1. Search
  2. Pick a Restaurant
  3. Build Your Meal
  4. → Order & Eat!
  • Pay with a credit card, PayPal, or cash at the door.
  • Tip online.
  • 24/7 Customer Care.
  • Free to use.
  • Get text updates about your order.
  • Saves your payment info.
  • Remembers your special instructions.
  • Saves your addresses.

Build your meal by clicking whatever sounds good.

Subsconscious Menu

Trending Items

Suggested Meals

    • $10.25 Make Your Own Salad Large, Romaine, Croutons, Pickles, Red Onions, Tomatoes, Hard-Boiled Egg, Avocado, Bacon Bits, Grilled Chicken, Ranch Dressing
    • $1.85 Cookies Chocolate Chip
    • $8.00 Bologna & Cheese 10 Sub, Mayo, Add Double Meat, Add Extra Provolone, Provolone, Sweet Peppers
    • $3.75 Cheese Fries Large
    • $2.50 Soda (1 Liter) Diet Coke
    • $9.00 Super Cheese Steak Sub, Russian Dressing, Add Pickles, Add Jalapenos, Provolone, Hot Peppers
    • $2.50 Soda (1 Liter) Coke
    • $1.75 Gatorade (20oz) Lemon Lime
  • Popular Items

    • Make Your Own Salad $2.75+ Your choice of greens, toppings and dressing.
    • Poland Spring Water $1.10+
    • Soda (1 Liter) $2.50
    • Tropicana Juice (16oz) $2.00
    • Gatorade (20oz) $1.75
    • Cookies $1.85+
    • Cakes $2.50+
    • Cheese Fries $2.25+
    • French Fries $1.75+
    • Onion Rings $2.00+
  • Beverages

    • Soda (Bottle) $1.65
    • Soda (1 Liter) $2.50
    • Poland Spring Water $1.10+
    • Snapple $1.75
    • Gatorade (20oz) $1.75
    • Vitamin Water (20oz) $2.25
    • Tropicana Juice (16oz) $2.00
    • Red Bull $2.50
    • Sugar Free Red Bull $2.50
  • Bagels and Spreads

    • Bagel $0.85
    • Cream Cheese $1.50
    • Sun Dried Tomato Spread $1.95
    • Walnut Raisin Spread $1.95
    • Scallion Spread $1.95
    • Vegetable Spread $1.95
    • Lox Spread $2.95
    • Lite Spread $1.95
    • Butter $1.15
    • Peanut Butter $1.95
    • Peanut Butter & Jelly $2.25
    • Jelly $1.15
    • Cream Cheese & Jelly $1.75
    • Butter & Jelly $1.50
  • Salad Bar

    • Make Your Own Salad $2.75+ Your choice of greens, toppings and dressing.
  • Other Stuff

    • Grilled Cheese on Toast $3.75
    • B.L.T. $4.25 Bacon, Lettuce & Tomatoes
    • Burger on a Bun $4.00
    • Cheeseburger on a Bun $4.25
  • Wraps

    • Turkey Wrap $5.00
    • Smoked Turkey Wrap $5.00
    • Roast Beef Wrap $5.50
    • Grilled Chicken Wrap $6.00
    • Veggie Wrap $5.25
    • Greek Wrap $6.50
  • Classic Sandwiches

    • Turkey Breast $4.75+
    • Honey Turkey $4.75+
    • Smoked Turkey $4.75+
    • Pepper & Egg $4.50+
    • Roast Beef $5.25+ Cooked & seasoned on premises
    • Virginia Ham $5.00+
    • Pepper Cracked Turkey $4.75+
    • Pastrami $4.75+
    • Corned Beef $4.75+
    • Regular Italian $5.50+ Spicy, delicious, 3 meats with cheese
    • Ham & Cheese $4.50+
    • Bologna & Cheese $4.50+
    • B.L.T. $4.25+ Bacon, lettuce & tomato
    • Cooked Salami $4.25+
    • Capicola $4.25+
    • Genoa Salami $4.25+
    • American Cheese $4.00+
    • Swiss Cheese $4.00+
    • Munster Cheese $4.00+
    • Provolone $4.00+
    • Cheddar Cheese $4.00+
    • Fresh Veggie $3.75+ No cheese
  • On The Grill

