1. Search
  2. Pick a Restaurant
  3. Build Your Meal
  4. → Order & Eat!
  • Pay with a credit card, PayPal, or cash at the door.
  • Tip online.
  • 24/7 Customer Care.
  • Free to use.
  • Get text updates about your order.
  • Saves your payment info.
  • Remembers your special instructions.
  • Saves your addresses.

Brother Jimmy's BBQ isn't taking orders right now.

Brother Jimmy's BBQ Menu

  • Popular Items

    • BBQ Burger $14.00 Our half-pound custom blend, basted with chipotle BBQ sauce, cheddar cheese and topped with onion rings. Served with your choice of a side and pickles.
    • Popcorn Shrimp $10.50 Served with Cajun mayonnaise.
    • Hush Puppies $7.75 Served with maple butter.
    • Hot Wings $11.50
    • Fiji Bottled Water $3.00
    • Carolina Pulled Pork Platter $18.50 Pork shoulder, slow-smoked and pulled with Brother Jimmy's Carolina BBQ sauce. Smoked over hickory wood for five to twelve hours. Served with your choice of up to two sides, cornbread and pickles.
    • Southern-Style Ribs Platter $23.75 A half rack of St. Louis-style ribs. Smoked with Brother Jimmy`s Memphis-style rub. Smoked over hickory wood for five to twelve hours. Served with your choice of up to two sides, cornbread and pickles.
    • Macaroni and Cheese $5.75
    • Sliced Marbled Brisket Sandwich $14.00 Smoked over hickory wood for five to twelve hours. Served on a white bun, with your choice of a side and pickles. Subject to change due to market pricing.
    • Carolina Pulled Pork Sandwich $12.50 Smoked over hickory wood for five to twelve hours. Served on a white bun, with your choice of a side and pickles.
  • Beverages

    • Soda $3.25
    • Cheerwine Soda $3.50 A cherry flavored soda.
    • Fiji Bottled Water $3.00
    • Quart of Lemonade $5.25
    • Boylan Soda $3.50
    • Ginger Beer $3.50
    • Quart of Homemade Iced Tea $5.25
    • Quart of Raspberry Lemonade $5.25
  • Beginnings

    • Hush Puppies $7.75 Served with maple butter.
    • Fried Green Tomatoes $8.75 Served with spicy aioli.
    • Spinach and Artichoke Dip $10.75
    • 3 Jimmy's Minis $12.50
    • Brother Jimmy's BBQ Humongous Nachos $17.25 Chips, BBQ beans, cheese, sour cream, salsa and guacamole.
    • Bucket O' Hot Wings $21.00
    • Frickles $9.50 Served with horseradish sauce.
    • Popcorn Shrimp $10.50 Served with Cajun mayonnaise.
    • Quesadilla $11.00 Served with salsa and sour cream.
    • Chicken Fingers $11.50
    • Hot Wings $11.50
    • Warm Housemade Potato Chips $7.75
  • Salads

    • House Salad $7.50
    • Chopped Cobb Salad $14.75 Romaine lettuce, onions, tomatoes, bacon bits, crumbled blue cheese, avocado and chicken.
    • Jimmy's Wedge Salad $11.00 Iceberg lettuce, bacon bits, and diced tomato, covered with onion rings. Recommended with blue cheese dressing.
  • Sandwiches and Burgers

    • Fried Chicken Sandwich $11.75 Served on a white bun with your choice of a side and pickles.
    • BBQ Burger $14.00 Our half-pound custom blend, basted with chipotle BBQ sauce, cheddar cheese and topped with onion rings. Served with your choice of a side and pickles.
    • BBQ Grilled Chicken Sandwich $11.50 Basted with BBQ sauce, served with shredded lettuce, tomatoes and onions. Served with your choice of a side and pickles.
    • Jimmy's Burger $13.00 Our half pound custom blend burger grilled to perfection. Served with your choice of a side and pickles.
    • Turkey Burger $13.00 A big version of our mini with grilled onions and chipotle BBQ mayonnaise. Served with your choice of a side and pickles.
    • Blackened Catfish Sandwich $13.50 Served with avocado and tomato and topped with roasted tomato tartar sauce. Served with your choice of a side and pickles.
    • Portobello Mushroom Sandwich $12.00 Grilled portobellos with Swiss cheese and topped with onion rings and chipotle BBQ mayo. Served with your choice of a side and pickles.
    • Press'd Bourbon Brisket $13.50 Smoked Brisket with cheddar, onion rings, and our homemade bourbon bbq sauce.
  • BBQ Sandwiches

