1. Search
  2. Pick a Restaurant
  3. Build Your Meal
  4. → Order & Eat!
  • Pay with a credit card, PayPal, or cash at the door.
  • Tip online.
  • 24/7 Customer Care.
  • Free to use.
  • Get text updates about your order.
  • Saves your payment info.
  • Remembers your special instructions.
  • Saves your addresses.

Papa John's Pizza - Midtown isn't taking orders right now.

Papa John's Pizza - Midtown Menu

  • Popular Items

    • Cinnapie $4.00 Fresh original dough topped with sweet cinnamon filling and brown sugar streusel and drizzled with white icing.
    • 20 oz. Bottles $2.15
    • Aquafina Bottle $2.00
    • Create Your Own Pizza $0+
    • Cheesesticks $8.75 Fresh original dough topped with our pizza sauce and 100% real mozzarella cheese. 10" cheesesticks. Served with one dipping sauce.
    • Papa's Wings $9.50 Served with one dipping sauce.
    • Garlic Parmesan Breadsticks $7.75 Fresh original dough topped with our special garlic sauce and Parmesan Italian seasonings. Served with one dipping sauce.
    • BBQ Chicken and Bacon Pizza $15.00+ BBQ sauce topped with grilled all-white chicken, bacon and fresh-sliced onions.
    • The Works Pizza $15.00+ Pepperoni, Canadian bacon, spicy Italian sausage, black olives, baby portabella mushrooms, fresh-sliced onions and green peppers.
    • The Meats Pizza $15.00+ Pepperoni, sausage, been, bacon and Canadian bacon.
  • Delivery Fee Information

    • The delivery fee is not a tip distributed to service staff. Please reward your delivery professional for their awesomeness. $0+
  • Specials

    • Large 3 Topping Pizza and 2L $19.00 One large three topping pizza and your choice of 2 liter soda.
    • Small 2 Topping Pizza and Side $16.00 One small two topping pizza with your choice of side.
    • Extra Large 3 Topping Pizza $21.00
    • Large 3 Topping Pizza and Side $24.00 One large three topping pizza and your choice of side.
    • Medium 3 Topping Pizza and Side $20.00 One medium three topping pizza and your choice of side.
    • 2 Large 3 Topping Pizzas and 2L $35.00 Two large three topping pizzas and your choice of 2 liter.
  • Beverages

    • 20 oz. Bottles $2.15
    • 2 Liters $3.00
    • Aquafina Bottle $2.00
  • Create Your Own Pizza

    • Create Your Own Pizza $0+
  • John's Favorite Pizza

    • The Meats Pizza $15.00+ Pepperoni, sausage, been, bacon and Canadian bacon.
    • Spinach Alfredo Pizza $15.00+ Rich and creamy garlic Parmesan Alfredo sauce blended with spinach.
    • BBQ Chicken and Bacon Pizza $15.00+ BBQ sauce topped with grilled all-white chicken, bacon and fresh-sliced onions.
    • Garden Fresh Pizza $15.00+ Baby portabella mushrooms, black olives, fresh-sliced onions, green peppers and diced Roma tomatoes.
    • Spicy Italian Pizza $15.00+ Pepperoni and a double portion of spicy Italian sausage.
    • Tuscan 6 Cheese Pizza $15.00+ Blend of mozzarella, Parmesan, Romano, asiago, provolone, fontina and Italian herb seasonings.
    • The Works Pizza $15.00+ Pepperoni, Canadian bacon, spicy Italian sausage, black olives, baby portabella mushrooms, fresh-sliced onions and green peppers.
  • Sides

    • Cheesesticks $8.75 Fresh original dough topped with our pizza sauce and 100% real mozzarella cheese. 10" cheesesticks. Served with one dipping sauce.
    • Papa's Wings $9.50 Served with one dipping sauce.
    • Garlic Parmesan Breadsticks $7.75 Fresh original dough topped with our special garlic sauce and Parmesan Italian seasonings. Served with one dipping sauce.
    • Breadsticks $7.25 Fresh original dough baked to a golden brown. Served with one dipping sauce.
    • Chicken Poppers $7.50+
    • Pizza Sauce $0.85 One cup.
    • Ranch Sauce $0.85 One cup.
    • Honey Mustard Sauce $0.85 One cup.
    • Cheese Sauce $0.85 One cup.
    • Bleu Cheese Sauce $0.85 One cup.
    • Buffalo Hot Sauce $0.85 One cup.
    • Tangy BBQ Sauce $0.85 One cup.
    • Pepperonicinis $0.85
  • Dessert

    • Cinnapie $4.00 Fresh original dough topped with sweet cinnamon filling and brown sugar streusel and drizzled with white icing.