    • Turkey Burger $5.00+
    • Pizza Burger $5.00+
    • Mushroom Burgher $5.00+
    • Cheese Burger $4.25+
    • Hamburger $4.00+
    • Veggie Burger $5.50+
    • Fish & Chips $6.75
    • 10 Cheeseburger Sub $6.00
    • 10 Hamburger Sub $5.50
    • Grilled Cheese $3.75+
    • Grilled Cheese w. Tomato $4.25+
    • Grilled Cheese w. Bacon & Tomato $4.75+
    • Grilled Cheese w. Ham & Tomato $4.75+
    • The Full House $5.50+ Grilled Cheese w. Bacon, Ham & Tomato
    • Tuna Melt $6.00+
  • Breads

    • Roll $0.60
    • Sliced Bread $0.60
    • Plain Hero $1.00
    • Roll with Butter $0.75
    • Roll with Butter & Jelly $1.50
    • Roll with Cream Cheese $1.10
    • Sliced Bread with Butter $0.75
    • Sliced Bread with Butter & Jelly $0.90
    • Sliced Bread with Cream Cheese $1.10
    • Bagel with Butter $0.90
    • Bagel with Butter & Jelly $1.05
    • Bagel with Cream Cheese $1.50
    • English Muffin with Butter $1.35
    • English Muffin with Butter & Jelly $1.75
    • English Muffin with Cream Cheese $1.75
  • 10" Specialty Subs

    • The C.C. Blue $8.25 Chicken Cutlet, Melted Swiss Grilled Ham Bleu Cheese Dressing, Lettuce, Tomatoes & Onions
    • Chris' Cream Cheese Creation $8.00 Grilled Chicken, Melted Swiss Cheese, Cream Cheese, Grilled Mushrooms & Onions, Tomatoes & Honey Mustard.
    • Cornell's Husky Cheeseburger $7.25 Melted American, Swiss & Provolone, Grilled Onions, Pickles, Lettuce, Tomatoes, Mayo & Ketchup.
    • Bronx 10461 $8.75 Grilled Turkey & Ham, Melted American Cheese, Bacon, Lettuce, Tomatoes, Onions & Cole Slaw.
    • The Ultimate Veggie $7.00 Extra Helping of Grilled Vegetables, Melted Cheddar & Swiss, Lettuce, Tomatoes, Pickles, Olives, Oregano, Oil & Vinegar.
    • The Pastrami Salami Swami $8.75 Hot Pastrami, Grilled Turkey & Salami, Melted Cheddar, Hot Peppers, Onions, Lettuce, Tomatoes & Mustard.
    • The Lifeguard $9.75 Grilled Chicken, Grilled Philly Steak, Bacon, Melted American Cheese, Onions, Peppers, Lettuce, Tomatoes & Mayo.
    • Columbia Cold Combo $7.50 Smoked Turkey, Ham, Cheddar, Swiss, Lettuce, Tomato, Onions and Roasted Peppers with Balsamic Vinaigrette Dressing
    • American Cold Combo $8.00 Roast Beef, Turkey, Ham, American Cheese, Lettuce, Tomatoes, and Ranch Dressing
    • Cuban $8.00 Grilled Roast Pork, Melted Swiss Cheese, Ham, Pickles, Mustard, on a Toasted Hero
    • Rueben $6.75 Corn Beef, Sauerkraut, Swiss Cheese, and Russian Dressing on Toasted Hero
  • Triple Decker Sandwiches

    • Turkey & Bacon Triple Decker $5.50+
    • Roast Beef & Swiss Triple Decker $5.75+
    • Tuna & Sliced Egg Triple Decker $5.25+
    • Chicken Salad & Bacon Triple Decker $5.25+
    • Grilled Chicken & Bacon Triple Decker $6.25+
  • Grilled Panini

