1. Search
  2. Pick a Restaurant
  3. Build Your Meal
  4. → Order & Eat!
  • Pay with a credit card, PayPal, or cash at the door.
  • Tip online.
  • 24/7 Customer Service.
  • Free to use.
  • Get text updates about your order.
  • Saves your payment info.
  • Remembers your special instructions.
  • Saves your addresses.
Mr. Pies
516-303-9360
3255 Sunrise Hwy Wantagh NY 11793
13
4.0769
Pizza and pasta was awesome! Will buy from again!
5
5
Pizza Sandwiches Italian Pasta Calzones

Mr. Pies isn't taking orders right now.

Mr. Pies Menu

  • Popular Items

    • Pasta with Cavatelli $12.95 In garlic and oil. Served with house salad, bread and cannoli.
    • Meatball Parmesan Hero $6.95
    • 18" Large Cheese Pie $11.95
    • Sicilian Pizza $13.95
    • Mozzarella Sticks $6.95 Served with tomato sauce.
    • Garlic Knots $2.50+ .
    • Buffalo Wings $8.95 Served with celery and blue cheese.
    • Garlic Bread with Mozzarella $3.95
    • Eggplant Roll $5.50 Served with side of sauce.
    • Cheese Calzone $5.95 Served with a side of sauce.
  • Menu Coupons

    • Buy 10 Pizzas and Get the 11th Free Pickup Special (Pickup Only) $159.50
    • Mr. Pies Special Combo #1 (Pickup Only) $21.95 Large pizza, large house salad, 12 garlic knots and a 20 oz. Coke.
    • Mr. Pies Special Combo #2 (Pickup Only) $30.95 Large pizza, one meatball Parmesan, one chicken Parmesan and one two-liter Coke.
    • Mr. Pies Special Combo #3 (Pickup Only) $35.95 Two chicken Parmesan dinners over pasta, one large house salad, one meatball hero and a two-liter Coke.
  • Mr. Pies Homemade Pizza

    • 18" Large Cheese Pie $11.95
    • Sicilian Pizza $13.95
    • Grandma Pizza $14.95 Thin crust with marinara and mozzarella.
    • Baked Ziti Pizza $16.95 Ziti with tomato sauce, ricotta and mozzarella.
    • Chicken Bruschetta Pizza $20.95 Diced fried chicken cutlet, fresh tomatoes, diced red onion, fresh chopped basil, fresh mozzarella and balsamic vinegar.
    • Buffalo Chicken Pizza $20.95 Tender pieces of Buffalo chicken with mozzarella.
    • Chicken Marsala Pizza $20.95 Tender pieces of chicken in a marsala wine sauce with mushrooms.
    • Margherita Pizza $16.95 Fresh tomato slices, fresh mozzarella and fresh chopped basil.
    • Veggie Pizza $18.95 Broccoli, mushrooms, onions, peppers, olives, tomato slices and mozzarella.
    • White Pizza $17.95 Ricotta and mozzarella.
    • Mr. Pies Special Pizza $23.95 Pepperoni, sausage, meatballs, onions, peppers, olives and mushrooms.
    • House Special Pizza $23.95 Artichoke, spinach and roasted garlic with a white sauce.
  • Appetizers

    • Fried Calamari $8.95 Served with tomato sauce.
    • Buffalo Calamari $9.95
    • Buffalo Wings $8.95 Served with celery and blue cheese.
    • Chicken Fingers and Fries $8.95 Served with honey mustard.
    • Fried Cheese Ravioli $6.95 Served with tomato sauce.
    • Garlic Knots $2.50+ .
    • Garlic Bread $2.95
    • Garlic Bread with Mozzarella $3.95
    • Mozzarella Sticks $6.95 Served with tomato sauce.
    • Zucchini Sticks $6.95 Served with tomato sauce.
    • Artichoke Piccata $9.95 Lemon, butter, wine and capers.
    • Bruschetta $7.95 Chopped tomatoes, diced onions and fresh basil on a crustini.
  • Soups

    • French Onion Soup $5.95
    • Pasta Fagioli Soup $4.95
    • New England Clam Chowder Soup $5.95
    • Chicken Tortellini Soup $5.95
  • Salads

    • Caesar Salad $7.95 Romaine lettuce, Parmesan cheese, homemade croutons and Caesar dressing.
    • House Salad $6.95 Lettuce, tomato, onion, cucumbers, peppers and carrots, with Italian dressing.
    • Tomato and Fresh Mozzarella Salad $8.95 Fresh basil and balsamic vinegar.
    • Greek Salad $8.95 Lettuce, tomatoes, cucumbers, feta cheese, olives, red onions and homemade Greek dressing.
  • Chicken Entrees

