1. Search
  2. Pick a Restaurant
  3. Build Your Meal
  4. → Order & Eat!
  • Pay with a credit card, PayPal, or cash at the door.
  • Tip online.
  • 24/7 Customer Care.
  • Free to use.
  • Get text updates about your order.
  • Saves your payment info.
  • Remembers your special instructions.
  • Saves your addresses.

Papa Romeo's Pizza isn't taking orders right now.

Papa Romeo's Pizza Menu

  • Popular Items

    • Large 14'' Thin and Crispy Cheese Pizza $15.99
    • Small 10'' Thin and Crispy Cheese Pizza $8.99
    • Cheesebread $8.99+ Our Famous "Chicago Style" cheesy bread, piled high with the best cheese in town! Comes with a side of our pizza sauce.
    • Jalapeno Poppers $6.99 Six pieces comes with marinara sauce
    • Mozzarella Sticks $8.99 Eight cheesy baked mozzarella sticks and a side of our pizza sauce.
    • 24 oz Soda $1.99
    • Medium 12'' Original Hand Tossed Cheese Pizza $13.99
    • Large 14'' Original Hand Tossed Cheese Pizza $15.99
    • Extra Large 16'' Original Hand Tossed Cheese Pizza $17.99
    • Hot Fudge Brownie Bites (10 piece) $6.99 10 hot fudge brownie bites, fresh out of the oven and sure to disappear fast! Served with chocolate dipping sauce.
  • Menu Coupons

    • Large Veggie Pizza and 16 piece Cheesey Bread $31.99
    • Large Super Combo Pizza and 10 piece Buffalo Wings $35.99
  • Beverages

    • Can of Soda $0.99
    • 24 oz Soda $1.99
    • Bottled Water $1.69
    • Apple Juice $2.49
    • Orange Juice $2.49
    • Orange Gatorade $2.49
    • 2 Liter Diet Pepsi $2.99
  • Gyros

    • Gyro Combo $8.99 Gyro Combo comes with Gyro fries and your choice of a drink.
    • Gyro $6.99
  • Sides and Appetizers

    • Cheesebread $8.99+ Our Famous "Chicago Style" cheesy bread, piled high with the best cheese in town! Comes with a side of our pizza sauce.
    • Twisty Breadsticks $4.99 Eight pieces of our signature Twisty breadsticks - warm and soft inside with a delicate crisp crust. Comes with a side of pizza sauce and garlic sauce.
    • Large Order Cajun Spicy Fries $4.99
    • Garlic Bread $5.99 A half foot of our mouthwatering garlic bread.
    • Mozzarella Sticks $8.99 Eight cheesy baked mozzarella sticks and a side of our pizza sauce.
    • Onion Rings $3.99
    • Jalapeno Poppers $6.99 Six pieces comes with marinara sauce
    • Side of Garlic Sauce $0.99
    • Side of Ranch $0.99
    • Side of Blue Cheese $0.99
    • Side of Italian $0.99
    • Side Caesar $0.99
    • Side of Marinara Sauce $0.99
    • Large Order Cheese Fries $5.99
    • Cheese sauce $0.99
  • Fresh Salads

    • Caesar Salad $5.99+ Romaine lettuce, shredded red cabbage, carrots, cucumbers, croutons and Parmesan.
    • Small Garden Salad $5.99 Fresh tomatoes and cucumbers, black olives and croutons over a bed of crisp romaine lettuce.
    • Regular Garden Salad $7.99 Fresh tomatoes and cucumbers, black olives and croutons over a bed of crisp romaine lettuce.
  • Specialty Pizzas [Deep Dish only comes in Medium or Large]