    • New Yorker Panini $6.50 Lean Prime Beef, Swiss Cheese, Orasted Red Peppers, Onions, & Russian Dressing
    • Americano Panini $6.50 Grilled Chicken Breast, Grilled Onions, & Peppers, Peperjack Cheese, Sun Dried Tomatoes, & Salsa
    • Vegetarian Panini $6.00 Oven Roasted Vegetables, Fresh Mozzarella, Pesto Sauce on Semolina Hero
    • Chicken Fajita Panini $6.50 Grilled Chicken, Cheddar Cheese, Roasted Peppers, Caramelized Onions & Salsa
    • The Russian Panini $6.50 Raost Beef, Munster Cheese, Caramelized Onions, Lettuce, Plum Tomatoes & Russian Dressing
    • The Italiano Panini $6.50 Grilled Chicken, Roasted Peppers, Fresh Mozzarella, and Pesto Sauce
  • Gourmet Foods & Sandwiches

    • Crab Cakes $6.00+
    • Filet of Fish $5.50+
    • Meatball Parmigana $5.75+
    • Chicken Cutlet Parmigana $6.25+
    • Chicken Cutlet $5.75+
    • Sausage & Peppers $5.75+
    • Cajun Chicken $6.00+
    • Dijon Chicken $6.00+
    • Sesame Chicken $6.00+
    • Grilled Chicken $5.75+
    • BBQ Chicken Breast $5.75+
    • Lemon Chicken $5.75+
    • Terriyaki Chicken $6.00+
    • Chicken Salad $4.75+
    • Tuna Salad $4.75+
    • Egg Salad $4.25+
  • Burritos

    • Vegetable Burrito $6.00
    • Chicken Burrito $6.50
    • Steak Burrito $6.75
  • 10" Signature Philly Steak Subs

    • The Final Exam $8.25 Grilled Philly Steak, American Cheese, Two Eggs, Bacon, Grilled Onions, Peppers & Mayo
    • The Nuclear Sub $8.00 Grilled Philly Steak, Jalapenos, Hot Peppers, Special Hot Sauce, Grilled Green Peppers, Provolone Cheese, Lettuce, Tomatoes & Spicy Mustard.
    • The Triple Play $7.75 Grilled Philly Steak, American, Swiss, Provolone, Grilled Onions, Mushrooms & Peppers, Lettuce, Tomatoes & Ketchup.
    • The Lion's Den $7.50 Grilled Philly Steak, Grilled Ham, Swiss, Grilled Onions, Lettuce, Tomatoes & BBQ Sauce.
    • Garden Delight $7.75 Extra Grilled Philly Steak, Sweet, Hot & Green Peppers, Onions, Pickles, Mushrooms, Lettuce, Tomatoes, Oil & Vinegar.
    • Al's Advantage $8.00 Grilled Philly Steak, Grilled Mushrooms & Onions, Bacon, Cheddar, Lettuce, Tomatoes, Mayo & BBQ Sauce.
    • Double Trouble $8.25 Grilled Philly Steak, Grilled Turkey, Onions, Swiss & American Cheese, Lettuce, Tomatoes & Russian Dressing.
    • Philly Steak $6.25
    • Philly Cheese Steak $6.75
    • Super Cheese Steak $8.25 Extra Meat & Cheese
    • Grilled Chicken Philly Style $7.25
  • Hot 10inch Subs

    • Philly Steak $5.25+
    • Philly Cheese Steak $6.50+ Our signature sub
    • Super Cheese Steak $7.25+ Hungry? Try this!
    • Grilled Chicken $5.50+ An Athletic Department Favorite
    • Chicken Cutlet $5.50+
    • Hamburger $4.50+
    • Cheeseburger $5.00+ Try it on a 10 inch sub
    • Pastrami $4.75+
    • Pepper & Egg $4.00+
    • Turkey Burger $4.75+
    • Grilled Chicken Philly Style $6.25+
    • Tuna Melt $5.25+
  • Sides

    • French Fries $1.75+
    • Cheese Fries $2.25+
    • Onion Rings $2.00+
  • Dessert

    • Cakes $2.50+
    • Pudding $1.50+
    • Cupcakes $1.99+
    • Cookies $1.85+

Build your meal by clicking whatever sounds good.

