1. Pie-Eyed Pizzeria

    Pizza, Sandwiches…

    Delivery $2.50

    Minimum $15.00

Pie-Eyed Pizzeria

312-929-1218 | 1111 W Chicago Ave, Chicago, IL

Our Rating

Yelp's Rating

56 Yelp! Reviews

Free online ordering

Click an item to order.

Popular Items
Beverages
Appetizers
Salads
Sandwiches
Fried Shrimp
Wings
Thin Crust Pizza
Chicago Style Pan Pizza
Gourmet Pizza
Calzone
Dessert

Add A Review
Sort reviews by
  • Order placed on 9.24.10.
    David

    25 Reviews  |  196 Orders

    Decent version of NY style thin. Need less sweet and less tangy sauce though. Needs to be more tomato-ee fresh and not as strongly sweet.

  • Order placed on 2.5.12.
    Kate

    3 Reviews  |  29 Orders

    I love this place! Tastiest sauce in the city and a good selection of toppings. Yummy!

  • Angie

    11 Reviews  |  73 Orders

    Delivery is way too long. It took about an hour to receive 1 pizza and I only live 1/2 mile away. I requested a thin crust, and although what I received was pretty good, it isn't what they say it is. The sauce is way to thick, too much. The crust is just plain boring, and it is more of a medium, hand-tossed crust. If anyone knows of a super thin crust, almost wafer-thin pizza in chicago, please let me know.

  • devon

    8 Reviews  |  40 Orders

    The pizza wasn't bad actually. It was really good the second day re heated crispy. If you like your pizza crispy ask for it extra done.

  • Order placed on 1.1.12.
    Randall

    6 Reviews  |  25 Orders

    it's just not very good pizza. we got Chicago style, and the crust was hard, the sauce too sweet (though it was plentiful), and the toppings too few. there are far too many other good options for pizza around to bother with this one. appetizer sampler was pretty good, still hot & crispy when delivered, which is unusual for any delivery spot.

Pie-Eyed Pizzeria Delivery

Pizza , Sandwiches , Italian , Late Night

Pie-Eyed Pizzeria Coupons

Click coupons to see full details

$2.25 Off

$1.75 Off

Order Minimum

$15.00

Delivery Fee

$2.50

Hours

Sun
  1. 5:00 PM - 10:00 PM
Mon
  1. 11:00 AM - 11:30 PM
Tue
  1. 11:00 AM - 11:30 PM
Wed
  1. 11:00 AM - 11:30 PM
Thu
  1. 11:00 AM - 11:30 PM
Fri
  1. 11:00 AM - 4:00 AM
Sat
  1. 6:00 PM - 4:00 AM
Map
See a discrepancy? Click here to report it.

Internet Explorer 6, eh? Sadly, we can no longer support your outdated internet cruiser.

Why? Because it's old. Older than the iPod, older than Windows XP, even older than East Timor. So we're pulling the plug, and some site features might not work for you. Switch over to Firefox, Google Chrome, or the latest version of IE.

Sadly, we're no longer supporting IE7.

Why? It's old, and it just can't keep up with us anymore so we're pulling the plug. This means some site features might not work for you anymore. We recommend taking a look at Firefox, Google Chrome, or the latest version of IE.