Papa John's Pizza - Midtown isn't taking orders right now.

Papa John's Pizza - Midtown Menu

71 Ratings

"quick and good 5 stars. -Meesha "

31 Reviews Hide Reviews

Close
Papa John's Pizza - Midtown

Papa John's Pizza - Midtown

GrubHub reviews in your neighborhood

  • “Usually my go to pizza place this time the wings were not very spicy and didn't have much sauce ”

    Ian T.D.

    2 reviews and 0 orders
  • “perfect! great prices and fast delivery. consistently good!”

    Anna Meghan

    2 reviews and 0 orders
  • “I don't know if something perhaps changed since the last reviews, but I've ordered from here several times. I always get exactly what i ordered, and extremely fast/hot.”

    Ryan

    8 reviews and 0 orders
  • “Waited for 2 hrs and no pizza. Called the store and was told they were closed. Once i told them i have a pizza ordered and paid for, he said he'd call back, but no call back. They ended up delivering the pizza at 12:30am. Who the hell wants pizza that late 3hrs after i ordered. I'd rather get my money back at that point. I would not recommend this place even to my worst enemy”

    taichi

    1 reviews and 0 orders
  • “After 1 hour i call them and the guy say that he had to cancel my order because they are closing now. After one hour. ”

    Shara

    1 reviews and 0 orders
  • “Waited almost an hour for my food to arrive only to have it missing an order. When I called the restaurant, the gentleman just berated me about the fact that they're busy and will put in another order. I told him I didn't want to wait another hour just for cheese bread, so I just asked for a refund. The wings were mediocre at best but I'll never order from here again.”

    Brandon

    2 reviews and 0 orders
  • “They sent me a thin crust when I ordered a regular pie. They didn't bring the soda I ordered, and didn't include the ranch dressing I ordered. Fail. ”

    charles

    1 reviews and 0 orders
  • “The absolute worst. Not only did I wait two hours for my delivery, but when i called to check on it, no one answered the phone and I had to listen to the hold music for 10 minutes. I ordered at 11:15pm and it just arrived now at 1:19am and when it arrived I was missing part of my order and my pizza was cold. ”

    Arden

    2 reviews and 0 orders
  • “Haven't even received my order, but the delivery time alone gives this place an F. 30 minutes ago when i called they were "on the way" and now they are "5 minutes away". too many other pizza places in nyc to deal with this in the future.”

    Ruth

    2 reviews and 0 orders
  • “As bad as Domino's but with worse service”

    Joseph

    2 reviews and 0 orders
  • “quick and good ”

    Meesha

    9 reviews and 116 orders
  • “The pizza took forever. Was cold when it got here. The delivery man wanted money and I had to explain to him twice that I paid on here. And tipped. I asked for light sauce and that did not happen. I also paid for extra peppers and they were not included. Needless to say. I won't be ordering from papa johns anymore. ”

    Joseph

    1 reviews and 0 orders
  • “Don't ever use these guys ”

    julia

    1 reviews and 0 orders
  • “Food is wonderful. Delivery service is TERRIBLE. The last three deliveries have taken well over an hour when the seamlessweb delivery time is 15-30 min.”

    Mary

    1 reviews and 0 orders
  • “Very good!”

    Nilsa

    1 reviews and 38 orders
  • “Eh. One of the cheaper pizza places but they're ridiculously bad with delivery. Only place ever to have gotten lost getting to my place and then made me go outside my building to find him...”