    • BBQ Chicken Pizza $14.99+ Tender, grilled, premium white meat chicken over mouth -watering bbq sauce topped with cheese.
    • Italian Margherita Pizza $14.99+ Extra cheese and sliced ripe tomatoes on our famous garlic butter sauce, topped with fresh-picked basil.
    • Cheesy Beef Pizza $14.99+ Finely sliced Italian beef smothered in extra cheese.
    • Hawaiian Fiesta Pizza $14.99+ Juicy bits of pineapple and finely sliced ham topped with cheese.
    • Super Combo Pizza $19.99+ A feast of toppings! Sausage, pepperoni, mushrooms, onions, green peppers, ham, and ripe black olives.
    • Junior Combo Pizza $17.99+ A lighter version of our classic. Sausage, pepperoni, mushrooms, onions and green peppers.
    • Vegetarian Combo Pizzas $17.99+ No meats here! Mushroom, onion, green pepper, and ripe black olives topped with cheese.
    • Meat Combo Pizza $18.99+ Tired of the greens? Loaded with all your favorites: Sausage, pepperoni, ham, and ground beef.
    • Italian Spicy Supreme Veggie Pizza $23.99+
  • Original Hand Tossed Pizza

    • Small 10'' Original Hand Tossed Cheese Pizza $11.99
    • Medium 12'' Original Hand Tossed Cheese Pizza $13.99
    • Large 14'' Original Hand Tossed Cheese Pizza $15.99
    • Extra Large 16'' Original Hand Tossed Cheese Pizza $17.99
    • Giant Size Original Hand Tossed Cheese Pizza $29.99
  • Thin and Crispy Pizza

    • Small 10'' Thin and Crispy Cheese Pizza $8.99
    • Medium 12'' Thin and Crispy Cheese Pizza $13.99
    • Large 14'' Thin and Crispy Cheese Pizza $15.99
    • Extra Large 16'' Thin and Crispy Cheese Pizza $17.99
    • Giant 22" Thin and Crispy Cheese Pizza $29.99
  • Pan Pizza

    • Medium 12'' Pan Cheese Pizza $14.99
    • Large 14'' Pan Cheese Pizza $17.99
  • Deep Dish Pizza

    • Medium Deep Dish Pizza $16.99
    • Large Deep Dish Pizza $18.99
  • Gourmet Sandwiches

    • Meatball Marinara Sandwich $6.99
    • Italian Sausage Sandwich $6.99
    • Sausage and Beef Combo Sandwich $9.99
    • Chicken Sandwich $7.99
    • BBQ Beef Sandwich $7.99
    • Turkey Sandwich $6.99
    • Fish Sandwich $8.99 With Fries and Coke
  • Chicken, Ribs, & Seafood Specials

    • 5 Piece Buffalo Wings $6.99 Choice of sauce. Served with crisp celery sticks and bleu cheese.
    • 10 Piece Buffalo Wings $10.99 Choice of sauce. Served with crisp celery sticks and bleu cheese.
    • 10 Piece Cajun Spicy Wings $12.99 Choice of sauce. Served with crisp celery sticks and bleu cheese.
    • 20 Piece Buffalo Wings $19.99 Choice of sauce. Served with crisp celery sticks and bleu cheese.
    • 30 Piece Buffalo Wings $29.99 Choice of sauce. Served with crisp celery sticks and bleu cheese.
    • 5 Piece Boneless Chicken Bites $4.99 Breaded all white meat chicken served with your choice of one sauce.
    • 10 Piece Boneless Chicken Bites $8.99 Breaded all white meat chicken served with your choice of one sauce.
    • 20 Piece Boneless Chicken Bites $16.99 Breaded all white meat chicken served with your choice of one sauce.
    • 30 Piece Boneless Chicken Bites $26.99 Breaded all white meat chicken served with your choice of one sauce.
    • Buffalo Shrimp A La Carte $9.99 A full 1/2 pound of breaded buffalo shrimp, served with cocktail sauce.
    • Buffalo Shrimp Dinner $13.99 A full 1/2 pound of breaded buffalo shrimp, served with cocktail sauce. Served with fries, coleslaw, and garlic bread.
    • Season Roasted Chicken $15.99 Whole roasted chicken.
    • Chicken Tikka Meal $7.99 Spicy Chicken Tikka Breast. Served with fries, raita, and a coke.
    • Salmon Fish Combo Dinner $12.99 2 pieces of Salmon Fish. Served with fries & soda (Coke only)
    • Breaded Tilapia Fish Dinner $9.99 2 pieces of Tilapia Fish, Served with Fries and Soda (Coke only)
    • Full Slab B-Que Ribs $22.99 Served with cole slaw, fries, and two pieces of sweet corn.
  • Desserts

