1. Search
  2. Pick a Restaurant
  3. Build Your Meal
  4. → Order & Eat!
  • Pay with a credit card, PayPal, or cash at the door.
  • Tip online.
  • 24/7 Customer Care.
  • Free to use.
  • Get text updates about your order.
  • Saves your payment info.
  • Remembers your special instructions.
  • Saves your addresses.

Build your meal by clicking whatever sounds good.

St Nicholas Fish Market Menu

Trending Items

Suggested Meals

    • $6.00 Seafood Salad
    • $5.00 Fish Soup Small
    • $1.50 Soda Diet Coke
    • $10.00 Fried Fish Nugget Fries
    • $8.00 Fried Shrimp Fries
    • $13.95 Shrimps Grilled, Fried Green Plantains
    • $9.95 Fillet of Tilapia Grilled, Fried Green Plantains
    • $1.50 Soda Coke
  • Popular Items

    • Passion Fruit Juice $3.50
    • Homemade Lemonade $3.50
    • Fried Jumbo Shrimp $11.95 Served with your choice of either fried rice, green plantains, sweet plantains or fries.
    • Fried Shrimp $8.00 12 pieces. Served with your choice of either fried rice, green plantains, sweet plantains or fries.
    • Seafood Soup $6.00+
    • Crab Patty $2.00+
    • Lobster Patty $3.00
    • Shrimp Patty $2.00+
    • Side of French Fries $3.00
    • Side of Fried Sweet Plantains $3.00
  • Beverages

    • Soda $1.50
    • Spring Water $1.00
    • Homemade Lemonade $3.50
    • Passion Fruit Juice $3.50
  • Appetizers

    • Crab Patty $2.00+
    • Shrimp Patty $2.00+
    • Lobster Patty $3.00
    • Shrimp on a Stick $6.00
    • Raw Clams (8) $9.00 8 piece.
    • Baked Clams (8) $10.00 8 piece.
  • Soup

    • Fish Soup $5.00+
    • Seafood Soup $6.00+
    • Shrimp Soup $7.00+
    • Boneless Fish Soup $6.95+
  • Rice Soup

    • Shrimp in Rice Soup $12.95
    • Special Seafood in Rice Soup $30.00 Serves two.
    • Fillet Fish in Rice Soup $12.00
    • Fillet Salmon in Rice Soup $14.95
    • Lobster in Rice Soup $22.00
  • Salads

    • Seafood Salad $6.00
    • Conch Meat Salad $7.00
    • Conch Salad $9.00
    • Shrimp Salad $6.00
    • Octopus Salad $7.00
    • Cocktail Shrimp $13.95
  • Rice

    • Rice with Seafood $8.95+ Spanish style.
    • Rice with Shrimp $8.95+ Spanish style.
    • Rice with Octopus $8.95+
    • Rice with Whole Lobster $24.95
    • Rice with Vegetables $4.95+
    • Rice with Squid $8.95+
  • Fried Fish

    • Crab Stick $6.00 Five pieces. Served with your choice of either fried rice, green plantains, sweet plantains or fries.
    • Fried Shrimp $8.00 12 pieces. Served with your choice of either fried rice, green plantains, sweet plantains or fries.
    • Fried Jumbo Shrimp $11.95 Served with your choice of either fried rice, green plantains, sweet plantains or fries.
    • Fried Flounder $9.95 Served with your choice of either fried rice, green plantains, sweet plantains or fries.
    • Fried Scallops $6.00 10 pieces. Served with your choice of either fried rice, green plantains, sweet plantains or fries.
    • Fried Whiting $6.95 Served with your choice of either fried rice, green plantains, sweet plantains or fries.
    • Fried Blue Snapper $8.95 Served with your choice of either fried rice, green plantains, sweet plantains or fries.
    • Fried Fillet of Blue Snapper $10.00 Served with your choice of either fried rice, green plantains, sweet plantains or fries.
    • Fried Fish Nugget $10.00 Served with your choice of either fried rice, green plantains, sweet plantains or fries.
    • Fried Salmon $9.95 Served with your choice of either fried rice, green plantains, sweet plantains or fries.
    • Fried Tilapia (Whole Fish) $9.95 Served with your choice of either fried rice, green plantains, sweet plantains or fries.
    • Fried Fillet of Tilapia $7.95 Served with your choice of either fried rice, green plantains, sweet plantains or fries.
    • Fried Red Snapper $11.95+ Served with your choice of either fried rice, green plantains, sweet plantains or fries.
    • Fried Porgy $7.95+ Served with your choice of either fried rice, green plantains, sweet plantains or fries.
    • Fried Squid $9.95 Served with your choice of either fried rice, green plantains, sweet plantains or fries.
  • Grilled Baked or Steamed Fish

    • Squid $12.95
    • Salmon $12.95
    • Red Snapper $15.00+
    • Fillet of Blue Snapper $10.95
    • Fillet of Salmon $13.95
    • Fillet of Flounder $12.95
    • Shrimps $13.95
    • Fillet of Tilapia $9.95
  • Steamed Seafood

