1. Search
  2. Pick a Restaurant
  3. Build Your Meal
  4. → Order & Eat!
  • Pay with a credit card, PayPal, or cash at the door.
  • Tip online.
  • 24/7 Customer Service.
  • Free to use.
  • Get text updates about your order.
  • Saves your payment info.
  • Remembers your special instructions.
  • Saves your addresses.
Mafia Pizzeria
315-437-7499
3106 James St Syracuse NY 13206
58
3.3797
LOVE their pizza! Best I've found around. Fast delivery, love that they double checked my order by phone when they weren't sure about it.
5
5
Pizza Sandwiches Pasta Salads Chicken

Mafia Pizzeria isn't taking orders right now.

Mafia Pizzeria Menu

  • Popular Items

    • Chicken Wings $8.99+ Breaded, boneless, deep-fried and char-grilled.
    • 10 Fried Dough $3.00
    • 4 Deep Fried Oreos $3.50
    • Large 1-Topping Pizza and 10 Boneless Wings $16.99
    • 16" Large Create Your Own Pizza $12.00
    • 12" Medium Create Your Own Pizza $9.00
    • Cheese and Bacon Fries $5.95
    • Mozzarella Sticks $5.50+
    • 2 Garlic Knots $1.25
    • 1 Buffalo Style Egg Roll $2.00 An egg roll with chicken, hot sauce, lettuce and tomatoes served with blue cheese or ranch.
  • Menu Coupons

    • Large 1-Topping Pizza and 10 Boneless Wings $16.99
    • 2 Large 1-Topping Pizzas and 20 Boneless Wings $34.00
    • 2 Medium 2-Topping Pizzas $16.99
    • Medium Pizza and 10 Boneless Wings $14.95
    • 2 Large 2-Topping Pizzas $22.00
    • Large 1-Topping Cheese Pizza and 20 Wings $21.00
    • Sheet Pizza and 30 Wings $39.99
  • Beverages

    • 2 Liter Soda $3.25
    • Can of Soda $1.75
    • Bottle Waters $1.50
  • Appetizers

    • Cheese and Bacon Fries $5.95
    • Mozzarella Sticks $5.50+
    • Fried Mushrooms $5.99
    • Garlic Bread with Cheese $4.50
    • Cheddar Jalapeno Poppers $5.99+
    • 1 Buffalo Style Egg Roll $2.00 An egg roll with chicken, hot sauce, lettuce and tomatoes served with blue cheese or ranch.
    • 1 Chicken Bacon Ranch Egg Roll $2.00 An egg roll with chicken, bacon, ranch.
    • 1 Meat Lovers Egg Roll $2.50 An egg roll with sausage, bacon and pepperoni.
    • Build Your Own Pizza Style Egg Roll $2.75 Includes up to three toppings.
    • Buffalo Bites $4.95 Medium pizza deep fried then baked with Frank's red hot sauce, cut into stripes and served with blue cheese.
    • 5 Potato Skins $6.99 Served with ranch.
    • Seasoned French Fries $3.00+
    • 2 Garlic Knots $1.25
    • Chili Cheese Fries $5.95
    • Mafia Firecrackers $6.25 Jalapeno peppers sliced in half then filled with mozzarella, cheddar and bacon, then baked.
    • Buffalo Fried Shrimp $7.99 Served with fries.
    • Buffalo Chicken Tenders $7.95+ Served with fries.
    • Fried Chicken Tenders $7.95+ Served with fries.
    • Fried Pickle Spears $5.59 6 pieces
  • Salads

    • Antipasto Salad $7.00 Includes lettuce, tomatoes, red onions, cucumber, banana peppers, baked ham, provolone cheese and salami.
    • Marinated Grilled Chicken Salad $7.00 Includes lettuce, tomatoes, red onions, cucumber, banana peppers.
    • Buffalo Chicken Salad $7.00 Includes lettuce, tomatoes, red onions, cucumber, banana peppers.
    • Garden Salad $5.00 Includes lettuce, tomatoes, red onions, cucumber, banana peppers.
    • Chicken Bacon Ranch Salad $7.00 Includes lettuce, tomatoes, red onions, cucumber, banana peppers.
    • Mandarin Orange Grilled Chicken Salad $7.95 Includes lettuce, tomatoes, red onions, cucumber, banana peppers.
    • Steak Salad $7.95 Includes lettuce, tomatoes, red onions, cucumber, banana peppers.
  • Mafia Cheeseburgers