    • Carolina Pulled Pork Sandwich $12.50 Smoked over hickory wood for five to twelve hours. Served on a white bun, with your choice of a side and pickles.
    • Sliced Lean Brisket Sandwich $14.00 Smoked over hickory wood for five to twelve hours. Served on a white bun, with your choice of a side and pickles. Subject to change due to market pricing.
    • Pulled Chicken Sandwich $12.50 Smoked over hickory wood for five to twelve hours. Served on a white bun, with your choice of a side and pickles.
    • Sliced Marbled Brisket Sandwich $14.00 Smoked over hickory wood for five to twelve hours. Served on a white bun, with your choice of a side and pickles. Subject to change due to market pricing.
  • BBQ Platters

    • Northern-Style Ribs Platter $23.75 A half rack of St. Louis-style ribs. Smoked and then grilled with Brother Jimmy's original BBQ sauce. Smoked over hickory wood for five to twelve hours. Served with your choice of up to two sides, cornbread and pickles.
    • Carolina Pulled Pork Platter $18.50 Pork shoulder, slow-smoked and pulled with Brother Jimmy's Carolina BBQ sauce. Smoked over hickory wood for five to twelve hours. Served with your choice of up to two sides, cornbread and pickles.
    • Sliced Lean Brisket Platter $21.00 Smoked for up to twelve hours. Smoked over hickory wood for five to twelve hours. Served with your choice of up to two sides, cornbread and pickles. Subject to change due to market pricing.
    • Half BBQ Chicken Platter $17.25 Smoked, grilled and basted in Brother Jimmy's original BBQ sauce. Smoked over hickory wood for five to twelve hours. Served with your choice of up to two sides, cornbread and pickles.
    • Southern-Style Ribs Platter $23.75 A half rack of St. Louis-style ribs. Smoked with Brother Jimmy`s Memphis-style rub. Smoked over hickory wood for five to twelve hours. Served with your choice of up to two sides, cornbread and pickles.
    • Combo Rib Platter $24.75 Choose from our three styles of ribs, "lil" more than a half rack. Smoked over hickory wood for five to twelve hours. Served with your choice of up to two sides, cornbread and pickles.
    • Pulled Chicken Platter $16.75 Smoked and pulled with Brother Jimmy's original BBQ sauce. Smoked over hickory wood for five to twelve hours. Served with your choice of up to two sides, cornbread and pickles.
    • Sliced Marbled Brisket Platter $21.00 Smoked for up to twelve hours. Smoked over hickory wood for five to twelve hours. Served with your choice of up to two sides, cornbread and pickles. Subject to change due to market pricing.
    • Baby Back Ribs Platter $24.75 Smoked and finished on the grill with a sweet and tangy sauce. Served with your choice of up to two sides, cornbread and pickles.
  • Southern Specialties

    • Jimmy's Pig Out for Two $45.00 Choose any four items and any four sides.
    • Blackened Chicken Dinner $18.00 Dipped in our special blackening spice. Nice and spicy. Served with your choice of up to two sides, cornbread and pickles.
    • Fried Chicken Dinner $18.25 Tossed in our seasoned flour, then finished off with toasted garlic. Served with your choice of up to two sides, cornbread and pickles.
    • Blackened Catfish Dinner $21.00 A Southern seafood staple, with a kick to it. Served with your choice of up to two sides, cornbread and pickles.
    • Country Fried Steak with Gravy $20.00 Top round steak, tenerized and dredged in our seasoned flour, fried crisp, tender and topped with gravy.
  • BBQ Snacks

    • BBQ Minis $12.00 Choose any style.
    • BBQ Wings $12.00 Cut wings dusted with our southern rub, smoked and basted with our special sauce.
    • Rib Tips $11.00 Northern style.
    • Bucket O' Tips $19.50
  • Sides

    • Potato Salad $4.50
    • Hand Cut French Fries $4.50
    • Fried Okra $5.75
    • BBQ Baked Beans with Pulled Pork $5.00
    • Fried Brussels Sprouts $5.75
    • Coleslaw $4.50
    • Basket of Cornbread $5.00
    • Spiced String Beans $5.00
    • Mashed Potatoes with Gravy $5.00
    • Macaroni and Cheese $5.75
    • Collard Greens $5.75
    • Corn on the Cob $5.00
    • Sweet Potato Tots $4.50 With spicy ketchup.
    • Basket of Cornbread $5.00
    • Choose Four Sides $12.00

Brother Jimmy's BBQ isn't taking orders right now.

