1. Search
  2. Pick a Restaurant
  3. Build Your Meal
  4. → Order & Eat!
  • Pay with a credit card, PayPal, or cash at the door.
  • Tip online.
  • 24/7 Customer Care.
  • Free to use.
  • Get text updates about your order.
  • Saves your payment info.
  • Remembers your special instructions.
  • Saves your addresses.

Build your meal by clicking whatever sounds good.

Sutton Pizza and Gyro Menu

Trending Items

Suggested Meals

    • $13.00 Cheese Pizza Small
    • $3.75 Regular Pizza Slice Meatballs
    • $2.75 Regular Pizza Slice
    • $1.85 20 oz. Bottled Soda Ginger Ale
    • $18.75 2 Topping Combination Pizza Small, Sausage, Pepperoni
  • Popular Items

    • Regular Pizza Slice $2.75
    • Gyro on Pita $6.50 Served with lettuce, tomato, onions and white sauce.
    • Cheese Pizza $13.00+
    • Pepperoni Pizza $16.00+
  • Beverages

    • Can of Soda $1.25
    • 20 oz. Bottled Soda $1.85
    • Snapple $1.85 Please call the restaurant for today's selection.
    • Coffee $1.50
    • Tea $1.50
    • Hot Chocolate $2.00
  • Salads

    • Antipasto Salad $7.25+ Served with oil and vinegar dressing.
    • Chef's Salad $7.25+ Served with oil and vinegar dressing.
    • Greek Salad $7.00+ Served with oil and vinegar dressing.
    • House Salad $5.00+ Served with oil and vinegar dressing.
    • Grilled Chicken over Salad $12.00 Served with oil and vinegar dressing.
    • Grilled Chicken over Greek Salad $13.50 Served with oil and vinegar dressing.
    • Garlic Bread $2.50
    • Soup $4.00 Please call the restaurant for today's selection.
  • Gyro and Souvlaki

    • Gyro on Pita $6.50 Served with lettuce, tomato, onions and white sauce.
    • Gyro Platter $9.00 Pita on the side. Served with lettuce, tomato, onions and white sauce.
    • Gyro Platter with French Fries $12.00 Served with lettuce, tomato, onions and white sauce.
    • Chicken Souvlaki on Pita $6.50 Served with lettuce, tomato, onions and white sauce.
    • Combination Gyro and Chicken Platter $14.00 Served with lettuce, tomato, onions and white sauce.
    • Side of French Fries $3.75
  • Rolls

    • Calzone $6.50
    • Spinach Roll $6.00
    • Stromboli $6.00
    • Sausage Roll $6.00
    • Chicken Roll $6.00
    • Beef Patties $2.50
  • Pizza

    • Cheese Pizza $13.00+
    • Extra Cheese Pizza $16.00+
    • Sausage Pizza $16.00+
    • Anchovies Pizza $16.00+
    • Pepperoni Pizza $16.00+
    • Green Peppers Pizza $16.00+
    • Meatballs Pizza $16.00+
    • Onions Pizza $16.00+
    • Mushrooms Pizza $16.00+
    • 1/2 and 1/2 Pizza $16.00+
    • 2 Topping Combination Pizza $18.75+
    • 3 Topping Combination Pizza $21.00+
    • Sutton Pride Pizza Galore $22.00+
    • Hawaiian Pizza $18.75+
    • White Pizza $19.00+
    • Onion and Tomato Pizza $19.00+
    • Vegetable Pizza $22.00+
    • Chicken and Tomato Pizza $22.00+
    • Broccoli Pizza $16.00+
    • Chicken Pizza $17.00+
    • Olives Pizza $16.00+
    • Meat Lovers Pizza $22.00+
    • 12 Slice Square Sicilian Pizza $22.00
  • Pizza Slices

    • Regular Pizza Slice $2.75
    • Sicilian Pizza Slice $2.75
    • Chicken Pizza Slice $4.25
    • Chicken and Tomato Pizza Slice $4.75
    • Onion and Tomato Pizza Slice $4.25
    • Meat Lovers Pizza Slice $4.75
    • Vegetable Pizza Slice $4.75
    • Hawaiian Pizza Slice $4.25
    • White Pizza Slice $3.75
  • Pasta

    • Spaghetti with Tomato Sauce $6.00
    • Spaghetti with Butter $7.50
    • Spaghetti with Meat Sauce $9.00
    • Spaghetti with Garlic and Oil $9.00
    • Spaghetti Meatballs $9.50
    • Spaghetti with Clam Sauce $9.50
    • Spaghetti Mushroom and Sauce $9.00
    • Spaghetti with Sausage $9.50
    • Ravioli with Tomato Sauce $9.50
    • Ravioli with Meat Sauce $11.25
    • Bake Ravioli a la Parmigiana $10.50
    • Baked Manicotti $9.50
    • Baked Lasagna $11.00
    • Baked Lasagna with Meatballs $14.00
    • Baked Lasagna with Sausage $14.00
    • Baked Ziti $9.75
    • Baked Ziti with Meat $11.00
    • Baked Ziti with Meatballs $14.00
    • Bake Ziti with Sausage $14.00
    • Stuffed Shells $9.75
  • Entrees

