 With cream cheese frosting.
    • Slice of Banana Cake $5.75 With whipped Nutella frosting.
    • Slice of Coconut Cake $5.75 With coconut buttercream and coconut flakes.
    • Muffin $3.50
    • Banana Walnut Bread $3.00
    • Homemade Oreos $3.50
    • Buttermilk Biscuit $2.75
    • Individual Homemade Banana Cream Pie $5.00
    • Individual Homemade Key Lime Pie $5.00
    • Cornbread $2.50
    • Zucchini Bread $3.00 Moist and delicious. Contains nuts.
    • Chocolate Chubbies $3.50 More than a cookie, not quite a brownie. Super Chocolate-y!!
    • Strawberry Cheesecake $5.50
    • Salted Caramel Cheesecake $5.50
    • Oreo Cheesecake $5.50
    • Croissant Twist $4.50
    • Homemade Donuts (Weekends Only) $3.25
    • Cheese Danish (Weekends Only) $3.95
    • Apple Turnover (Weekends Only) $3.95

Build your meal by clicking whatever sounds good.

Plenty Cafe Menu

Start a Group Order

Name Your Group Order

233 Ratings

124 Reviews Hide Reviews

Close
Plenty Cafe

Plenty Cafe

GrubHub reviews in your neighborhood

  • “Fresh and always delicious! Great addition to the neighborhood ”

    Jodi

    2 reviews and 272 orders
  • “I order from here almost every day when I'm at work. Everything is great. Love their sandwiches and baked dessert goodies. Solid espresso drinks.”

    Patrick

    5 reviews and 1174 orders
  • “Plenty was an amazing Lunch find in the neighborhood. The food is fresh and delicious every time! The turkey meatloaf sandwich is out of this world!”

    jane

    3 reviews and 1163 orders
  • “I love this place. They have everything and it's all homemade and delicious. I love the baked goods especially. One time they were out of a baked item and I got a very friendly phone call with alternate ideas. ”

    Alyssa

    1 reviews and 170 orders
  • “This place will be the death of me! Amazing baked goods, esp. the chocolate cake with "fudgy frosting." Chicken tenders are the best I've had -- not the usual greasy strips but big chunks in crispy, flavorful batter. Meatball platter is delicious, too. Everything is just really fresh and good in that homemade way. The ONLY items that aren't great are the salads--actually, just the dressings. Odd flavors, even for basics like Caesar and vinaigrette. Figures that the healthy stuff would be a miss!”

    J

    2 reviews and 978 orders
  • “food is good, but the past 3 out of 4 times i've ordered from here there's been a problem with my order -- something isn't ready yet, they've sold out of an item, etc. not worth the hassle.”

    melissa

    4 reviews and 129 orders
  • “Everything is amazing”

    Claire

    3 reviews and 2108 orders
  • “The food is always fresh and the delivery is usually very prompt. I order from here at least once a week. ”

    Katherine

    5 reviews and 411 orders
  • “This is the second breakfast from them now.... i'm sure they're great at other things, but the quality of the 'Cheesy Egg Sandwich) is awesome. NO ONE else sends you a properly cooked, fluffy, omelet on the perfect style roll to appreciate the texture of the perfectly cooked ..... OK. So I can't get enough of those things. I give the a 4.5 this time. I wish the menu were a bit bigger.. I love the yoghurt parfait as well. Just a tad Over for the bacon, but better than last time. Not everyone likes 'chewy bacon...' Give it a Try! ”

    Anne

    8 reviews and 353 orders
  • “I order delivery from Plenty all of the time and it's always great. They're never more than 30mins to deliver and that's always surprising to me. The delivery people are courteous, friendly and always smiling. If they don't have something, they call. The food is great. I love the bacon, egg & cheese biscuit..it's to die for. The Mac & cheese is great. The chicken fingers are great, they don't come with dipping sauce, but they don't need any. The salads are fresh, and I love the dressing ..it's a balsamic vinegar type. Yummy. Now, the downfall for me is keeping to my diet, as I always have to order a dessert here. The cheesecake, the cake, pies, donuts and etc are all amazing. Plus they have the best coffee. ”

    Heather

    19 reviews and 971 orders
  • “pricy and slow but so worth it!”

    Laura

    1 reviews and 448 orders
  • “Great food! But they forgot the bacon on my sandwich”

    Kate

    1 reviews and 62 orders
  • “Great food and good delivery times. Love the homemade Oreo - when they don't run our. Consistently fresh and yummy. A delivery staple. ”

    Chelsea

    2 reviews and 404 orders
  • “My only compliant is that they had more selection. I love everything at Plenty. ”

    Erin

    14 reviews and 496 orders
  • “The biscuits here are out of this world. And the homemade oreos are pure sugary heaven. Trust me.”

