1. Search
  2. Pick a Restaurant
  3. Build Your Meal
  4. → Order & Eat!
  • Pay with a credit card, PayPal, or cash at the door.
  • Tip online.
  • 24/7 Customer Care.
  • Free to use.
  • Get text updates about your order.
  • Saves your payment info.
  • Remembers your special instructions.
  • Saves your addresses.

Build your meal by clicking whatever sounds good.

Papa John's Pizza - Upper East Side Menu

Trending Items

Suggested Meals

    • $23.00 Extra Large 3 Topping Pizza Canadian Bacon, Italian Sausage, Onions
    • $16.50 The Meats Pizza 12" Medium Original-Crust Pizza
    • $8.50 Papa's Wings Spicy Buffalo Sauce, Ranch Dipping Sauce
    • $6.00 Cinnamon Knots
    • $14.50 Create Your Own Pizza 10" Small Original-Crust Pizza, Pepperoni, Pineapple
    • $0.75 Ranch Sauce
  • Popular Items

    • Chicken Poppers $5.00+
    • Cheesesticks $8.00 Fresh original dough topped with our pizza sauce and 100% real mozzarella cheese. 10" cheesesticks. Served with one dipping sauce.
    • Papa's Wings $8.50 Served with one dipping sauce.
    • BBQ Chicken and Bacon Pizza $14.00+ BBQ sauce topped with grilled all-white chicken, bacon and fresh-sliced onions.
    • Cinnapie $4.00 Fresh original dough topped with sweet cinnamon filling and brown sugar streusel and drizzled with white icing.
    • 20 oz. Bottles $1.66
    • Create Your Own Pizza $0+
    • Medium 3 Topping Pizza and Side $22.00 One medium three topping pizza and your choice of side.
    • Large 3 Topping Pizza and 2-Liter $22.00 One large three topping pizza and your choice of 2 liter soda.
    • Small 2 Topping Pizza and Side $18.00 One small two topping pizza with your choice of side.
  • Delivery Fee Information

    • The delivery fee is not a tip distributed to service staff. Please reward your delivery professional for their awesomeness. $0+
  • Specials

    • Large 3 Topping Pizza and 2-Liter $22.00 One large three topping pizza and your choice of 2 liter soda.
    • Small 2 Topping Pizza and Side $18.00 One small two topping pizza with your choice of side.
    • Extra Large 3 Topping Pizza $23.00
    • Large 3 Topping Pizza and Side $27.00 One large three topping pizza and your choice of side.
    • Medium 3 Topping Pizza and Side $22.00 One medium three topping pizza and your choice of side.
    • 2 Large 3 Topping Pizzas and 2 Liter $38.00 Two large three topping pizzas and your choice of 2 liter.
  • Beverages

    • 20 oz. Bottles $1.66
    • 2 Liters $2.75
    • Aquafina Bottle $1.66
  • Create Your Own Pizza

    • Create Your Own Pizza $0+
  • John's Favorite Pizza

    • The Meats Pizza $14.00+ Pepperoni, sausage, been, bacon and Canadian bacon.
    • Spinach Alfredo Pizza $14.00+ Rich and creamy garlic Parmesan Alfredo sauce blended with spinach.
    • BBQ Chicken and Bacon Pizza $14.00+ BBQ sauce topped with grilled all-white chicken, bacon and fresh-sliced onions.
    • Garden Fresh Pizza $14.00+ Baby portabella mushrooms, black olives, fresh-sliced onions, green peppers and diced Roma tomatoes.
    • Spicy Italian Pizza $14.00+ Pepperoni and a double portion of spicy Italian sausage.
    • Tuscan 6 Cheese Pizza $14.00+ Blend of mozzarella, Parmesan, Romano, asiago, provolone, fontina and Italian herb seasonings.
    • The Works Pizza $14.00+ Pepperoni, Canadian bacon, spicy Italian sausage, black olives, baby portabella mushrooms, fresh-sliced onions and green peppers.
  • Sides

    • Cheesesticks $8.00 Fresh original dough topped with our pizza sauce and 100% real mozzarella cheese. 10" cheesesticks. Served with one dipping sauce.
    • Papa's Wings $8.50 Served with one dipping sauce.
    • Garlic Parmesan Breadsticks $7.00 Fresh original dough topped with our special garlic sauce and Parmesan Italian seasonings. Served with one dipping sauce.
    • Breadsticks $6.50 Fresh original dough baked to a golden brown. Served with one dipping sauce.
    • Chicken Poppers $5.00+
    • Pizza Sauce $0.75 One cup.
    • Ranch Sauce $0.75 One cup.
    • Honey Mustard Sauce $0.75 One cup.
    • Cheese Sauce $0.75 One cup.
    • Bleu Cheese Sauce $0.75 One cup.
    • Buffalo Hot Sauce $0.75 One cup.
    • Tangy BBQ Sauce $0.75 One cup.
    • Pepperonicinis $0.75
    • Garlic Knots $6.00
  • Dessert

    • Cinnapie $4.00 Fresh original dough topped with sweet cinnamon filling and brown sugar streusel and drizzled with white icing.
    • Cinnamon Knots $6.00
    • Double ChocChip Brownie $7.00
    • Chocolate Chip Cookie $7.00

Build your meal by clicking whatever sounds good.

Papa John's Pizza - Upper East Side Menu

Start a Group Order

Name Your Group Order

129 Ratings

"GREAT SERVICE 5 stars. -Franklin "

55 Reviews Hide Reviews

Close
Papa John's Pizza - Upper East Side

Papa John's Pizza - Upper East Side

GrubHub reviews in your neighborhood

  • “What can I say, it's always good. ”

    Karrie

    4 reviews and 173 orders
  • “ Well in my experience, I alwasy got delivery within 25 minutes and pizza was always delievered hot and perfect. Fast and reliable delivery and good pizza too.”

