1. Search
  2. Pick a Restaurant
  3. Build Your Meal
  4. → Order & Eat!
  • Pay with a credit card, PayPal, or cash at the door.
  • Tip online.
  • 24/7 Customer Care.
  • Free to use.
  • Get text updates about your order.
  • Saves your payment info.
  • Remembers your special instructions.
  • Saves your addresses.

Build your meal by clicking whatever sounds good.

Fat Sal's Pizza Menu

Trending Items

Suggested Meals

    • $9.45 Baked Ziti
    • $6.50 Mozzarella Sticks
    • $1.15 Canned Soda Ginger Ale
    • $11.95 Lasagna Add Meatballs
    • $6.00 Chicken Roll
    • $2.95 Sicilian Slice
    • $15.75 Small Cheese Pie
    • $7.00 Italian Combo Hero
    • $3.75 French Fries
  • Popular Items

    • Mozzarella Sticks $6.50
    • Garlic Knots $1.50 Five pieces.
    • Cheeseburger Deluxe $8.25 Served with fries.
    • Italian Combo Hero $7.00
    • Caesar Salad $7.00
    • Large Cheese Pie $17.75 18", eight slices. Mozzarella and our signature tomato sauce.
    • Small Cheese Pie $15.75 16", six slices. Mozzarella and our signature tomato sauce.
    • Cheese Slice $2.75
    • Calzone $5.50
    • Chicken Roll $6.00
  • Beverages

    • Canned Soda $1.15
    • 20 oz. Soda $1.50
    • Water $1.00
    • Snapple Lemon Iced Tea $1.75
  • Appetizers

    • Mozzarella Sticks $6.50
    • Fried Zucchini Sticks $7.00
    • Stuffed Clams $8.45
    • Buffalo Chicken Wings $8.75+ Your choice of sauce.
    • Chicken Fingers $8.00 Served with BBQ sauce.
    • Fried Calamari $12.95
    • French Fries $3.75
    • French Fries with Cheese $4.50
    • Garlic Bread $2.50
    • Garlic Bread with Cheese $3.25
    • Garlic Knots $1.50 Five pieces.
    • Beef Pattie $2.25
    • Beef Pattie with Cheese $2.75
  • Soups

    • Pasta Fagoli $4.95 Served with bread.
    • Tortellini Soup $4.95 Served with bread.
    • Chicken Noodle Soup $4.95 Served with bread.
  • Gourmet Salads

    • Chef Salad $9.95+ Served with your choice of dressing.
    • Cold Antipasto Salad $9.95+ Served with your choice of dressing.
    • Tossed Salad $6.00+ Served with your choice of dressing.
    • Tossed Salad with Breaded Chicken Cutlet $10.95+ Served with your choice of dressing.
    • Grilled Chicken Salad $10.95+ Served with your choice of dressing.
    • Caesar Salad $7.00
  • Pizza

    • Small Cheese Pie $15.75 16", six slices. Mozzarella and our signature tomato sauce.
    • Large Cheese Pie $17.75 18", eight slices. Mozzarella and our signature tomato sauce.
    • Sicilian Pie $19.00 11" x 17". Eight slices.
    • Cheese Slice $2.75
    • Sicilian Slice $2.95
    • Fat Sal's Special Pizza Pie $27.00 18" pizza plus five toppings.
    • Fresh Mozzarella and Basil Pie $24.00
    • Vegetables Pie $25.00
    • Margarita Pie $23.00
  • Calzones and Stuffed Rolls

    • Calzone $5.50
    • Sausage Roll $5.50
    • Chicken Roll $6.00
    • Eggplant Roll $6.00
  • From Our Grill

    • Hamburger $5.75
    • Hamburger Deluxe $7.75 Served with fries.
    • Cheeseburger $6.50
    • Cheeseburger Deluxe $8.25 Served with fries.
  • Pasta

    • Pasta with Garlic and Olive Oil $8.50 Served with your choice of pasta and Italian bread.
    • Pasta with Butter $8.50 Served with your choice of pasta and Italian bread.
    • Pasta with Marinara Sauce $8.00 Served with your choice of pasta and Italian bread.
    • Pasta with Broccoli, Garlic & Olive Oil $9.50 Served with your choice of pasta and Italian bread.
    • Pasta with Meatballs $10.95 Served with your choice of pasta and Italian bread.
    • Pasta with Sausage $10.95 Served with your choice of pasta and Italian bread.
    • Pasta with Meat Sauce $10.95 Served with your choice of pasta and Italian bread.
    • Pasta with Red Clam Sauce $12.95 Served with your choice of pasta and Italian bread.
    • Pasta with White Clam Sauce $12.95 Served with your choice of pasta and Italian bread.
    • Pasta with Baby Clams in Cream Sauce $13.95 Served with your choice of pasta and Italian bread.
    • Pasta ala Vodka $10.95 Served with your choice of pasta and Italian bread.
  • Baked Pasta