    • Cheesecake $2.49 Have a slice of Eli's legendary cheesecake. Available in original or flavor of the month.
    • Tiramisu $5.99 The classic heavenly Italian dessert.
    • Hot Fudge Brownie Bites (10 piece) $6.99 10 hot fudge brownie bites, fresh out of the oven and sure to disappear fast! Served with chocolate dipping sauce.
    • Cream Puffs (10 pieces) $5.99
    • Cinnamon Sticks $5.99
    • Miniature Cheesecake $8.99
    • Cherry Pie Pizza $11.99+
    • Cannoli $4.99
    • Buttered Banana foster bites $7.99 10 piece

Papa Romeo's Pizza isn't taking orders right now.

Papa Romeo's Pizza Menu

151 Ratings

"Quality pizza! It got it pretty late and it still tasted awesome! … See more. "

47 Reviews Hide Reviews

Close
Papa Romeo's Pizza

Papa Romeo's Pizza

GrubHub reviews in your neighborhood

  • “Quality pizza! It got it pretty late and it still tasted awesome!”

    Shelli

    1 reviews and 57 orders
  • “Food arrived late and cold.”

    Aliza

    1 reviews and 12 orders
  • “1 Large 14'' Original Hand Tossed Cheese Pizza $ 24.24 MY order above, but have ordered from here numerous times. Its the best of the commercial pizza places in my opinion. Have been getting tired of Grubhub service lately and have been ordering direct. About $11.00 cheaper for the order above for picking up the phone and speaking with someone. I have about 140 orders under my account in a short period of time, not the account you want to piss off people!”

    Michael

    34 reviews and 403 orders
  • “fast good late night pizza”

    Stephanie

    1 reviews and 541 orders
  • “The food was horrible the driver was rude would never order from there again . Worst food ever ”

    NITA

    1 reviews and 92 orders
  • “Really hit the spot. Grilled chicken was awesome”

    Noorjhan

    11 reviews and 354 orders
  • “Maybe it was just too far away ... but the order took over two hours to arrive, was cold, was wrong and was missing items. After two hours I was not going to wait longer for them to correct it. I think if the food would have arrived warm, it would probably have been average to pretty good ... hard to tell when its congealed and cold though. Could have just been a bad night for them, but I wont risk it again for the high price for dive food and crazy wait.”

    Gretchen

    5 reviews and 153 orders
  • “The food turned up nearly 50 minutes late and two of the four items we bought and paid for did not come at all! That said, the pizza was AMAZING!”

    Alisdair

    6 reviews and 51 orders
  • “Love the crust.”

    Leon

    1 reviews and 2 orders
  • “The fried shrimp were raw. Instead of the tiramisu we received freezer burned cheesecake. The fries were missing from one order. And to add insult to injury the delivery person stuck our order sticker to our mailbox we are still trying to scrape it off. Needless to say... We will never order from here again. ”

    Dawn

    2 reviews and 82 orders
  • “It was pretty good for late late night food. ”

    Graeme

    1 reviews and 192 orders
  • “It was horrible”

    Yara

    1 reviews and 38 orders
  • “Got the wrong order for out-of-town guests, then couldn't get anyone on chat or on the phone to remedy the situation. Due to food allergies, had to throw away the wrong pizza.”

    misty

    4 reviews and 580 orders
  • “Got here cold, overpriced, I got a thin crust and I think their dough is not my style. But they are open on Christmas so that's a plus. Don't think ill order from here again though.”

    David

    5 reviews and 116 orders
  • “My co-workers and I loved the pizza and promptness of delivery!! ”

    melissa

    1 reviews and 51 orders
  • “Terrible. Mozz sticks and Buffalo wings packaged together in the same box? It boggles the mind. The driver was clearly lost in what he was doing. Never again. Food was sub par so not even worth trying.”