    • 70/30 Bacon Cheeseburger $9.50 70% ground beef mixed with 30% fresh bacon grilled burger topped with even more bacon, cheddar and American cheese.
    • Buffalo Blue Cheeseburger $9.50 Half-pound burger grilled then topped with blue cheese, caramelized onions and fresh bacon.
    • Frank's Red Hot Blue Cheese Infused Burger $9.50 Ground beef mixed with Frank's red hot and blue cheese, then grilled and topped with American cheese and bacon.
    • Homemade Chili Cheeseburger $9.50 Fresh made ground beef patty topped with homemade chili, caramelized onions and nacho cheddar cheese sauce.
    • Double Stacker Cheeseburger Platter $9.99 Includes fries.
    • Deluxe Cheeseburger Platter $7.99 Includes fries.
    • 2 Hot Dogs with Fries Platter $6.99 Includes fries.
  • Chicken Tender Dinner Platters

    • 4 Piece Chicken Tender Platter $7.50 Includes fries.
    • 6 Piece Chicken Tender Platter $9.95 Includes fries.
  • Seafood Dinner Platters

    • 8 Fried Shrimp Platter $9.95 Includes fries.
  • Mafia Specialty Pizzas

    • Italian Lovers Pizza $13.95+ Roasted garlic, Parmesan, tomatoes, ricotta and broccoli.
    • Machine Gun Kelly Pizza $13.95+ Smoked sausage and smoked chicken with pepper and onions.
    • Little Nicky Pizza $13.95+ Grilled eggplant with fresh tomatoes and basil served with red sauce or roasted garlic base.
    • The Rabbit Pizza $13.95+ Roast garlic, Romano cheese, tomatoes and fresh basil.
    • Iceman Pizza $13.95+ Pepperoni, mushrooms and Italian sausage.
    • Scar Face Pizza $13.95+ Hot sauce and blue cheese base topped with Buffalo grilled chicken.
    • Prime Minster Pizza $13.95+ Grilled chicken and bacon over ranch base and mozzarella.
    • Nicky Nails Pizza $13.95+ Hawaiian pizza with ham, pineapple and bacon.
    • Mad Dog Pizza $13.95+ Philly steak and cheese with onion, mushroom, sweet peppers, cheddar and mozzarella.
    • The Don Pizza $13.95+ Ham, pepperoni, bacon and sausage.
    • Baby Face Pizza $13.95+ Tomatoes, mushrooms, sweet peppers, onions and black olives.
    • Meet the Greek Pizza $13.95+ Roast garlic base, spinach, tomatoes, feta and mozzarella.
    • The Enforcer Pizza $13.95+ Sausage, pepperoni, ham, onion, sweet peppers, mushroom, black olives, bacon and tomatoes.
    • Mafia Breakfast Pizza $17.95 Sausage, fresh eggs, bacon, ham and mozzarella cheese. 16" Large Pizza.
    • The Godfather $13.95+ BBQ chicken pizza topped with fried onions, BBQ chicken, onions and sweet peppers.
    • Al Capone $13.95+ Topped with homemade chili, french fries, cheddar and mozzarella cheese.
    • Teflon Don Pizza $13.95+ Chicken Riggie pizza, Chicken with (our Riggie sauce), hot peppers, green peppers, onions, mushrooms in a creamy but spicy tomato sauce.
    • Carlito's Way $14.95+ Roasted garlic Parmesan base, broccoli, fresh tomatoes, roasted red peppers and spinach.
    • Meat Lovers Luna $24.95
    • Veggie Luna $24.95
  • Make Your Own Pizza

    • 12" Medium Create Your Own Pizza $9.00
    • 16" Large Create Your Own Pizza $12.00
    • 18" Extra Large Create Your Own Pizza $14.00
    • Create Your Own Sheet Pizza $21.00 32 slices.
  • Hot Baked Subs