    • Baked Ziti $9.45 Served with Italian bread.
    • Lasagna $9.95 Served with Italian bread.
    • Stuffed Shells $9.95 Served with Italian bread.
    • Manicotti $9.95 Served with Italian bread.
    • Cheese Ravioli $9.95 Served with Italian bread.
    • Eggplant Parmesan $11.95 Served with your choice of pasta and Italian bread.
    • Eggplant Rollatini $12.95 Served with your choice of pasta and Italian bread.
    • Spinach Ravioli $11.95 Served with Italian bread.
  • Chicken Entrees

    • Chicken Parmesan $12.95 Served with your choice of pasta and Italian bread.
    • Chicken Marsala $13.95 Served with your choice of pasta and Italian bread.
    • Chicken Francese $13.95 Served with your choice of pasta and Italian bread.
    • Chicken Florentine $13.95 Served with your choice of pasta and Italian bread.
    • Chicken Piccata $13.95 Served with your choice of pasta and Italian bread.
  • Veal Entrees

    • Veal Parmesan $14.45 Served with your choice of pasta and Italian bread.
    • Veal Marsala $14.95 Served with your choice of pasta and Italian bread.
    • Veal Francese $14.95 Served with your choice of pasta and Italian bread.
    • Veal Florentine $14.95 Served with your choice of pasta and Italian bread.
    • Veal Piccata $14.95 Served with your choice of pasta and Italian bread.
  • Seafood Entrees

    • Shrimp Parmesan $14.95 Served with your choice of pasta and Italian bread.
    • Calamari Marinara $13.95 Served with your choice of pasta and Italian bread.
    • Lobster Ravioli $13.95 Served with Italian bread.
  • Sandwiches

    • Veal Hero $10.25
    • Veal Parmigiana Hero $10.95
    • Veal, Peppers and Onions Hero $10.50
    • Veal, Peppers and Onions Parmigiana Hero $11.25
    • Meatball Hero $7.45
    • Meatball Parmigiana Hero $8.45
    • Eggplant Hero $7.45
    • Eggplant Parmigiana Hero $7.95
    • Chicken Hero $8.00
    • Chicken Parmigiana Hero $8.75
    • Chicken Cutlet Hero $8.50 Lettuce, tomato and mayo.
    • Shrimp Hero $9.95
    • Shrimp Parmigiana Hero $10.45
    • Sausage, Peppers and Onions Hero $7.45
    • Sausage, Peppers and Onions Parmigiana Hero $7.95
    • Sausage Hero $7.00
    • Sausage Parmigiana Hero $7.75
    • Cheesesteak Hero $8.45
    • Grilled Chicken Hero $8.45
    • Pepper and Egg Hero $5.50
    • Italian Combo Hero $7.00
  • Wraps

    • Chicken Caesar Salad Wrap $7.50
    • Grilled Chicken Caesar Salad Wrap $7.50
    • Pepper and Eggs Wrap $7.50
    • Italian Combo Wrap $7.50
    • Build Your Own Wrap $7.50
  • Winter Special

    • Winter Special $9.95 Choice of soup and a build your own wrap.

Build your meal by clicking whatever sounds good.

Fat Sal's Pizza Menu

Start a Group Order

Name Your Group Order

142 Ratings

"Love this place; it's inexpensive, delicious, and certain meals w … See more. "

69 Reviews Hide Reviews

Close
Fat Sal's Pizza

Fat Sal's Pizza

GrubHub reviews in your neighborhood

  • “Good pizza for the price, quick delivery, even late. Not the best by any means, but does the trick.”

    Ben

    1 reviews and 22 orders
  • “Love this place; it's inexpensive, delicious, and certain meals will last for a few days. I've never had food that reheats this well, and as someone on a tight budget this helps me so much. I'm really grateful for such good food!”

    Katherine

    2 reviews and 293 orders
  • “delicious pizza and always on time.”

    Kristin

    1 reviews and 125 orders
  • “Foods good... Quick delivery and good prices. But, they won't send you extra stuff even if you want to pay for it! No marinara for garlic knots, even when offered to pay because the owner said so". Come on! ”

    Joshua

    3 reviews and 0 orders
  • “This is my favorite pizza in the area. ”

    Benjamin

    2 reviews and 0 orders
  • “2 points because the food wasn't bad and the delivery time was on point. No more points because delivery guy called when he was outside and didn't deliver it to my door. Wish i hadn't given a 27% tip (I did that because i live a mile away) There were shards of plastic in my chicken parm with spaghetti. I spit out one large piece but I choked on a smaller piece until I swallowed it. Buyer beware. Food was good for late night munchies, just inspect it before eating/ ”

    D.