Brother Jimmy's BBQ Menu

109 Ratings

56 Reviews Hide Reviews

Close
Brother Jimmy's BBQ

Brother Jimmy's BBQ

GrubHub reviews in your neighborhood

  • “Terrible experience. They screwed up my order and then failed to change it or make restitution. ”

    Adam

    13 reviews and 0 orders
  • “This will be the last time i order from here!!! Despte special instructions written in CAPS and repeated at least 5 times. thay said NO PICKLES..NO PICKLES.. (since my wife is allergic to pickles..they packed them in anyway. The food took the full 60 min to arrive, was semi-cold even though they are just 3 streets away. I thought i would try it a second time but clearly they are either too stupid to read the instructions or simply don't care about their customers orders and just ignore their requests...So long Jimmy..”

    Donald

    1 reviews and 0 orders
  • “SO good! I love the fried chicken dinner. The mashed potatoes, collards, brussell sprouts, and te cornbread are amazing too. The pecan pie is the only decent dessert though.”

    MAREIKA

    10 reviews and 0 orders
  • “Ordered the Fried Chicken dinner, ribs, and chicken wings. All fantastic. Delivery quick, food was hot and fresh. ”

    luigi

    1 reviews and 0 orders
  • “Love the food, however they have messed up my order on several occasions. Once I ordered a salad and it came with grilled chicken instead of buffalo chicken (major difference in my opinion, the salad was virtually tasteless). Another occasion I ordered a salad that came with no dressing on the side (which I requested). They said they would bring it to me immediately, yet when I called again 20 minutes later they said that he hadn't left yet. They clearly did not feel the need to make me a priority after they had messed up my order. ”

    Eliza

    1 reviews and 0 orders
  • “The fried food is great, but the deserts are awful (the apple crumb pie is falsely advertised and would not have waisted $7 on the crap they sent me that did not have crumbs)”

    Sasha

    6 reviews and 0 orders
  • “It's good enough but the other bbq places are better.”

    Ellen

    2 reviews and 0 orders
  • “Have gotten my order wrong 3 times in a row (The BJ BBQ burger and BJ burger ring up the same to the kitchen so I end up receiving a burger topped with just a pile of bacon...). Also, I live only one block away and my food is always cold when it gets to the door - it would be pretty good if it was actually warm, and they never include condiments so you're left with saltless and ketchup free fries. ”

    Robert

    2 reviews and 0 orders
  • “Brother Jimmy's has generally good food but I really object to the 20.4% tip they impose for deliveries. I could understand a 10% tip because there is someone packing it all up & a delivery but there is no wait service per se, no 'how is everything?', zero restaurant experience ambiance. In fact, as I hit 'submit' for this order (that I'm currently waiting for), I recalled my last order where the items were not packaged well, condiments were missing and I was left wondering how the lack of TLC warranted the excessive tip. Beware seamless customers...the more you add, the higher that tip ...and it's obscene. I will not make this mistake again.”

    Tricia

    1 reviews and 0 orders
  • “delivery ripp off 20% you would think it would be here in under 90 minutes but over an hour and a half no food yet”

    steven

    2 reviews and 0 orders
  • “Completely bogus that they set a minimum tip percentage, especially with their overpriced food! I understand that the money goes to the delivery person, but unlike a server who takes care of me throughout my meal, the only thing this person does is deliver my food from point a to point b. I should be allowed to determine the tip percentage myself. I like to tip in cash when the food is delivered, based on the length of delivery time. ”

    William

    1 reviews and 0 orders
  • “Fried Chicken Dinner was phenomenal. Comes with cornbread PLUS a choice of two tasty sides. Will definitely be ordering from here again. Great menu, would probably order every item”

    Jon

    1 reviews and 0 orders
  • “Not only is the food good but they are environmentally conscious with how they package the takeout. No plastic except for the sauce and even that came in a "greenware" container. Very much appreciated! ”

    Christina

    2 reviews and 0 orders
  • “Great food for a great price... Could have been warmer upon delivery, but nothing a quick nuke in the microwave can't fix. Great comfort food. Highly recommended.”

    Stuart

    2 reviews and 0 orders
  • “The food is excellent, but they can take forever to deliver and wtf is with the new cardboard boxes and tiny sides? Go back to the decent sized sides, normal containers, and quicken the delivery so it's still hot when I eat it and I'd give it five stars.”

    Paul

    29 reviews and 0 orders
  • “Food was very good and the portions are generous ... tasty corn bread but I just didn't like it arrived all crumbled up...very fragile pieces ”

    Karina

    7 reviews and 0 orders
  • “The food was fabulous and on time as always.”

