1. Search
  2. Pick a Restaurant
  3. Build Your Meal
  4. → Order & Eat!
  • Pay with a credit card, PayPal, or cash at the door.
  • Tip online.
  • 24/7 Customer Care.
  • Free to use.
  • Get text updates about your order.
  • Saves your payment info.
  • Remembers your special instructions.
  • Saves your addresses.

Pizza Supreme isn't taking orders right now.

Pizza Supreme Menu

  • Popular Items

    • Neapolitan Pie with Cheese $13.65
    • Chicken Cutlet Hot Hero $8.25
    • Square Pizza Slice $1.75
    • Neapolitan Pizza Slice $2.26
    • Pepperoni Pin Wheels $2.19
    • Garlic Knots $1.25+
    • 6 Mozzarella Sticks $5.25
    • Salad $5.80+
    • Penne ala Vodka $9.00
    • Square Pie with Cheese $14.45
  • Beverages

    • 1-Liter Soda $2.25
    • 2-Liter Soda $2.75
  • Appetizers

    • Garlic Knots $1.25+
    • Pepperoni Pin Wheels $2.19
    • Broccoli Pin Wheels $2.19
    • Spinach Pin Wheels $2.19
    • 6 Mozzarella Sticks $5.25
  • Salads

    • Salad $5.80+
    • Antipasto Salad $8.95+
    • Salad with Chicken $10.35+
  • Square Pies

    • Square Pie with Cheese $14.45
    • Square Pie with Extra Cheese $16.95
    • Square Pie with Mushrooms $16.95
    • Square Pie with Pepperoni $16.95
    • Square Pie with Sausage $16.95
    • Square Pie with Onion $16.95
    • Square Pie with Garlic $16.95
    • Square Pie with Meatball $16.95
    • Square Pie with Fresh Peppers $16.95
  • Neopolitan Pies

    • Neapolitan Pie with Cheese $13.65
    • Neapolitan Pie with Extra Cheese $16.15
    • Neapolitan Pie with Mushrooms $16.15
    • Neapolitan Pie with Pepperoni $16.15
    • Neapolitan Pie with Sausage $16.15
    • Neapolitan Pie with Onion $16.15
    • Neapolitan Pie with Garlic $16.15
    • Neapolitan Pie with Meatball $16.15
    • Neapolitan Pie with Fresh Peppers $16.15
    • Neapolitan White Pie $17.85
    • Neapolitan White Pie with Broccoli $19.95
    • Neapolitan White Pie with Spinach $19.95
    • Neapolitan Vegetable Pie $19.95
    • Neapolitan Pie with Fried Chicken $21.00
    • Neapolitan Pie with Buffalo Chicken $21.00
  • Pizza Slices

    • Square Pizza Slice $1.75
    • Neapolitan Pizza Slice $2.26
    • Chicken Pizza Slice $3.80
    • Buffalo Chicken Pizza Slice $3.80
    • Chicken and Broccoli Slice $4.10
    • Veggie Pizza Slice $3.45
    • White Pizza Slice $3.02
    • Slice of White Pizza with Broccoli $3.26
    • Slice of White Pizza with Spinach $3.26
  • Hero Sandwiches

    • Veal Cutlet Hot Hero $9.25
    • Chicken Cutlet Hot Hero $8.25
    • Sausage and Peppers Hot Hero $7.75
    • Eggplant Hot Hero $7.25
    • Pepper and Egg Hot Hero $7.25
    • Meatball Hot Hero $7.25
    • Sausage Hot Hero $7.25
    • Cold Italian Hero $7.50
  • Hot Dishes

    • Veal Cutlet Parmigiana $14.50 With a side of pasta.
    • Chicken Cutlet Parmigiana $12.10 With a side of pasta.
    • Eggplant Parmigiana $11.25 With a side of pasta.
  • Pasta

    • Pasta with Tomato Sauce $7.50
    • Pasta with Meat $10.50 Choice of meatballs or sausage.
    • Lasagna $9.95
    • Stuffed Shells $9.00
    • Ravioli $9.00
    • Baked Ziti $9.00
    • Penne ala Vodka $9.00
    • Penne ala Vodka with Chicken $14.50
    • Penne ala Vodka with Chicken, Broccoli and Spinach $16.50
    • Penne with Chicken, Broccoli and Spinach $14.50
  • Calzones and Rolls

    • Ricotta & Mozzarella Calzone $5.10
    • Ricotta, Mozzarella & Ham Calzone $5.65
    • Veggie Roll $5.95
    • Sausage & Pepper Roll $5.95
    • Meatball Roll $5.95
    • Chicken Roll $7.15
  • Side Orders

    • Side of Meatballs $7.25
    • Side of Sausage $7.25

Pizza Supreme isn't taking orders right now.

Pizza Supreme Menu

15 Ratings

"I love the square pizza extra cheese! By far one of my favorite p … See more. "

5 Reviews Hide Reviews

Close
Pizza Supreme

Pizza Supreme

GrubHub reviews in your neighborhood

  • “I love the square pizza extra cheese! By far one of my favorite places. Delivery guy is very nice , friendly and prompt!”

    Laura

    3 reviews and 35 orders
  • “The order was not right”

    David

    1 reviews and 3 orders
  • “Penne alla vodka is very good, and the chicken parm hero is probably the best you could get around.”

    Mike

    1 reviews and 28 orders
  • “Awesome like always!”

    Catherine

    1 reviews and 41 orders
  • “Veal parm hero met my expectations, side salad exceeded my expectations, and the fast delivery (I'm on Hofstra campus) blew me away! I'll call them back soon.”

    Michael

    6 reviews and 12 orders

Full Hours, Cuisines, More Info... Hide Extra Info

Close

Pizza Supreme Delivery

Pizza, Sandwiches, American, Lunch, Dinner

Hours

  • Monday 11:00 AM - 9:00 PM
  • Tuesday 11:00 AM - 9:00 PM
  • Wednesday 11:00 AM - 9:00 PM
  • Thursday 11:00 AM - 9:00 PM
  • Friday 11:00 AM - 9:00 PM
  • Saturday 11:00 AM - 9:00 PM
  • Sunday Closed

5162284300

678 Stewart Ave Garden City, NY

Sunday

Not taking orders at this time.

Closed

Delivery

Delivery Free

Minimum $ 10.00

Pickup

Show map