    • Little Neck Clams $13.95
    • Snow Crab $23.95 1 1/2 lb. Seasoned with Old Bay, butter and garlic.
    • Jumbo Shrimp $20.00 1 lb.
    • Seafood Combo $65.00 Squid, jumbo shrimp, snow crab, mussel and lobster.
    • Mussels $12.95 2 lbs.
    • Vegetables $3.00
  • Chef's Specialties

    • Sauteed Conch Meat $16.95
    • Shrimps in Garlic Sauce $13.95
    • Shrimps Creole $13.95
    • Crawfish Meat $25.00 16oz.
    • Crab Meat Creole $14.95
    • Seafood in Garlic Sauce $18.95
    • Squid with Garlic Sauce $13.95
    • Fillet Fish with Shrimp on Top $22.00 Covered with chef's special sauce.
    • Lobster Tail in Garlic Sauce $38.95 16 oz.
    • Lobster Tail with Shrimp on Top $50.00 Covered with chef's special sauce.
    • Octopus with Garlic Sauce $13.95
  • Spaghetti (Italian Style)

    • Jumbo Shrimps with Spaghetti $13.95
    • Squid with Spaghetti $13.95
    • Seafood Spaghetti $18.95
    • Special Spaghetti $35.00 Includes lobster tail, prawn, squid, mussels, etc.
  • Mofongo

    • Masa de Cangrejo Mofongo $15.95 Crabmeat with mofongo.
    • Camarones Mofongo $13.95 Shrimp with mofongo.
    • Fillet Salmon Mofongo $14.95
    • Mariscos Mofongo $17.95 Seafood combo with mofongo.
    • Chicharron de Pescado Mofongo $12.00 Fish chunks with mofongo.
  • Sandwiches

    • Whiting Sandwich $6.95 Two whiting fillets and served with fries.
    • Fillet Tilapia Sandwich $7.95 Served with fries.
    • Flounder Sandwich $7.95 Served with fries.
  • Sides

    • Side of Plantains $3.00
    • Side of French Fries $3.00
    • Side of Fried Sweet Plantains $3.00
    • Side of Fried Rice $3.00
    • Side of White Rice $3.00
    • Side of Mashed Potato $3.00

Build your meal by clicking whatever sounds good.

St Nicholas Fish Market Menu

Start a Group Order

Name Your Group Order

76 Ratings

"Food was great!! The seasoning in the tilapia was to die for. I … See more. "

29 Reviews Hide Reviews

Close
St Nicholas Fish Market

St Nicholas Fish Market

GrubHub reviews in your neighborhood

  • “Food was great!! The seasoning in the tilapia was to die for. I will definitely be ordering from there again.”

    Geralde

    5 reviews and 183 orders
  • “Great food”

    David

    2 reviews and 69 orders
  • “Food was delicious. Had the grilled tilapia which was amazing .Also ordered the lobster empanada and conch , I will say the conch salad could have been chopped smaller and perhaps tenderized. ”

    Nelson

    1 reviews and 72 orders
  • “Great fish!!!”

    Cinthia

    1 reviews and 4 orders
  • “Great food, particularly the fried fish. Great service and delivery. ”

    J

    6 reviews and 717 orders
  • “Love this spot!!!”

    Yensy

    2 reviews and 52 orders
  • “The best seafood restaurant in this area!!! And great prices!!”

    Jericka

    6 reviews and 27 orders
  • “Great food, great prices!!”

    Elizabeth

    1 reviews and 25 orders
  • “OMG! This is really good! Fresh and delicious and full of fresh vegetables and plenty of fish! I got the shrimp patty and fish and rice soup. The shrimp patty is actually an empanada, but the filling, oh, I will go to sleep dreaming about the filling. REALLY good, though a little salty. Be warned if you're watching sodium.”

    Rachel

    3 reviews and 48 orders
  • “Solid!”

    Annie

    10 reviews and 102 orders
  • “Excellent Tilapia Sandwich!! Also highly recommended is the yellow rice! ”

    Micah

    2 reviews and 52 orders
  • “came quickly, a little too greasy. ”

    Nicole

    11 reviews and 286 orders
  • “Food was a but cold. Need a warmer”

    Ariel

    1 reviews and 6 orders
  • “Never again!! I ordered from Grub When my order finally arrived (1/2 hour late), the food was ice cold! I ordered a cup of juice and the cup was broken at the bottom and leaked all over the bag. The potatoes tasted very old. When I called to inform them of the problem, the person on the phone didn't speak one word of english and couldn't put anyone on the phone to speak english - the guy kept repeating "Fax" "Fax."- I finally hung up and decided it was a learning lesson as a newbie to the neighborhood.”