    Yarimel

    2 reviews and 0 orders
  • “food took over an hour and a half. burger was ok, fries were soggy, wings were good...shouldn't take that long to deliver food!”

    jill

    12 reviews and 133 orders
  • “What a mess! Sandwich same cold, bread was soggy and the the entire thing had fallen apart in the box. Maybe they should wrap the sandwich in foil or parchment paper instead of just throwing it inside of a large box. Very disappointing since I love to dine in there. Not ordering again for delivery. ”

    marlyn

    1 reviews and 0 orders
  • “Rapid service, but the ribs were dry and mealy. Parts were as tough as jerky. The hush puppies and corn bread were tasty, but the ribs seemed like they had been sitting around for days and reheated repeatedly.”

    Jeffrey

    2 reviews and 0 orders
  • “Very disappointing. Took over an hour to deliver, despite the fact that I live three short blocks away. Food was completely cold, although that was easy to fix by putting in the microwave. The fried chicken dinner had great texture (juicy chicken and crunchy coating) but had too little spices -- it just wasn't interesting. Heck, KFC does flavor a lot better. The "hot wings" weren't hot, probably because they didn't seem to have any sauce -- despite ordering "buffalo", they were totally dry. The collard greens were disgustingly overcooked and went straight into the garbage, the cornbread was gross because it was idiotically packed with pickles and tasted like pickles. The only really tasty thing was the fried brussels sprouts -- after I reheated them. If you want BBQ, I'd recommend nearby Blue Smoke (takeout only). If you want chicken, I was shocked to discover that Best Wingers is actually better, both for wings and chicken pieces.”

    Michael

    1 reviews and 0 orders
  • “Did not come with any gravy'!”

    Drusilla

    10 reviews and 0 orders
  • “We love brother jimmies. with a family, its great to go in person because they offer 'kids eat free'. but ordering via seamless is great too. I'd give them 5 stars if they would offer something other than a salad for someone on a diet. ”

    jeff

    5 reviews and 0 orders
  • “Horrendous. Receptionist Ashley is snide when I had to report that my order was incorrect, she lied when she told me a new, correct order would be sent, she lied 1/2 hour later when she said new, correct order was on its way (and then hung up on me) and after 2 hours when I called to find out where new corrected order was, she kept me on hold while supposedly fetching the manager, and then reported that it just left. Not the first time I have been through this with Brother Jimmy's--the exact opposite of the Seamless Web mission--but this is the last time I give Brother Jimmy's another chance. Go to Duke's. Their food is always correct and delicious, and their service is impeccable.”

    Cecily

    2 reviews and 0 orders
  • “Took an hour and a half to get my food. Food was cold and just meh. ”

    Christine

    3 reviews and 0 orders
  • “Worst Po Boy of my life. I was incredibly disappointed by this place. ”

    Will

    10 reviews and 0 orders
  • “I love ordering from here. My go-to is the half BBQ chicken. It never disappoints. The side of sweet potato fries are some of the best in the city and you get a lot of them - enough for two people. The mac and cheese side is hit or miss. Comes with bread crumbs and can be lumpy. I have had the BBQ chicken quesedilla at least a few times as well and love it. Plenty of cheddar cheese and sizable white meat pieces in a crispy tortilla. You can definitely make a meal out of that appetizer alone. Be prepared to wait a bit for your order though. In my opinion, it's worth it.”

    valerie

    1 reviews and 0 orders
  • “Before I ordered, I read the reviews and saw mixed feelings but I wanted this so bad I went and ordered anyway. I should have listened to the bad reviews! The food is not good, the mac and cheese was horrible and cold, the pulled pork sandwich was not hot and not tasty at all! Signed Disappointed”

    Nailah

    6 reviews and 0 orders
  • “Food was over an hour late, it was cold, french fries looked more like sloppy fries. They did not include any BBQ sauce. The food was dry and pretty tasteless. Will not order out from here again.”

    claudia

    1 reviews and 0 orders
  • “Not good at all. Ribs were dry! Oily hush puppies. Not value for money.”

    helena

    5 reviews and 0 orders

Full Hours, Cuisines, More Info... Hide Extra Info

Close

Brother Jimmy's BBQ Delivery

BBQ, Lunch Specials, Lunch, Dinner

Hours

  • Monday 11:30 AM - 10:00 PM
  • Tuesday 11:30 AM - 10:00 PM
  • Wednesday 11:30 AM - 10:00 PM
  • Thursday 11:30 AM - 10:00 PM
  • Friday 11:30 AM - 10:00 PM
  • Saturday 12:00 PM - 10:00 PM
  • Sunday 12:00 PM - 10:00 PM

917-444-7832

181 Lexington Ave New York, NY

Monday

Not taking orders at this time.

11:30 AM - 10:00 PM

Delivery

Delivery Free

Minimum $ 10.00

Pickup

Show map