    Ahren

    1 reviews and 70 orders
  • “Delivery was very fast. Hand-tossed pizza was great.”

    David

    3 reviews and 93 orders
  • “Deep dish is NOT a deep dish pizza. Looks exactly just like a Dominos/Pizza hut pan pizza. It was good, but very small, and too expensive for a pan sized pizza. Boo! I asked for garlic sauce and the delivery guy forgot it. and exited the door while I was asking him about it. He just hurried out wth!”

    Gino Paul

    3 reviews and 1 orders
  • “Fast and courteous deliver as always.”

    Adam

    6 reviews and 816 orders
  • “super fast delivery, like 20 minutes faster than predicted. i'm not a picky eater, but i must say the crust of the pizza wasn't that good and the pizza could've used more taste. i'm so happy they deliver past 3 AM though.”

    Gian

    2 reviews and 46 orders
  • “Great pizza! They got the order wrong but it was late Friday night and obviously busy. Still, you should ask them to double check the order. I'll likely order from them again anyway. ”

    Sarah

    3 reviews and 90 orders
  • “Delivery was slow. Pizza was ok. Charging $1.50 per topping is a ripoff.”

    Michael

    13 reviews and 85 orders
  • “I've ordered from them 4 or 5 times now and they've never gotten the order right. The deliverers are also rude ... I asked if the ranch I ordered was inside, and he said they didn't have ranch, only bleu cheese. He shrugged his shoulders and then left.”

    Paul

    1 reviews and 141 orders
  • “Great pizza. Just how I like it.”

    Ali

    3 reviews and 34 orders
  • “Fast delivery great pizza!”

    olga

    1 reviews and 1 orders
  • “Good, not great pizza. But at 11:30 on a weeknight when you need a pizza and very little else is open, it works!”

    Jim

    1 reviews and 2 orders
  • “Food was good as always. Delivery took a while.”

    Mallory

    3 reviews and 7 orders
  • “*1 star for: After order & $amount was confirmed, a 2nd e-mail was sent saying the total was more because of additional pizza toppings. Could that not have been calculated at time of order? ****4stars for food. Excellent pizzza!”

    Arlen Music

    1 reviews and 1 orders
  • “I could have made my own pizza dough in the time it took for them to deliver. When I called to check on the status of my order (twice) the very unhelpful woman told me 'its on its way' without actually asking my name or what I ordered.”

    Ann

    2 reviews and 17 orders
  • “I miss picking up a giant order of twisty breadsticks AND/OR cheeeeesy breadsticks and not being able to wait until we got it home...... we would devour half of it in the car before I could even drive out of the parking lot! (i miss the chairs too)”

    Max

    2 reviews and 5 orders

3 Coupons Hide Coupons

Close
Papa Romeo's Pizza

GrubHub Coupons

You'll be able to apply a coupon once you've started your order.

Just a heads up - some special offers are only available on certain days and times.

  • Large Super Combo Pizza and 10 piece Buffalo Wings
  • Large Veggie Pizza and 16 piece Cheesey Bread
  • Receive free garlic bread with any purchase of $30 or more.

Full Hours, Cuisines, More Info... Hide Extra Info

Close

Papa Romeo's Pizza Delivery

Pizza, Sandwiches, Italian, Lunch, Dinner

#1 Award Winning Pizza in 2012. Papa Romeo's only uses the highest quality ingredients.

Hours

  • Monday 4:00 PM - 5:00 AM
  • Tuesday 4:00 PM - 5:00 AM
  • Wednesday 4:00 PM - 5:00 AM
  • Thursday 4:00 PM - 5:00 AM
  • Friday 4:00 PM - 5:00 AM
  • Saturday 4:00 PM - 5:00 AM
  • Sunday 4:00 PM - 5:00 AM

2243530825

1168 Dodge Ave Evanston, IL

Sunday

Not taking orders at this time.

4:00 PM - 5:00 AM

Delivery

Delivery $4.00

Minimum $ 15.00

Pickup

Show map