1. Search
  2. Pick a Restaurant
  3. Build Your Meal
  4. → Order & Eat!
  • Pay with a credit card, PayPal, or cash at the door.
  • Tip online.
  • 24/7 Customer Care.
  • Free to use.
  • Get text updates about your order.
  • Saves your payment info.
  • Remembers your special instructions.
  • Saves your addresses.

Brother Jimmy's isn't taking orders right now.

Brother Jimmy's Menu

  • Popular Items

    • Popcorn Shrimp $10.50 Served with Cajun mayonnaise.
    • Chicken Fingers $10.50
    • Frickles $9.50 Served with horseradish sauce.
    • Hot Wings $11.50
    • Fried Chicken Dinner $18.25 Tossed in our seasoned flour, then finished off with toasted garlic.
    • Northern-Style Ribs Platter $23.75 Half rack of St. Louis-style ribs. Smoked and then grilled with Brother Jimmy's original BBQ sauce. Served with your choice of up to two sides, cornbread and pickles.
    • Carolina Pulled Pork Platter $18.50 Pork shoulder slow-smoked and pulled with Brother Jimmy's Carolina BBQ sauce. Served with your choice of up to two sides, cornbread and pickles.
    • Macaroni and Cheese $5.75
    • Carolina Pulled Pork Sandwich $12.50 Served on a white bun, with your choice of a side and pickles.
  • Beverages

    • Soda $3.25
    • Cheerwine Soda $3.25 A Carolina favorite since 1917.
    • Homemade Iced Tea $5.25 Sold by the quart because one cup is never enough.
    • Raspberry Lemonade $5.25 Sold by the quart because one cup is never enough.
    • Boylan Soda $3.50
    • Ginger Beer $3.50 Non alcoholic.
    • Lemonade $5.25 Sold by the quart because one cup is never enough.
  • Beginnings

    • Hush Puppies $7.75 Served with maple butter.
    • Popcorn Shrimp $10.50 Served with Cajun mayonnaise.
    • Chicken Fingers $10.50
    • Bucket o' Hot Wings $21.00
    • Warm Homemade Potato Chips $7.75 With Buffalo blue cheese dip.
    • Frickles $9.50 Served with horseradish sauce.
    • Brother Jimmy's BBQ Humongous Nachos $17.25 Chips, BBQ beans, cheese, sour cream, salsa and guacamole.
    • Quesadilla $11.00 Served with salsa and sour cream.
    • Hot Wings $11.50
    • Spinach and Artichoke Dip $10.75
  • BBQ Snacks

    • BBQ Wings $12.25 Cut wings, dusted with our Southern rub and basted with our ``special`` wing sauce.
    • Rib Tips $10.00 Northern-style.
    • Bucket O' Tips $18.50
    • Pulled Pork Minis $12.50
    • Pulled Chicken Minis $12.50
  • Salads

    • House Salad $7.50
    • Chopped Cobb Salad $14.75 Romaine lettuce, onions, tomatoes, bacon, crumbled blue cheese and avocado.
    • Jimmy's Wedge Salad $11.00 Iceberg lettuce, bacon bits and diced tomato smothered in blue cheese dressing and covered with onion rings.
  • BBQ Sandwiches

    • Carolina Pulled Pork Sandwich $12.50 Served on a white bun, with your choice of a side and pickles.
    • Sliced Marble Brisket Sandwich $14.00 Served on a white bun, with your choice of a side and pickles. Subject to change due to market pricing.
    • Pulled Chicken Sandwich $12.50 Served on a white bun, with your choice of a side and pickles.
  • BBQ Platters

    • Northern-Style Ribs Platter $23.75 Half rack of St. Louis-style ribs. Smoked and then grilled with Brother Jimmy's original BBQ sauce. Served with your choice of up to two sides, cornbread and pickles.
    • Combo Rib Platter $24.75 Choose from our two styles of ribs, lil more than a half rack. Served with your choice of up to two sides, cornbread and pickles.
    • Pulled Chicken Platter $16.75 Smoked and pulled with brother jimmy's original BBQ sauce. Served with your choice of up to two sides, cornbread and pickles.
    • Southern-style Ribs Platter $23.75 A half rack of St. Louis-style ribs. Smoked with Brother Jimmy's Memphis-style rub. Served with your choice of up to two sides, cornbread and pickles.
    • Carolina Pulled Pork Platter $18.50 Pork shoulder slow-smoked and pulled with Brother Jimmy's Carolina BBQ sauce. Served with your choice of up to two sides, cornbread and pickles.
    • Baby Back Ribs Platter $24.75 Smoked and finished on the grill with a sweet & tangy sauce.
    • Sliced Brisket Platter $21.00 Smoked for up to 12 hours. Subject to change due to market pricing.
    • 1/2 BBQ Chicken Platter $17.25 Smoked, grilled and basted in Brother Jimmy's Original BBQ Sauce.
  • Southern Fried Specialties