    Peter

    8 reviews and 876 orders
  • “overpriced and not very tastey but they deliver late night”

    Thomas

    12 reviews and 109 orders
  • “Prompt, service, good food. I have never had any food or deliver issues and I order often!”

    Stephanie

    1 reviews and 83 orders
  • “The cheesy bread is what it is. A bit pricey in my opinion, and definitely does not come with enough dipping sauce, so you have to pay for more... but when you get a craving, you follow it.”

    Francesca

    3 reviews and 392 orders
  • “I ordered a large pizza through Seamless Web....and the pizza order was placed, made, and delivered hot and fresh to my door within 13 minutes. I live 1 block away from the store - but that's still a record in my book!”

    Kay

    14 reviews and 402 orders
  • “Delivery was quick which i appreciate. Order from one their special deals but not that great of a deal. You still end up paying a lot. Just stick with the pizza and don't order the sides.”

    Terence

    1 reviews and 345 orders
  • “GREAT SERVICE ”

    Franklin

    7 reviews and 153 orders
  • “A really bad experience with this Papa John's location. They claimed there was a delay in the rose from Seamless and then they said they arrived but couldn't get into my building but I live in a town house with direct access to the front door so they clearly lied again! Ultimately I called seamless and they cancelled my order for me. ”

    Alan

    1 reviews and 76 orders
  • “Slow and not reliable”

    ellen

    1 reviews and 215 orders
  • “Sloppy preparation and undercooked.”

    Sina

    1 reviews and 75 orders
  • “I love papa johns but I will never order from this one again. Waited too long for a cold small cheese and Pepsi which the delivery guy forgot then made me come down to get it from him ”

    Amanda

    3 reviews and 207 orders
  • “The delivery guy has taken over an hour to get here and repeatedly got lost around the UES despite my address being on the order. Next time I'll go somewhere else. ”

    Kate

    1 reviews and 121 orders
  • “Quick delivery, recommend if in a pinch”

    Jason

    2 reviews and 304 orders
  • “30-45 minutes actually means over an hour. ”

    Kenny

    1 reviews and 10 orders
  • “They added pepperoni on the pizza when it was never asked for. I'm a vegetarian. It was all over.”

    Hila

    4 reviews and 142 orders
  • “Don't do it! Bad pizza and wrong order.... ”

    Carol

    2 reviews and 108 orders
  • “Definitely not order from here again!!!! Worst place in NYC.”

    Pensiri

    1 reviews and 35 orders
  • “Great pizza”

    Jim

    3 reviews and 32 orders
  • “Its Papa Johns. Its good”

    Pete

    2 reviews and 27 orders
  • “Did not get what I ordered at all- then sat on hold for over 20 mins to sort out- hung up with no resolve - worst place”

    Ashley

    1 reviews and 243 orders
  • “Horrible service !!!!!! Waited over 1 hr for a small pizza ... And when I called the guy couldn't even help me or tell me where's the driver or contact him, didn't apologize and no offense but could not speak English which was difficult to talk to him. ”

    Crystal

    1 reviews and 9 orders
  • “Their delivery is terrible. They are always much later than the promised time.”

    Stephen

    2 reviews and 537 orders
  • “Ordered a pizza from this place and was close to three hours late even after calling in two separate occasions. Requested my money back and they refused. Ended up receiving a cold pizza that was not worth eating at all from a delivery guy that only grunted and didn't a say a word at all. Stay away from this place, not worth your time, money or aggravation.”

    niat

    1 reviews and 87 orders
  • “Good pizza, quick delivery.”

    Scott

    3 reviews and 403 orders
  • “Pizza took over an hour for delivery when the store is three block away from my place and the pizza was cold. I usually like papa johns but that is just not cool. ”

    Marie

    1 reviews and 82 orders
  • “Lives upto their name.”

    Rohit

    10 reviews and 165 orders
  • “Let me tell you about this Papa John's and their refusal to come into my building to deliver my pizza because its "project like". I dont live in the projects. Its a co-op. I've argued with their delivery people, I've argued with the woman at the store. I come home from work I want to sit down and relax. If I want to go down from the 17th floor to the street, I'll go get my own damn pizza. I normally auto-tip but for this Papa John's I tend not to tip at all until they deliver my door. Then again after having yet another incident of the delivery person not wanting to come upstairs I think I wont order from Papa Johns ever again.”

    Noelle

    2 reviews and 324 orders
  • “This was just terrible. The pizza was god awful but the worst part was the 6 inch piece of hair I nearly swallowed. What kind of degenerate bags of crap do you hire that could be so incompetent to not only screw up a fast food pizza but then supply their own hair to the order. The owner may be able to throw a football but his employees sure can't tell their ass from their elbows ”

    chris

    1 reviews and 83 orders
  • “Pizza was mediocre, soft and under-cooked. NY pizza significantly better.”

    Michael

    9 reviews and 183 orders

Full Hours, Cuisines, More Info... Hide Extra Info

Close

Papa John's Pizza - Upper East Side Delivery

Pizza, Late Night, Lunch, Dinner

Hours

  • Monday 10:00 AM - 2:00 AM
  • Tuesday 10:00 AM - 2:00 AM
  • Wednesday 10:00 AM - 2:00 AM
  • Thursday 10:00 AM - 2:00 AM
  • Friday 10:00 AM - 5:00 AM
  • Saturday 10:00 AM - 5:00 AM
  • Sunday 10:00 AM - 2:00 AM

9177223428

1732 2nd Ave New York, NY

Friday

Open Now

10:00 AM - 5:00 AM

Delivery

Delivery $2.25

Minimum $ 10.00

Pickup

Show map