    • Chicken Francese $13.95 Lemon, butter and white wine. Served with house salad, your choice of pasta, bread and cannoli.
    • Chicken Marsala $13.95 Marsala wine with mushrooms. Served with house salad, your choice of pasta, bread and cannoli.
    • Chicken Parmesan $13.95 Tomato sauce and mozzarella. Served with house salad, your choice of pasta, bread and cannoli.
    • Chicken Piccata $13.95 Lemon, white wine and capers. Served with house salad, your choice of pasta, bread and cannoli.
    • Chicken Valdestano $14.95 Prosciutto, mushrooms, baked with a marsala wine sauce and topped with cheese. Served with house salad, your choice of pasta, bread and cannoli.
  • Veal Entrees

    • Veal Francese $14.95 Lemon, butter and white wine. Served with house salad, pasta, bread and cannoli.
    • Veal Marsala $14.95 Marsala wine with mushrooms. Served with house salad, pasta, bread and cannoli.
    • Veal Parmesan $14.95 Tomato sauce and mozzarella. Served with house salad, pasta, bread and cannoli.
    • Veal Piccata $14.95 Lemon, white wine and capers. Served with house salad, pasta, bread and cannoli.
    • Veal Valdestano $15.95 Prosciutto, mushrooms, baked with a marsala wine sauce and topped with cheese. Served with house salad, pasta, bread and cannoli.
  • Eggplant Entrees

    • Eggplant Parmigiana $10.75 Baked eggplant with tomato sauce and mozzarella.
    • Eggplant Rollatini $11.50 Eggplant rolled with ricotta cheese, topped with tomato sauce and mozzarella.
  • Shrimp Entrees

    • Shrimp Fra Diavolo $15.95 Served with house salad, pasta, bread and cannoli.
    • Shrimp Scampi $15.95 Garlic, oil, white wine, lemon, butter, leeks and mushrooms. Served with house salad, pasta, bread and cannoli.
    • Shrimp Parmesan $15.95 Tomato sauce and mozzarella. Served with house salad, pasta, bread and cannoli.
    • Shrimp Francese $15.95 Served with house salad, pasta, bread and cannoli.
  • Sausage Entrees

    • Sausage and Peppers $10.95
    • Sausage and Peppers Parmigiana $12.50
  • Calzones and More

    • Cheese Calzone $5.95 Served with a side of sauce.
    • Broccoli Roll $5.50 Served with side of sauce.
    • Chicken Roll $5.95 Served with side of sauce.
    • Buffalo Chicken Roll $5.95 Served with side of sauce.
    • Eggplant Roll $5.50 Served with side of sauce.
    • Philly Cheesesteak Roll $6.50 Served with side of sauce.
    • Spinach Roll $5.50 Served with side of sauce.
    • Sausage, Pepper and Onion Roll $5.95 Served with side of sauce.
    • Stromboli $6.95 Filled with pepperoni, ham, salami and mozzarella.
    • Pepperoni Pinwheel $2.95 Served with side of sauce.
    • Broccoli Pinwheel $2.95 Served with side of sauce.
  • Heroes

    • Chicken Parmesan Hero $7.95
    • Eggplant Parmesan Hero $6.95
    • Meatball Parmesan Hero $6.95
    • Shrimp Parmesan Hero $8.95
    • Veal Parmesan Hero $8.95
    • Peppers and Eggs Hero $6.95
    • Potato and Eggs Hero $6.95
    • Sausage, Peppers and Onions Hero $6.95
    • Prime Rib Philly Cheesesteak $9.95 Mushrooms, peppers, onion and provolone cheese.
  • Pastas

    • Pasta with Marinara Sauce $8.95 Served with house salad, bread and cannoli.
    • Pasta with Meatsauce $9.95 Served with house salad, bread and cannoli.
    • Pasta with ala Vodka $10.95 Prosciutto, tomato sauce, vodka and heavy cream. Served with house salad, bread and cannoli.
    • Pasta with Alfredo $11.95 Butter, heavy cream and Parmesan cheese. Served with house salad, bread and cannoli.
    • Pasta with Carbonara $13.95 Prosciutto, onions and peas in cream sauce. Served with house salad, bread and cannoli.
    • Pasta with Clam Sauce $13.95 Choice of red or white sauce. Served with house salad, bread and cannoli.
    • Pasta with Cavatelli $12.95 In garlic and oil. Served with house salad, bread and cannoli.
  • Baked Pastas

    • Baked Ziti $11.95 Served with house salad, bread and cannoli.
    • Baked Ravioli $11.95 Served with house salad, bread and cannoli.
    • Baked Tortellini $10.95 Served with house salad, bread and cannoli.
    • Baked Cavatelli $12.95 Mozzarella and ricotta. Served with house salad, bread and cannoli.
    • Baked Eggplant Parmesan $10.95 Served with house salad, bread and cannoli.
    • Baked Stuffed Shells $11.95 Served with house salad, bread and cannoli.
    • Baked Meat Lasagna $11.95 Served with house salad, bread and cannoli.
    • Baked Eggplant Rollitini $12.95 Served with house salad, bread and cannoli.
  • Kid's Meals