    • Buffalo Chicken 12" Sub $7.95 Grilled or breaded chicken shaken in hot sauce, lettuce, tomato and onions.
    • Steak Cheese 12" Sub $7.95 Loaded with cheese, steak, onions, mushrooms and sweet peppers.
    • Chicken Bacon Ranch 12" Sub $7.95 Grilled chicken, bacon, ranch, lettuce, tomato and onions.
    • Meatball Parmesan 12" Sub $7.95 Meatballs smothered in mozzarella, homemade sauce and baked.
    • Sausage Parmesan 12" Sub $7.95 Onions, mushrooms and sweet peppers.
    • Philly Pizza Steak 12" Sub $7.95 Philly steak covered in pizza sauce the baked with mozzarella cheese.
    • Billy Philly Steak and Chicken 12" Sub $7.95 With mozzarella cheese, cheddar cheese, sweet peppers, onions and mushrooms.
    • Eggplant Parmesan 12" Sub $7.95 Fresh breaded eggplant smothered in marinara and baked with mozzarella cheese.
  • Wraps

    • Buffalo Chicken Wrap $6.50 Grilled or breaded chicken shaken in hot sauce, lettuce, tomato and onions.
    • Steak Cheese Wrap $6.50 Loaded with cheese, steak, onions, mushrooms and sweet peppers.
    • Chicken Bacon Ranch Wrap $6.50 Grilled chicken, bacon, ranch, lettuce, tomato and onions.
    • Meatball Parmesan Wrap $6.50 Meatballs smothered in mozzarella and homemade sauce.
    • Sausage Parmesan Wrap $6.50 Onions, mushrooms and sweet peppers.
    • Philly Pizza Steak Wrap $6.50 Philly steak covered in pizza sauce with mozzarella cheese.
    • Billy Philly Steak and Chicken Wrap $6.50 With mozzarella cheese, cheddar cheese, sweet peppers, onions and mushrooms.
  • Mafia Italian Pastas

    • Utica Style Chicken Riggies $9.95 Onions, fresh garlic, hot cherry peppers, roasted red peppers and mushrooms tossed in a creamy red sauce. Includes two garlic sticks and a side salad.
    • Baked Rigatoni $9.95 Tossed with our homemade sauce then baked with mozzarella cheeses. Includes two garlic sticks and a side salad.
    • Baked Lasagna $10.95 Smothered in sauce and baked to perfection. Includes two garlic sticks and a side salad.
    • Cajun Chicken Broccoli Alfredo $11.95 Fresh broccoli and chicken tossed with penne pasta in a creamy Cajun homemade sauce. Includes two garlic sticks and a side salad.
    • Chicken Parmesan $10.95 Breaded chicken covered in homemade sauce and mozzarella then baked to perfection served with side of pasta. Includes two garlic sticks and a side salad.
    • Eggplant Parmesan $9.95 Always freshly breaded here and then covered in homemade sauce and baked with mozzarella. Served with side of pasta.
    • Chicken Broccoli Alfredo $10.95 Chicken and fresh broccoli tossed with penne pasta in our homemade creamy Alfredo sauce. Includes two garlic sticks and a side salad.
    • Smoked Chicken and Sausage Bake $10.95 Rigatoni pasta tossed with smoked chicken, sausage, onions and sweet peppers, then covered with homemade sauce and baked with mozzarella. Includes two garlic sticks and a side salad.
    • 6 Stuffed Shells $9.50 Includes two garlic sticks and a side salad.
    • Chicken Fettuccine Alfredo $12.95 Fresh chicken sauteed with broccoli and garlic then finished with a creamy Alfredo sauce. Served with your choice of pasta and two garlic bread sticks.
    • Spicy Shrimp Divialo $13.95 Shrimp sauteed in garlic with fresh broccoli and roasted red peppers in a creamy spicy marinara sauce. Served with your choice of pasta and two garlic bread sticks.
    • Shrimp Scampi $13.95 Fresh shrimp sauteed with fresh garlic in a buttery white wine sauce over your choice of pasta. Served with two garlic bread sticks.
    • Shrimp Alfredo $13.95 Sauteed with garlic and broccoli in a creamy Alfredo sauce. Served with your choice of pasta and two garlic bread sticks.
    • Scallops Alfredo $13.95 Sauteed with garlic and broccoli in a creamy Alfredo sauce. Served with your choice of pasta and two garlic bread sticks.
    • Shrimp and Scallops Alfredo $15.95 Sauteed with garlic and broccoli in a creamy Alfredo sauce. Served with your choice of pasta and two garlic bread sticks.
  • Chicken Wings