Subsconscious Menu

Start a Group Order

Name Your Group Order

70 Ratings

"They forgot to put the feta cheese on the salad. The lettuce was … See more. "

36 Reviews Hide Reviews



GrubHub reviews in your neighborhood

  • “Subsconcious is excellent when they get your order right. Oftentimes I'll order a salad, and it will be missing entire ingredients. For example, today I ordered one with grilled chicken (a two dollar add on), and halfway through - I've yet to find it. Also, they call when they are laking ingredients or items - which is nice - but the substitution they send is not always what I asked for. An example - today I ordered a diet peach tea - and then they said they would send a diet lemon one - they sent a regular lemon one. So they're pretty hit or miss. Its nice to have a decent salad that can be delivered in the neighborhood - but its also frustrating when the order gets messed up (I would say a good 40-50% of the time). ”


    2 reviews and 452 orders
  • “Go in so the dumb chicks behind the phone can't give you an attitude problem. I don't know what customer service you are practicing, but you NEVER tell the other person on the phone that the issue was THEIR fault, especially when it wasn't. My coworker used my grubhub for the free drink i got through yummy rummy. She did not change the address to our job. No big deal, I called and, even though she was so unprofessional, I gave the address to have it changed. They cancelled the order. I call back and ask two hours later where is our food? They cancelled again, because she didn't write my number OR address down. Isn't that your ONE job function? Any other time, I call from a number and they know exactly the address because they have caller ID. I only order from work, and we order from here at least twice a week. ”


    2 reviews and 112 orders
  • “Decent food. Sometimes take way too long to deliver. It's been an ongoing issue.”


    1 reviews and 0 orders
  • “Fine food: quick delivery: happy delivery boy....Great Chili and Salads...First rate !! ”


    1 reviews and 0 orders
  • “AWESOME place for great subs and salads! Delivery usually arrives faster than estimated! ”


    1 reviews and 0 orders
  • “They forgot to put the feta cheese on the salad. The lettuce was wilted, but the taste was good.”


    1 reviews and 170 orders
  • “they did not deliver half the food that was ordered, when rang they said they would deliver the food that was forgotten but they never did”


    1 reviews and 5 orders
  • “ZERO stars! Was a regular customer but will NEVER EVER order from them again. An item was left off of my order. When I called to let them know, I was given a very hard time over THEIR omission and they refused to deliver the missing item. Fortunately Grubhub credited me. As for Subconscious, their rude service, unprofessionalism and short-sightedness has lost my business. ”


    1 reviews and 94 orders
  • “I love their salad bar! It's very generous. Fast service too. ”


    2 reviews and 304 orders
  • “When we got the sandwich and salad, they were good. However, they called about the sandwich and didn't have the ingredients required to make it or two backup sandwiches. Then, they called back because they didn't have all of the ingredients ordered for the salad. In the end, I ate and it was good. But not getting the food we ordered isn't great.”


    15 reviews and 71 orders
  • “Food was delicious ”


    3 reviews and 177 orders
  • “quick, delicious, and super affordable. Plus, an incredibly robust menu.”


    9 reviews and 267 orders
  • “Cheap prices, quick delivery, good food! ”


    2 reviews and 0 orders
  • “This will definitely be the last time that I order food from Subsconscious. My wife and I have ordered sandwiches from there since they opened. The quality, and delivery has slowly gone downhill, but they were still pretty good. Until today. We placed an order for lunch at 1250. We received the confirmation email saying that the delivery would be 30 to 50 minutes. This has always been what their email confirmation has said. The time is usually between 15 and 20 minutes. We waited over an hour before calling to ask about our order. We were dismissed by the woman who answered the phone dismissed my concern, simply telling me that "he has left." So we waited another 20 minutes, still no food. I called again, was dismissed a second time, simply being told that "he's not back yet." Finally, over an hour and a half after we ordered, our order arrived. They'd forgotten one of the drinks that we'd ordered. So we ended up with two cold, soggy, sandwiches, and a warm soda.”