    Michelle

    13 reviews and 0 orders
  • “I hadn't had Papa John's since college and I suddenly got a craving for the cheese sticks. I can't explain it - I just had to order. The delivery estimate was 60-75 minutes (ordered just before 9pm on Friday night) which was a little concerning given the other reviews which said delivery was much longer but when a craving takes over, you have to just go for it. It took a few minutes before the order was confirmed and then about 20 minutes later it was here. I couldn't believe it. I wish I had cash on me so I could tip the delivery guy more. He was pretty funny too. I still feel bad about that - he earned it! Quality was standard for Papa Johns. I tried the chicken bites but they came with no sauce and I didn't have any hot sauce on hand (I know! What was I thinking?) so those were pretty bland. The cheese sticks were exactly what I remembered and that dipping butter sauce stuff - oh man. I am mildly ashamed but it really hit the spot!”

    Erik

    6 reviews and 0 orders
  • “I order a small pizza and I did not receive the pizza until 40 minutes after the set time of delivery. Also, my pizza was cold. I will not be ordering from Papa John's again.”

    Alessandra

    1 reviews and 50 orders
  • “Good value. ”

    Diane

    4 reviews and 0 orders
  • “Delivery is verrrrrry slow. ”

    patrick

    2 reviews and 0 orders
  • “Food is great, but this time around they got my address mixed up and took over 2 hours to deliver it :(”

    Alyssa

    1 reviews and 0 orders
  • “Quick delivery and good pizza.”

    Lauren

    5 reviews and 0 orders
  • “I ordered at 12:40pm, it got delivered at 2:15pm...When I called, the staff at PJ's pizza said they did not get my seamless order until 1:30p, so something is wrong somewhere. Having said that, my pizza tasted good.”

    Julius

    1 reviews and 0 orders
  • “I live in the area and this was the first time I tried Papa John's. I was very happy with it! Better than Dominos and overall, not bad pizza!”

    jon

    6 reviews and 0 orders
  • “dont' expect greatness, the pizza is mediocre. however the garlic sauce is addictive and when starving, the pizza still hits the spot!”

    Victoria

    1 reviews and 0 orders
  • “I love this pizza. We had a bacon, mushroom, pepperoni combination. It was so good that we ate it all even though we ordered planning to save pizza for the next day. For people who have not ordered from PJP, it's noteworthy that it comes with a garlic butter sauce, so that you can dip in the last bites of pizza crust and get more flavor out of it.”

    Andres

    1 reviews and 0 orders
  • “Yum yum yum it's my favorite pizza. It's cheap and reliable and you know they're lying about their calorie contents but it's cool.”

    Michelle

    8 reviews and 0 orders
  • “Slow delivery and missing breadsticks. They were not willing to send delivery person back when we called to complain.”

    Elizabet

    1 reviews and 0 orders
  • “If you eat papa johns and you live anywhere in NYC or long island, you should be ashamed of yourself. This is barely food. I wouldn't feed this slop to my dog ”

    Jeff

    14 reviews and 0 orders
  • “Last time I ordered I left strict instruction to CALL, but instead they rang our Emergency Service bell downstairs. This time I had to wait outside for them to deliver. I waited politely for 40 minutes, at which point I called, and they said they should be right there. I called again 10 minutes later, and they said they will be there in 5 minutes. Another 10 minutes and I call again, this time asking to speak to a manager, I get put on hold and spent a good 15 minutes on hold before I hang up. My pizza still is NOT here, and it's now been close to 1 hour and a half. This is unacceptable!”

    Alexandru

    1 reviews and 0 orders

Full Hours, Cuisines, More Info... Hide Extra Info

Close

Papa John's Pizza - Midtown Delivery

Pizza, Lunch, Dinner

Hours

  • Monday 10:00 AM - 11:50 PM
  • Tuesday 10:00 AM - 11:50 PM
  • Wednesday 10:00 AM - 11:50 PM
  • Thursday 10:00 AM - 11:50 PM
  • Friday 10:00 AM - 11:50 PM
  • Saturday 10:00 AM - 11:50 PM
  • Sunday 10:00 AM - 11:50 PM

212-252-9500

12 E 37th St New York, NY

Monday

Not taking orders at this time.

10:00 AM - 11:50 PM

Delivery

Delivery $2.25

Minimum $ 12.00

Pickup

Show map