    • Blackened Catfish Dinner $20.00 A southern seafood staple, with a spicy kick to it.
    • Fried Chicken Dinner $18.25 Tossed in our seasoned flour, then finished off with toasted garlic.
    • Jimmy's Pig Pick for Two $45.00 Northern or Southern-style ribs, pulled pork, brisket and pulled chicken served with your choice of 4 sides.
    • Blackened Chicken $18.00 Dipped in our special blackening spice. Nice & spicy.
  • Sandwiches N Burgers

    • Blackened Catfish Sandwich $13.50 With roasted tomato tartar sauce served with avocado & tomato.
    • BBQ Grilled Chicken Sandwich $11.50 Basted with BBQ sauce, served with shredded lettuce, tomatoes and onions.
    • Fried Chicken Sandwich $11.75
    • BJ's Burger $13.00 Our half pound custom burger blend grilled to perfection.
    • BJ's Signature BBQ Burger $14.00 Our half pound custom blend basted with chipotle BBQ sauce, Cheddar & topped with onion rings.
    • Turkey Burger $13.00 Our custom turkey blend, with grilled onions and chipotle BBQ mayonnaise.
    • Portobello Burger $12.00 Grilled Portobellos with Swiss cheese and topped with onion rings and Chipotle BBQ mayo.
    • Press'd Bourbon Brisket Sandwich $13.50 Smoked Brisket with Cheddar, onion rings and our homemade Bourbon BBQ Sauce. Subject to change due to market pricing.
  • Family Meals

    • Ribs Family Meal $70.25 2 racks of ribs.
    • Chicken & Ribs Family Meal $60.25 1 rack of ribs and 1 whole chicken.
    • Chicken & Pork Family Meal $55.25 1 whole chicken and 1 lb. of pulled pork.
  • Sides

    • Coleslaw $4.50
    • Basket of Cornbread $4.50
    • Sweet Potato Tots $4.50
    • Spiced String Beans $5.00
    • Fried Brussels Sprouts $5.75
    • Macaroni and Cheese $5.75
    • Tater Tots $4.50
    • Mashed Potatoes with Gravy $5.00
    • BBQ Baked Beans and Pork $5.00
    • Collard Greens $5.75
    • Any 4 Sides $12.00
    • Potato Salad $4.50
    • Fried Okra $5.75
  • Desserts

    • Apple Crumb Pie $7.50
    • Fudge Brownie $3.00
    • Pecan Pie $7.00

Brother Jimmy's isn't taking orders right now.

Brother Jimmy's Menu

133 Ratings

"The turkey burger was amazing. The turkey burger was probably th … See more. "

67 Reviews Hide Reviews

Close
Brother Jimmy's

Brother Jimmy's

GrubHub reviews in your neighborhood

  • “Waited over an hour for my food and it was wrong! I will never order from Jimmy��s again”

    Liz

    2 reviews and 0 orders
  • “best takeout wings on the UWS. ”

    jed

    1 reviews and 0 orders
  • “Food was delicious, treated myself to a muchie craving for chicken tenders and french fries. Couldnt have picked a better place to get this from, 5 stars ”

    Michael

    1 reviews and 0 orders
  • “Solid bbq and good sides. Generous but not ridiculous portion sizes. Consistent delivery.”

    Kai

    5 reviews and 0 orders
  • “Excellent BBQ delivery (although its not the same as the best in the city). Great ribs and pulled pork. Fried brussel sprouts are amazing.”

    Brian

    8 reviews and 0 orders
  • “Love the food, but get ready to wait for it. It takes a while, but is worth it. Beware of anything that doesn't taste good warmed up... Food has been known to be room temp when delivered. Go for the ribs, BBQ chicken, brisket, BBQ beans, potato salad!”

    HILTON

    3 reviews and 0 orders
  • “Best BBQ in UWS. Recommend brisket and ribs w Hush Puppies. Being a native Texan and 30 year BBQ enthusiast and pitmaster-wannabe, this is just mediocre Q. For the real deal brisket needs to be smoked for 15 or so hours -- low and slow via indirect heat -- which just can't be done / vented in NYC. ”

    Roger

    1 reviews and 0 orders
  • “I'm one of the first to complain (and one of the reviews below was mine), so fair is fair. We decided to give Brother Jimmy's another chance and submitted an order. At the time we were submitting it, the delivery estimate given was 60 to 75 minutes. (That was revised and appeared as 30 to 45 on the confirmation, but of course we had already submitted the order at that point.) The order appeared at our door about 32 minutes from the moment I pressed "Send". It was complete and exactly as ordered, down to the extra barbeque sauce we requested. Brother Jimmy's scored on this one, no doubt about it,. ”

    Jeffrey

    2 reviews and 0 orders
  • “Awesome! Reminds me of home. ”

    Brianne

    2 reviews and 0 orders
  • “Food is usually 5 star AWESOME. This time I was a tad disappointed. The mac BARELY had any panko crumbs and was a bit lukewarm, the collard greens were VERY bland and the catfish was also bland and not really blackened the way it usually comes. May have been a rush job, but next time I'll eat in. Delivery isn't what it used to be of your favorite dishes. Sucks because my husband and I LOVE BJ's and we eat at this chain often.”