    Lisa

    3 reviews and 9 orders
  • “I really wish I read reviews on other sites re: this place before ordering. I ordered a shrimp with rice soup--the soup came with no rice. When I called, they sent another soup, but then expected me to pay for the replacement. Plus, the delivery person got lost the second time--I said it was the same address as the first time, but they sent a second delivery person who was unfamilar with the delivery address, so it took an extra hour--(Im 6 blocks away from the store). There was also a lot of communications issues, as they have a lot of people working there but not a lot who speak english, so it was difficult to explain the problem. I think the main problem is that 1) they have too many people taking orders and delivering and 2) they dont have a lot of english speaking staff, so when there is a problem, its difficult to get through. ”

    DeAndrea

    3 reviews and 100 orders
  • “fish was perfectly fried. not greasy at all”

    Shirley

    2 reviews and 23 orders
  • “GREAT! food delivery was a little slow but the food was great.”

    candice

    1 reviews and 98 orders
  • “I was excited that this place delivered late at night but disappointed once my order arrived. I ordered the boiled salmon, french frieds, and fried sweet plantains. The salmon was packed in a full container of liquid - which got on everything. Once I removed the salmon and put it on a plate I realized that none of the pin bones had been removed. I'm not talking about a thin bone here or there, I mean none of them, including the spine. Maybe this was done to keep it from falling apart when boiling? I'm not sure, but I spent the next ten minutes picking a TON of bones out, which was not fun. After all that the salmon was ok. The fries were soggy and undercooked - or maybe they just seemed that way since they got drenched in salmon liquid on the way over. Who knows. The plantains were ok. I dont think I'd buy dinner from here again, but I'd consider the breakfast I guess.”

    david

    11 reviews and 304 orders
  • “It was OK. Nothing impressive or superb, but quite decent for an order made at 4 am. Salmon tasted nice and fresh and the delivery guy came in about just 15-20 minutes.”

    Iurii

    1 reviews and 9 orders
  • “I've been ordering from Calle for about a year now. They won me over with their ability to deliver quality eats late night. I loved them so much I recommended them to others. I'd have dated them if they were a real human. Then today it all went up in vapors. My order is late, cold, wrong and the delivery being was rude enough to try to withhold my food because he thought he deserved a 40% tip ( I tipped ~20% on my card before they delivered the cold and wrong shenanigans called food) . Grubhub has been really great at righting wrongs, but this wrong cannot be undone. Calle 191, your hobbit sized minion of Mephistopheles just cost you your reputation and loyal customer. Everyone in earshot will soon learn of how fishy you've truly become.”

    Naomi

    2 reviews and 62 orders
  • “very good the best place to get sea food”

    david

    2 reviews and 67 orders
  • “Their fish is amazing!! and the rice is pretty good too!”

    Estil

    2 reviews and 67 orders
  • “Very good food. The problem however is the person I spoke with didn't speak English at all. That is VITAL to gaining more customers in a predominantly English speaking country. ”

    Marcus

    1 reviews and 5 orders
  • “Good food, reasonable prices fast late night delivery!”

    Alexandra

    6 reviews and 34 orders
  • “shrimp patties and shrimp mofongo are good”

    Tony

    4 reviews and 605 orders
  • “Does the trick but is far from gourmet ”

    Kile

    2 reviews and 17 orders
  • “not amazing...the seafood was rice was super bland. but the sweet plantains were better!”

    Tanya

    1 reviews and 1 orders
  • “The food was delicious, one portion lasted two days.”

    Jose

    2 reviews and 1 orders
  • “I ordered breakfast and some traditional Dominican dishes from this place. Scrambled eggs with ham was okay. The eggs were not really scrambled, more like fried and slices of ham were burned. They ran out of chicken croquettes so the restaurant called me to see what else I would like instead. I didn't have a preference so I asked them to replace it with something with the same price and they did. They replaced it with a plate of steamed yucca with what looked like fish ceviche on top. The flavor was not bad but the fish tasted rubbery. I also had a side order of yucca so I am not sure why they decided to replace the chicken croquette with another yucca dish. Anyway, the yucca tasted okay, a bit dry and without too much flavor. I actually added olive oil and sprinkled some sea salt to make it taste better. Finally, fish soup was rich and tasty, both my hubby and I enjoyed it. I am not sure if I will order from this place again.”

    Noe

    13 reviews and 77 orders

Full Hours, Cuisines, More Info... Hide Extra Info

Close

St Nicholas Fish Market Delivery

Seafood, Soup, Late Night, Latin American, Lunch, Dinner

Hours

  • Monday 12:00 PM - 11:59 PM
  • Tuesday 9:00 AM - 4:00 AM
  • Wednesday 9:00 AM - 4:00 AM
  • Thursday 12:00 PM - 11:59 PM
  • Friday 12:00 PM - 11:59 PM
  • Saturday 12:00 PM - 11:59 PM
  • Sunday 12:00 PM - 11:59 PM

646-758-6277

1609 St Nicholas Ave New York, NY

Saturday

Open Now

12:00 PM - 11:59 PM

Delivery

Delivery Free

Minimum $ 10.00

Pickup

Show map