    3 reviews and 0 orders
  • “Decent pizza”

    matthew

    1 reviews and 0 orders
  • “Great stuff, fast delivery.”

    Olina

    11 reviews and 0 orders
  • “Delivery is faster than stated by Seamless. The pastas are hot and as described. A $2.00 addition of meatball to the pasta is an excellent option to an already-not-overpriced pasta. Mozarella sticks were just OK, and probably should have been a little cheaper, but the nearly free side salad with the entree makes up for this. I believe this is an under-rated delivery place. Can't wait to try the WINGS. ”

    jason

    2 reviews and 0 orders
  • “Always fast delivery and the food is amazing. ”

    Noel

    12 reviews and 0 orders
  • “can I choose no stars? no sauce. just ketchup and bread crumbs thrown on the calamari. horrible. They did include salad dressing although no salad was ordered. Very unpredictable. Solo pizza is MUCH better but no calamari. This place just doesnt care ”

    steve

    5 reviews and 0 orders
  • “not bad, not amazing. but they deliver late and have a decent selection.”

    Gary

    130 reviews and 477 orders
  • “Good pizza, decent wings. Getting 4 stars not because the food was great but it was delivered hot, quick and wasn't a mess. With so many pizza options I will try others as the crust was a bit thick for my taste but it's good. ”

    JT

    1 reviews and 50 orders
  • “good portions and you get your moneys worth!”

    andre

    1 reviews and 0 orders
  • “I order from them all the time. It's the best bang for your buck and it's absolutely delicious. The wings are great, the chicken tenders are delicious, and the chicken parm sub was the size of my forearm with a whole block of cheese on it. Never had slow service and it's always piping hot. My friends love it too!”

    Milo

    3 reviews and 0 orders
  • “Favorite NYC style big slice greasy pizza place. Great pizza, decent prices. ”

    James

    2 reviews and 0 orders
  • “Delivery estimate said 45-60 minutes, and it was here in 20, so that was impressive. The linguine with red clam sauce is good. It isn't amazing, but it is tasty enough. I ordered garlic bread with mozzarella. I was expecting a few pieces, not a whole loaf. I got a lot of it, and it tastes great too!”

    Shawn

    3 reviews and 0 orders
  • “It is unfortunate I need to give Fat Sal's Pizza a bad review because I like the food but on Seamless delivery is just as important. Not only do they often not pay attention to special instructions but last night they didn't call the number I provided and over an hour later I still had the manager arguing with me about the order. The food is good but the aggravation is not worth it.”

    Ron

    2 reviews and 0 orders
  • “Very quick delivery but mediocre/not tasty pizza. It was mostly overcooked and too crunchy, not what I was looking for.”

    Nicole

    5 reviews and 0 orders
  • “Their Chicken Parm was pretty sweet. only 4/5 stars though because they didn't give me free food which everyone could admit would be pretty sweet.”

    Tim

    1 reviews and 0 orders
  • “Ordered, the restaurant confirmed the order and the food never arrived. The restaurant then did not answer phone calls.”

    Alex

    2 reviews and 0 orders
  • “”

    Greg

    1 reviews and 0 orders
  • “Never received my food”

    Nicole

    1 reviews and 0 orders
  • “They're fast and the pizza's always decent. I don't have much more to say but that's more than I can say about other places.”

    Mike

    7 reviews and 0 orders
  • “Good delivery time. Great zeti. I order from them all the time now.”

    DJ

    5 reviews and 240 orders
  • “descent cheap NYC pizza”

    Chris

    1 reviews and 0 orders
  • “Fast, yummy”

    Lindsey

    1 reviews and 0 orders
  • “late and cold.”

    phillip

    1 reviews and 12 orders
  • “Good food, but messed up the order, promised to send missing items and never did so.”

    Chris

    4 reviews and 0 orders
  • “Delicious! Delivery time is average ”

    Linda

    1 reviews and 0 orders

Full Hours, Cuisines, More Info... Hide Extra Info

Close

Fat Sal's Pizza Delivery

Pizza, Sandwiches, American, Pasta, Grill, Late Night, Lunch Specials, Lunch, Calzones, Dinner

Hours

  • Monday 11:00 AM - 11:00 PM
  • Tuesday 11:00 AM - 3:45 AM
  • Wednesday 11:00 AM - 3:45 AM
  • Thursday 11:00 AM - 3:45 AM
  • Friday 11:00 AM - 3:45 AM
  • Saturday 11:00 AM - 3:45 AM
  • Sunday 11:00 AM - 11:00 PM

917-791-5405

201 Ave A New York, NY

Saturday

Open Now

11:00 AM - 3:45 AM

Delivery

Delivery Free

Minimum $ 5.00

Pickup

Show map