    Michella

    2 reviews and 102 orders
  • “Ran out of brisket on a Saturday afternoon...”

    DeNora

    1 reviews and 0 orders
  • “The turkey burger was amazing. The turkey burger was probably the best burger I've had in my life, turkey or otherwise. ”

    Janeen

    1 reviews and 47 orders
  • “I've been in the restaurant before and enjoyed the food, however it just wasn't great. I felt like it was really over priced. I got a great deal of food but it just didn't taste as expensive as it was. I'm from the Carolina's and the carolina pulled pork was less than par. On a good note, it was a fast delivery. I might be willing to try something new, but I'll never get the carolina pulled pork, and cole slaw again. In regards to their tea.... It isn't sweet.... Isn't this a southern place?”

    brittnye

    3 reviews and 0 orders
  • “Delivery is as bad as previous reviews suggest. It took us over an hour to get our order and it was still missing cornbread. We called and were told they would credit our card, which they have yet to do. The food was fine, but not worth the hassle.”

    katie

    1 reviews and 0 orders
  • “Had to call and cancel order after waiting 1 hour 15 mins. Told it was on its way when it was not. #HAANGRY”

    Lauren

    1 reviews and 0 orders
  • “These guys get my order wrong every other time, remarkable incompetent”

    Ryan

    1 reviews and 0 orders
  • “This place is garbage. Order was 1 hour late and then they didn't bring what I ordered. Defeats the entire purpose of seamless web when your order isn't correct. ”

    Anthony

    2 reviews and 0 orders
  • “Love the Chopped Cobb Salad and the Chicken Fingers are great. The soda is really over priced and sometimes the delivery takes a little longer than I'd like, but nothing crazy- I order from here pretty often.”

    Jessica

    2 reviews and 0 orders
  • “super long delivery times. bbq sauces are all thin, and vinegary. ”

    Mike

    3 reviews and 0 orders
  • “Food is good, but the sliders I ordered--- one was just a bun, no meat. On the upside my chicken fried steak was best I've had from BJ. ”

    maggie

    2 reviews and 0 orders
  • “Have had food here many times, and it was adequate food for what you paid. Since prices were raised drastically in mid 2009, the amount and quality of food you get is no longer a value. I won't order from here again.”

    Terri

    1 reviews and 0 orders
  • “I love their food and portion size.”

    Guillermo

    3 reviews and 0 orders
  • “there is nothing healthy about the veggies but they are oh so delicious! great comfort food.”

    Sharon

    2 reviews and 0 orders
  • “Apparently they actually birth the animal, raise it, celebrate it and then cook it as the food takes upwards of 1.5 hours to get here. My husband went from weighting 200 lbs to 187 in the time we waited. Fortunately the delivery man did not perish on his trek from the 6 blocks it took to get here because he ate half our fries. Lastly my husband now has a gluten allergy because the bread his sandwich was served on was from the Clinton Administration. ”

    magdalena

    1 reviews and 0 orders
  • “I love the Southern dinners, especially the blackened catfish. The spicy wings are also great. Wish they'd offer a pulled-chicken platter, instead of just a sandwich, but a great menu, if a little on the pricey side.”

    Troy

    1 reviews and 0 orders
  • “Took over an hour to get here”

    Rachel

    1 reviews and 0 orders
  • “Took forever to confirm the order in the first place, so seamless called me and said they were going to cancel my order, but then they finally confirmed the order and delivered cold food 50 minutes later. They left out half of my order and I know calling them to fix it wouldn't be worth it. The food is good, and as someone who is an actual resident of North Carolina, it's actually decent Carolina barbeque. They really shouldn't deliver if they can't handle it, people would still go there to eat in. If they say they will deliver, then they should actually do it.”

    Wei

    3 reviews and 0 orders
  • “Amazing fried chicken. Rest is uneven and greasy.”

    laurie

    23 reviews and 0 orders
  • “Same great taste as you experience at their locations delivery time was as stated, food delivered warm”

    Glenn

    2 reviews and 0 orders
  • “Review takes a while. Buffalo chicken fingers make it worthwhile, though!”

    Jonathan

    6 reviews and 0 orders

Full Hours, Cuisines, More Info... Hide Extra Info

Close

Brother Jimmy's Delivery

BBQ, Dinner, Southern

Hours

  • Monday 4:00 PM - 10:00 PM
  • Tuesday 4:00 PM - 10:00 PM
  • Wednesday 4:00 PM - 10:00 PM
  • Thursday 4:00 PM - 10:00 PM
  • Friday 4:00 PM - 10:00 PM
  • Saturday 11:30 AM - 10:00 PM
  • Sunday 11:30 AM - 10:00 PM

9179628307

428 Amsterdam Ave New York, NY

Sunday

Not taking orders at this time.

11:30 AM - 10:00 PM

Delivery

Delivery FREE - $5.00 depending on your location

Minimum $ 10.00

Pickup

No Pickup Why not?

Pickup not available

Brother Jimmy's doesn't offer pickup through us.

Show map