    • Eggplant with Tomato Sauce $11.00 Served with side of spaghetti, ziti or salad.
    • Eggplant Parmigiana $12.00 Served with side of spaghetti, ziti or salad.
    • Sausage and Peppers $12.00 Served with side of spaghetti, ziti or salad.
    • Chicken Parmigiana $14.00 Served with side of spaghetti, ziti or salad.
    • Shrimp Parmigiana $14.00 Served with side of spaghetti, ziti or salad.
  • Cold Hero

    • Genoa Salami and Cheese Hero $6.00 Served with lettuce and tomato.
    • Ham and Cheese Hero $6.00 Served with lettuce and tomato.
    • Submarine Hero $8.50 Served with lettuce and tomato.
  • Hot Hero

    • Meatball Hero $6.00
    • Meatball Parmigiana Hero $7.25
    • Sausage Hero $6.25
    • Sausage and Peppers Hero $7.25
    • Peppers and Eggs Hero $6.00
    • Ham and Eggs Hero $6.00
    • Eggplant Hero $6.00 With tomato sauce.
    • Eggplant Parmigiana Hero $7.25
    • Chicken Cutlet Hero $7.50
    • Chicken Cutlet Parmigiana Hero $8.50
    • Shrimp Parmigiana Hero $9.00

Build your meal by clicking whatever sounds good.

Sutton Pizza and Gyro Menu

Start a Group Order

Name Your Group Order

41 Ratings

16 Reviews Hide Reviews

Close
Sutton Pizza and Gyro

Sutton Pizza and Gyro

GrubHub reviews in your neighborhood

  • “I didn't have any problems with confirming the order. My e-mail came through in minutes and my pizza always arrives on time super HOT <3. The toppings here are a little pricey but the pizza is the BEST in my neighborhood. Crunchy and chewey crust, tons of cheese and toppings and always delicious when it comes to my door. Their Hawaiian Pie is TDF. :-P ”

    Brittany

    2 reviews and 0 orders
  • “This is the first time ordering from here and I must say, it's pretty good. The delivery was quick, took about 20 minutes and the food was delicious. Also the portions I received were large, the pasta dish could easily feed three adults. I will definitely order from them again.”

    Dina

    2 reviews and 0 orders
  • “Love their pizza! It's one of the best I've had and always delivered hot! I've had pepperoni with green peppers and its really good. I highly recommend!”

    kailyn

    4 reviews and 0 orders
  • “great pizza and dishes!”

    Nicky

    4 reviews and 0 orders
  • “Best sicilian pizza I have had. Fresh with crispy crust cooked onions baked in with sauce. ”

    Patrick

    5 reviews and 0 orders
  • “Consistently good Italian food. Love the meatball ziti!!”

    Andrea

    2 reviews and 0 orders
  • “Great pizza. Pasta was okay.”

    Jason

    1 reviews and 0 orders
  • “This is the best pizza in the city in my opinion. Greasy but sooo good. The owner does a good job too. They messed up my order one time and he immediately offered to fix it. Love this place!”

    Shaun

    1 reviews and 0 orders
  • “I ordered from here because Seamless gave them a high rating for their eggplant parmigiano. It was anything but good. The slices of eggplant were cut super thick and it tasted like soap. It was probably the worst eggplant parmigiano I have ever eaten. And the garlic bread we ordered tasted sour. The garlic tasted rancid. The food also came 45 minutes after it was supposed to. We called 2 times to ask where the food was... it was extremely frustrating. We will never order from here again.”

    Brian

    2 reviews and 0 orders
  • “Pizza was pretty good, but it took over an hour to deliver. Would order here again only if i was ordering way in advance. ”

    zeena

    6 reviews and 0 orders
  • “One of the best pizza of the neighborhood, always on time, keep up the good work Sutton!”

    Sophie

    6 reviews and 0 orders
  • “Great pizza... Came in hot! Their plain cheese I think is the best! Would order from again.”

    Saima

    1 reviews and 0 orders
  • “food is good, but had to call to re-confrim order....annoying”

    tom

    3 reviews and 0 orders
  • “fries were good”

    Martina

    3 reviews and 0 orders
  • “Delicious Slices of Pizza, Quick Delivery, yumm!”

    Natalya

    3 reviews and 0 orders
  • “Goooood Pizza”

    Michael

    9 reviews and 0 orders

Full Hours, Cuisines, More Info... Hide Extra Info

Close

Sutton Pizza and Gyro Delivery

Pizza, Sandwiches, American, Pasta, Salads, Lunch, Gyro, Dinner

Hours

  • Monday 11:00 AM - 11:00 PM
  • Tuesday 11:00 AM - 11:00 PM
  • Wednesday 11:00 AM - 11:00 PM
  • Thursday 11:00 AM - 11:00 PM
  • Friday 11:00 AM - 11:00 PM
  • Saturday 11:00 AM - 11:00 PM
  • Sunday 11:00 AM - 11:00 PM

646-582-6915

1140 1st Ave New York, NY

Friday

Open Now

11:00 AM - 11:00 PM

Delivery

Delivery Free

Minimum $ 0.00

Pickup

Show map