    • Kid's Pasta $5.50 Choice of tomato sauce, butter sauce, meatball or sausage. Comes with a side of bread.
  • Sides

    • Sauteed Broccoli Rabe $5.95
    • Sauteed Spinach $5.95
    • 2 Meatablls $4.95
    • 2 Sausages $4.95
    • French Fries $3.95
    • French Fries with Cheese $4.95
  • Lunch Special

    • Meatball Parmesan Hero Lunch Special $5.00
    • Sausage, Peppers and Onions Lunch Special $5.00
    • Chicken Parmesan Lunch Special $5.00
    • Eggplant Parmesan Lunch Special $5.00
    • Potatoes and Eggs Lunch Special $5.00
    • Spaghetti with Meat Sauce Lunch Special $5.00 Served with a side of bread.
    • Fettucini Alfredo Lunch Special $5.00 Served with a side of bread.
    • Linguini in Garlic and Oil Lunch Special $5.00 Served with a side of bread.
    • Tortellini with Marinara Lunch Special $5.00 Served with a side of bread.
    • Penne ala Vodka Lunch Special $5.00 Served with a side of bread.
  • Desserts

    • New York Cheesecake $3.95
    • Cannoli $2.95

Mr. Pies isn't taking orders right now.

Mr. Pies Menu

13 Ratings

"Pizza and pasta was awesome! Will buy from again! 5 stars. -Mark "

13 Reviews Hide Reviews

Close
Mr. Pies

Mr. Pies

GrubHub reviews in your neighborhood

  • “Everything tested wrong. Almost like getting italian food out of NY. I don't get it. Decent Pizza most of the time but Traditional Italian dishes are just off in taste. Meatballs were not good at all!! Sorry for the negative feedback.”

    Keven

    1 reviews and 52 orders
  • “Pizza and pasta was awesome! Will buy from again!”

    Mark

    1 reviews and 2 orders
  • “First and last time ordering from here. Cold pizza, dry crust, lack of flavor with the sauce´┐Ż.”

    Christopher

    5 reviews and 26 orders
  • “awesome overall”

    Violetta

    1 reviews and 9 orders
  • “delivery took over an hour, pizza was decent, calzone was OK. garlic bread with cheese was probably the best. pretty good, get what you pay for. ”

    XAVIER

    1 reviews and 1 orders
  • “The garlic mozzerella bread is outstanding.”

    Ryan

    1 reviews and 44 orders
  • “I absolutely loved it! I have had a few bad experience with grub hub and the orders coming after 2hours, but the service from here was super fast! They give an abundant amount of food for such reasonable prices! I will be ordering from them more often! They know how to keep their customers happy! ”

    Neha

    1 reviews and 17 orders
  • “Good, fast delivery!!”

    Peter

    9 reviews and 114 orders
  • “The penne alla vodka was amazing with onions and proscuitto, just like it's supposed to be! The price was awesome, too! A good amount of pasta with a nice salad (not a crappy salad like you get sometimes when a salad is included), nice warm, soft bread and a freakin full-sized cannoli for 11 bucks! I will definitely be ordering from here again!”

    Heather

    9 reviews and 51 orders
  • “good food but very long wait”

    Monique

    1 reviews and 8 orders
  • “second time ordering and second time we devoured it. Good food!”

    Jim

    1 reviews and 11 orders
  • “Pizza and calamari where really good! (tasted really fresh) I never knew this place was around the street from me and the lowest price in town!! Would recommend!”

    Danielle

    1 reviews and 2 orders
  • “The pizza was amazing!! A friend of mine ordered the wings last night and they were delicious! I am going to order it next time!!”

    Danielle

    1 reviews and 2 orders

4 Coupons Hide Coupons

Close
Mr. Pies

GrubHub Coupons

You'll be able to apply a coupon once you've started your order.

Just a heads up - some special offers are only available on certain days and times.

  • Buy 10 Pizzas and Get the 11th Free Pickup Special (Pickup Only)
  • Mr. Pies Special Combo #1 (Pickup Only)
  • Mr. Pies Special Combo #2 (Pickup Only)
  • Mr. Pies Special Combo #3 (Pickup Only)

Full Hours, Cuisines, More Info... Hide Extra Info

Close

Mr. Pies Delivery

Pizza, Sandwiches, Italian, Pasta, Calzones, Dinner

Hours

  • Monday Closed
  • Tuesday 11:00 AM - 9:00 PM
  • Wednesday 11:00 AM - 9:00 PM
  • Thursday 11:00 AM - 9:00 PM
  • Friday 11:00 AM - 10:00 PM
  • Saturday 11:00 AM - 10:00 PM
  • Sunday 12:00 PM - 9:00 PM

516-303-9360

3255 Sunrise Hwy Wantagh, NY

Tuesday

Not taking orders at this time.

11:00 AM - 9:00 PM

Delivery

Delivery Free

Minimum $ 15.00

Pickup

Show map