    Ashley

    11 reviews and 322 orders
  • “Marble pound cake was insanely delicious, but fried chicken was burnt, and not worth the cost. Also had very little flavor. Mac and cheese was good, and the portions were ample. All of the baked goods I've had from this place have been very good. ”

    Evan

    7 reviews and 386 orders
  • “Everything is fresh and made very well - everything is delicious ”

    Douglas

    1 reviews and 465 orders
  • “The bacon, egg, cheese on a biscuit was yummy. They make delicious biscuits in general, which is an item more restaurants should start to offer. They didn't arrive quickly, but it was worth the wait. ”

    Geraldine

    3 reviews and 280 orders
  • “love the food!! i've gotten the two grilled chicken sandwiches, both with chipotle mayo twice now and it's delicious. oreo cheesecake and cornbread and blat are also good. first delivery time was not so great but i called and they came five minutes later. the second time the food was here in almost under thirty minutes. love!!!”

    karen

    1 reviews and 18 orders
  • “Best breakfast you can get delivered (or maybe just get, period). Quick delivery. They're also very nice when you're in the store. My favorite breakfast is the bacon egg and cheese on a biscuit!”

    Amanda

    2 reviews and 256 orders
  • “Food is amazing! Why don't you offer vegetable sides though? ”

    Henry

    1 reviews and 290 orders
  • “The food is great, but the delivery is really slow. Definitely outside of the Estimate Time of Delivery. ”

    Rachel

    1 reviews and 327 orders
  • “Consistently amazing! Breakfast lunch and dinner are equally executed. Everything is fresh and homemade. I've tried something different each time and all are better than the last! Best overall cafe on the UES”

    Angela

    1 reviews and 463 orders
  • “The food and baked goods are overall pleasing. The roast beef sandwich and mac and cheese are favorites. I find take out service better than eating in. ”

    Gail

    1 reviews and 567 orders
  • “I love this place, everything tastes good and no hassles with the delivery. This is how food delivery should be.”

    Sangita

    4 reviews and 798 orders
  • “One of my favorite places on the UES. I order from here all the time. The cheesy egg sandwiches are my favorite (try one on a biscuit instead of a roll). And the desserts are simply yummy. Especially the key line pie which is the best I've had, and I'm very particular about my key lime pie! The salads and the sandwiches are good, too. There are a couple of food items that don't live up to Plenty's usually high quality - the fried chicken plate and the meatloaf sandwich among them. Also, the macaroni and cheese plate is good, but there are better on the UES. While this isn't the cheapest restaurant, I find the quality of food to be worth the price. I've always had pretty quick service meaning the food is hot and fresh when it arrives. The couple of times they've been out of something I've ordered, they've called and offered to switch it out with something else (and at no additional charge if what I switched it with is more expensive than the original item). Bottom line, I order from Seamless all the time, and I always find myself going back to Plenty because the food and service quality is consistently great. ”

    Jillian

    1 reviews and 240 orders
  • “The only seamless review I have ever made... Plenty is By far my favorite seamless place to order from. Fresh & made with care. I have been to the restaurant in person and know it is clean- which is a huge thing for me living in NYC. Can't believe it doesn't have 5 stars considering some of the other restaurants that actually have 5 stars are beyond gross (like awful diners ect). Fresh baked treats.. I love the Caesar salad with chicken and the chicken sandwich with a side salad and sub the mayo for mustard.. Plenty is so delicious! ”

    alexandra

    1 reviews and 388 orders
  • “can't go wrong with anything on the menu, absolutely delicious!”

    Sara

    2 reviews and 906 orders
  • “Prices keep rising and portions keep shrinking. Not cool. What used to fill me up no longer does so and costs $3-4 more. -- Prompt delivery (sub 30 mins). Chicken breast sandwich was very tasty and had quality ingredients. Smoked turkey sandwich was also very good/fresh. Housemade roast beef sandwich was good but not as well executed as the other two.”

    Carlo

    7 reviews and 327 orders
  • “Honestly, the food isn't the best I've ever had but for some reason I find myself ordering from here multiple times a week. Can't go wrong with the smoked turkey sandwich and a chocolate chubbie”

    Amanda

    1 reviews and 205 orders

Full Hours, Cuisines, More Info... Hide Extra Info

Close

Plenty Cafe Delivery

Sandwiches, Healthy, Salads, Breakfast, Bakery, Lunch, Dinner

Hours

  • Monday 7:30 AM - 9:30 PM
  • Tuesday 7:30 AM - 9:30 PM
  • Wednesday 7:30 AM - 9:30 PM
  • Thursday 7:30 AM - 9:30 PM
  • Friday 7:30 AM - 9:30 PM
  • Saturday 7:30 AM - 9:30 PM
  • Sunday 7:30 AM - 9:30 PM

9177915057

1457 3rd Ave New York, NY

Sunday

Open Now

7:30 AM - 9:30 PM

Delivery

Delivery $1.50

Minimum $ 15.00

Pickup

Show map