    1 reviews and 0 orders
  • “totally sent a sandwhich on a brick hard, sand dry hero - then had the nerve ti pitch a fit and refuse a refund as if I was absurd for not eating the stale sandwich. Also walked by and saw a huge GRADE PENDING on their door. Well obviously. ”


    8 reviews and 0 orders
  • “I was quoted 35-50 minutes and it took over 70 minutes to receive my order. I live only 2 blocks away from the restaurant. My food arrived cold and packed improperly. The juice was laying on the bottom of the bag on it's side with the toast on top and my order on top of that. Now my toast is cold from being up against the cold juice, and with an unbalanced base (the juice), the plate was tipped in transport spilling the egg yolk inside the bag. Horrible delivery. I refuse to ever order from this restaurant again. Don't waste your time. ”


    1 reviews and 0 orders
  • “These guys called me twice last time I ordered -- once to tell me they didn't have the orange juice and could they substitute the orange pineapple (fine), then to tell me they didn't have the orange pineapple and did I want anything else that equaled $4 exactly. Then they offered a $4 credit. Then, when I called to take advantage of the $4 credit, they told me that my order didn't reach the minimum for delivery. This is customer service 101: if you screw something up, you go as far as you can to fix it. They're not willing to do that. Decent food, bad ethics.”


    14 reviews and 0 orders
  • “Subs are decent but they forgot half my order. When I called them with the delivery man (because the delivery man didn't have a phone???), the first thing the woman said is, "It's your fault. You must be wrong." Nice customer service. I politely said, "No, your delivery man is here holding the printout and it clearly says two subs. I already paid, and paid $24 at that," to which she continued to insist it was my error. Finally, the woman answering the phone got her manager and realized THEY made mistake because THEY didn't read the order right and THEY didn't cook the second sandwich. She ended up mildly apologizing and offering no compensation or incentive to order again. They also left items on my sandwich, such as lettuce and ketchup, that I had clearly stated we didn't want. Not rocket science to: (1) quickly look over the items going into your delivery bag before sending out the delivery man and (2) counting the items against the printout. Oy vey.”


    6 reviews and 108 orders
  • “Good sandwiches at a good price.”


    11 reviews and 174 orders
  • “Delicious food, good service. ”


    1 reviews and 0 orders
  • “they are good at making sandwiches, just never read any specifics, I specifically asked for the fries and onion rings to be well done, because they are always soggy, and again soggy mush with no seasoning. really good italian hero ”


    4 reviews and 415 orders
  • “BLT was banging, bacon was really good. Grilled cheese was also delicious. Faster than expected delivery time; would recommend.”


    1 reviews and 17 orders
  • “i ordered a turkey sandwich but got no turkey and when i called to say something about it, i was hung up on...”


    1 reviews and 2 orders
  • “I guess you have to stick to the sandwiches. I ordered a chicken burrito it is disgusting as I sit here staring at chickpeas, carrots and corn NOT indicated in the description but what was indicated wasn't included such as sour cream and pico de gallo. Disappointed. Yuck. ”


    5 reviews and 0 orders
  • “I love subconscious; I hate the fact they close so early on saturdays. ”


    1 reviews and 32 orders
  • “Fast, efficient and tast delivery. A little pricey but you get what you pay for. ”


    4 reviews and 20 orders
  • “My sandwich (lemon chicken) was fine as has been the food other times I have ordered. The coffe has been mysterious, gross and disappointing. I ordered a cappuccino and it tasted like salty hot chocolate, and not in a good way. ”


    4 reviews and 0 orders
  • “Chicken Philly was delicious - I'll definitely be back to try another sandwich. Create-your-own-salad was fresh and full of ingredients (not lettuce-heavy). Delivery was quick.”


    1 reviews and 52 orders
  • “Great Subs!”


    3 reviews and 34 orders
  • “I. LOVE. THIS. RESTAURANT. I've ordered from Subsconcious twice and I am yet to get something I don't like. The fries are amazing, the burritos to die for, and don't even get me started on the cheese steaks. So yummy. Eat from here, you won't regret it. ”


    13 reviews and 154 orders

Full Hours, Cuisines, More Info... Hide Extra Info


Subsconscious Delivery

Sandwiches, Healthy, Salads, Breakfast, Subs, Bagels, Lunch, Cheesesteaks, Dinner


  • Monday 8:00 AM - 8:00 PM
  • Tuesday 8:00 AM - 8:00 PM
  • Wednesday 8:00 AM - 8:00 PM
  • Thursday 8:00 AM - 8:00 PM
  • Friday 8:00 AM - 8:00 PM
  • Saturday 9:00 AM - 7:00 PM
  • Sunday 9:00 AM - 7:00 PM


1625 Amsterdam Ave New York, NY


Open Now

8:00 AM - 8:00 PM


Delivery Free

Minimum $ 12.00


Show map