    • Chicken Wings $8.99+ Breaded, boneless, deep-fried and char-grilled.
  • Calzones, Pizza Rolls and Stromboli

    • Small Calzone $5.95 Includes mozzarella and ricotta.
    • Large Calzone $9.99 Includes mozzarella and ricotta.
    • Chicken Wing Calzone $6.95
    • Chicken, Bacon, Ranch Calzone $6.95
    • Meat Lovers Calzone $6.95
    • Cheese Pizza Rolls $5.95 Includes mozzarella and cheese.
    • Stromboli $6.95 Includes sauce and one topping.
    • Chicken Bacon Ranch Pizza Roll $6.50
    • Buffalo Pizza Roll $6.50
    • Steak and Cheese Stromboli $7.95 Includes onions, mushrooms and peppers.
  • Desserts

    • Brownie Bites $3.00
    • 10 Fried Dough $3.00
    • 4 Deep Fried Oreos $3.50
    • 6 Cinnamon Sticks $3.50

Mafia Pizzeria isn't taking orders right now.

Mafia Pizzeria Menu

79 Ratings

"LOVE their pizza! Best I've found around. Fast delivery, love tha … See more. "

58 Reviews Hide Reviews

Close
Mafia Pizzeria

Mafia Pizzeria

GrubHub reviews in your neighborhood

  • “thats strike two. last couple of times order not right. I ordered the shrimp scampi with linguine and got fettuccine tonight.”

    Kimberly

    1 reviews and 4 orders
  • “very good food,but slow!!! it was also Valentines day and awful weather so im not sure if that contributed to the awful delay. However, the dough was great and I would try it again.”

    Amiele

    8 reviews and 18 orders
  • “its not that good”

    Joseph

    11 reviews and 39 orders
  • “Good pizza. The delivery time was pretty slow but it was snowing out. Time of order on grubhub 845, delivery 1020. I will order from here again. ”

    James

    1 reviews and 3 orders
  • “LOVE their pizza! Best I've found around. Fast delivery, love that they double checked my order by phone when they weren't sure about it. ”

    Heather

    3 reviews and 33 orders
  • “The food is really good. Delivery is always on time . Had an issue with receiving wrong food once, but the owner, John, called me back and resolved it.”

    Anthony

    1 reviews and 5 orders
  • “Not exactly the best food to get. Their garlic knots were great, but the pasta they gave me had literally about 4 drops of sauce on it and the rest was butter or grease.”

    Alana

    1 reviews and 23 orders
  • “Pizza was pretty good. Garlic knots were great! The delivery came about 15-20 minutes earlier than the estimate, so no complaint there!”

    Jeremy

    1 reviews and 12 orders
  • “good! friendly nice delivery ”

    michelle

    2 reviews and 28 orders
  • “They were friendly, fast and the food was awsome”

    Jennifer

    8 reviews and 21 orders
  • “Dont know-never received it! very disappointed!”

    Jesse

    1 reviews and 12 orders
  • “Bad pizza. Wings were ok. Pizza was the worst I've had in a while though.”

    Craig

    2 reviews and 6 orders
  • “Just so so. Wings were dry and pizza was decent, but nothing special.”

    Kevin

    2 reviews and 9 orders
  • “TASTELESS NO SEASONING SMALL PORTIONS FOR THE MONEY(CMON, PASTA IS $1.50 A POUND!)”

    CHRIS

    1 reviews and 4 orders
  • “Love the garlic knots. ”

    christine

    1 reviews and 1 orders
  • “Pizza was AWESOME! ”

    Lisa

    3 reviews and 33 orders
  • “The food was standard for these sorts of places that have huge menus and low prices. Good for what you pay for. I ordered food around 10:20 pm: some "Firecrackers," which were described as, basically, jalapeno poppers, and a steak & cheese sandwich. I get a call some time later letting me know they're out of steak and ask me what I'd like instead. No big deal, it happens to this sort of place. So I ask for a chicken and cheese. I ultimately get my order around 11:30 pm. Instead of jalapeno poppers, it is some crummy french fries. The chicken sandwich has that weird, neon-gold "cheese" sauce rather than actual cheese. I wouldn't be so irked but these types of restaurants were my go-to when I worked a hotel desk in north carolina, and they were of a far higher caliber for the same price. Just be careful and double-check your order.”

