1. The Baked Tomato

    Starts taking orders at 11:00 AM

    Pizza, Sandwiches…

    Delivery $2.00

    Minimum $15.00

The Baked Tomato

773-966-1284 | 4358 N Elston Ave, Chicago, IL
Add to Favorites

Our Rating

Yelp's Rating

21 Yelp! Reviews

Free online ordering

Click an item to order.

Starts Taking Orders at 11:00 AM

Popular Items
Appetizers/Sides
Sandwiches
Dinners
Thin Crust Pizza
Stuffed and Pan Pizza
BBQ

Add A Review
Sort reviews by
  • Order placed on 2.12.11.
    Mick

    16 Reviews  |  202 Orders

    Estimated delivery 45 minutes. After 90 minutes finally got phone call from driver who couldn't find us. We are on the EXACT SAME MAIN STREET as this restaurant!! and less than a mile or so away! 25 minutes after the call, we still not get delivery and had to contact Grub Hub and cancel and kids had to starve the night as we had to leave.. Ridiculous and pathetic service.

    and die

    12 Reviews  |  63 Orders

    This place can not still be in business? This is the most disgusting place ever. Your pizza might actually be made by the drug addict delivery guy if the chef decided to rest his hangover. I am not lieing one bit that, my pizza came with 5 holes in the crust because it wasnt rolled out propery.. was 1" thich in some spots or paper thin on the others. I ordered something like a supreme, and there must have been 3 whole green peppers quartered and put on top. Not lying one bit.. Should be shut down and thrown in jail I will add info to person who talks about ordering in the past.. This place was called Aiellos I believe before he sold it.. Which might have been where you got your "GOOD" pie from.. Stay away now

  • Order placed on 10.26.11.
    Brian

    6 Reviews  |  285 Orders

    Ordered here for the first time the other night. Service was pretty fast too. Under 45 minutes. We ordered wings and a pepperoni pizza. The wings were nice and hot. The pizza was fantastic. The crust was amazingly crisp;even through the middle of the pizza. Will definitely be ordering from there again!

  • Order placed on 8.22.10.
    Cristy

    8 Reviews  |  21 Orders

    We ordered a sausage and mushroom stuffed pizza, mozzarella sticks, and a side salad. The pizza was wonderful, however, the mozzarella sticks were a bit undercooked...or they had sat out too long after cooking. They were kinda soggy and flopped over when you tried to pick one up. We were told that our food would be there in 50 minutes, but it really took an hour and 20 minutes to arrive. All in all, we would order from here again because we really liked their stuffed pizza, but there are a couple drawbacks.

  • Order placed on 4.10.10.
    andrew

    4 Reviews  |  171 Orders

    Pizza is good, but i've order here 3 times and they've gotten the order wrong twice. i order the pan pizza and twice i've waited 45 mins to an hour to find that its a thin crust when it arrives. they send me another pizza everytime but its annoying not getting what you order. perk is i get two pizzas for the price of one. bad business model.

The Baked Tomato Delivery

Pizza , Sandwiches , Italian , American

Order Minimum

$15.00

Delivery Fee

$2.00

Hours

Sun
  1. 12:00 PM - 11:00 PM
Mon
  1. 4:00 PM - 11:00 PM
Tue
  1. 11:00 AM - 11:00 PM
Wed
  1. 11:00 AM - 11:00 PM
Thu
  1. 11:00 AM - 11:00 PM
Fri
  1. 11:00 AM - 1:00 AM
Sat
  1. 11:00 AM - 1:00 AM
Map
See a discrepancy? Click here to report it.

Internet Explorer 6, eh? Sadly, we can no longer support your outdated internet cruiser.

Why? Because it's old. Older than the iPod, older than Windows XP, even older than East Timor. So we're pulling the plug, and some site features might not work for you. Switch over to Firefox, Google Chrome, or the latest version of IE.

Sadly, we're no longer supporting IE7.

Why? It's old, and it just can't keep up with us anymore so we're pulling the plug. This means some site features might not work for you anymore. We recommend taking a look at Firefox, Google Chrome, or the latest version of IE.