    Scott

    1 reviews and 1 orders
  • “Good food delivered fast & HOT!!”

    tammy

    1 reviews and 1 orders
  • “Hot, great sauce, and the driver was amazing...”

    Mari

    3 reviews and 89 orders
  • “It sound good but there was one problem I never got My pizza they said tht they called Me. never got a phone call....I dont understand why they could not just bring it to My house.this is the whole point of useing grubhub”

    rashad

    4 reviews and 33 orders
  • “I didnt really care for the chicken but pizza was just ok”

    Damien

    1 reviews and 1 orders
  • “Over and over again we order from other places... and wish we would just stick to Mafia! Yup, been a few issues, but immediately taken care of and could not be more apologetic. Real food, decent prices and excellent delivery. How can you go wrong! PS Their darn brownie bites should be illegal!”

    leslie

    2 reviews and 29 orders
  • “Great timing and food!”

    Priscilla

    1 reviews and 30 orders
  • “Great Pizza! Delivery guy was an idiot and didn't know which apartment to drop it off at (read the ticket!!!!). ”

    Mary Rachel

    1 reviews and 3 orders
  • “Took a little while to delivery but food was great and the size was gigantic!”

    Eric

    4 reviews and 113 orders
  • “Got the order wrong. Barely ANY sauce on the wings. Dont offer a top for the side sauces so it drips through the whole box. Wont order from again. ”

    Gary

    1 reviews and 58 orders
  • “Delivery was prompt and courteous...fried cauliflower was incredible as were the brownie bites. Was offered a bolognese meat sauce on pasta in lieu of sausage but didn't find it to be meaty...however, I tend to like my sauce on the thick/hearty side. ”

    Linda

    1 reviews and 1 orders
  • “Wayy overpriced for the portions i got- I got a one-topping pizza and bacon-cheese fries. I couldnt find the pepperoni on the pizza, and for 5.95 i got a handfull of fries with cheese and bacon-what you would consider a small. Extremely dissapointed, taking my buisness elsewere”

    codey

    2 reviews and 60 orders
  • “Absolutely awful. So expensive.. AND our orders were wrong AND the pizza was gross. We ordered wings and they came as tiny pieces of chicken breasts...worst than boneless. The wings were sitting in grease and butter. So disappointed in this food. ”

    Bethani

    2 reviews and 49 orders
  • “SOO GOOD!”

    Kyra

    1 reviews and 46 orders

7 Coupons Hide Coupons

Close
Mafia Pizzeria

GrubHub Coupons

You'll be able to apply a coupon once you've started your order.

Just a heads up - some special offers are only available on certain days and times.

  • 2 Large 1-Topping Pizzas and 20 Boneless Wings
  • 2 Large 2-Topping Pizzas
  • 2 Medium 2-Topping Pizzas
  • Large 1-Topping Cheese Pizza and 20 Wings
  • Large 1-Topping Pizza and 10 Boneless Wings
  • Medium Pizza and 10 Boneless Wings
  • Sheet Pizza and 30 Wings

Full Hours, Cuisines, More Info... Hide Extra Info

Close

Mafia Pizzeria Delivery

Pizza, Sandwiches, Pasta, Salads, Chicken, Seafood, Dessert, Wraps, Hamburgers, Dinner, Hot Dogs, Calzones, Cheesesteaks

A Slice you can't refuse...

Hours

  • Monday 4:30 PM - 12:00 AM
  • Tuesday 4:30 PM - 12:00 AM
  • Wednesday 4:30 PM - 12:00 AM
  • Thursday 4:30 PM - 12:00 AM
  • Friday 4:30 PM - 2:00 AM
  • Saturday 4:00 PM - 2:00 AM
  • Sunday 4:00 PM - 12:00 AM

315-437-7499

3106 James St Syracuse, NY

Thursday

Not taking orders at this time.

4:30 PM - 12:00 AM

Delivery

Delivery $1.25

Minimum $ 10.00

Pickup

Show map